Optimal Differentially Private Model Training with Public Data
0
📈
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Differential privacy (DP) ensures that training a machine learning model does not leak private data.
- In practice, we may have access to auxiliary public data that is free of privacy concerns.
- This paper addresses two fundamental questions:
- What is the optimal error of a DP model trained over private data while having access to public data?
- How can we use public data to improve DP model training in practice?
Plain English Explanation
Differential privacy is a way to train machine learning models without revealing private information about the data used to train the model. In real-world situations, we may have access to additional public data that is not private. This paper explores how to best use this public data to improve the performance of differentially private models.
The researchers first determine the theoretical best-case performance of differentially private models that can use public data. They prove mathematical limits on how accurate these models can be, both for simple tasks like estimating the average of a dataset and more complex tasks like optimization problems.
The researchers then develop new algorithms that can practically use public data to train differentially private models. These algorithms perform even better than the theoretical limits, getting closer to the performance of models trained on public data alone. For example, their algorithm for estimating the average under local differential privacy is optimal, including the constants.
Overall, this work provides a deeper understanding of the potential and limitations of using public data to improve differentially private machine learning, along with new practical techniques to realize those benefits.
Technical Explanation
The paper studies the problem of training differentially private (DP) machine learning models when some public data is available. The authors consider both the local and central models of pure and approximate DP.
To understand the best-case performance, the paper proves tight (up to log factors) lower and upper bounds on the optimal error rates for three fundamental problems: mean estimation, empirical risk minimization, and stochastic convex optimization. These bounds show that the optimal error can be achieved either by discarding the private data and training a model on the public data alone, or by treating the public data as private and using an optimal DP algorithm.
Building on these insights, the authors develop novel DP algorithms that outperform the asymptotically optimal approaches described above. For local DP mean estimation, their algorithm is optimal including the constants. Empirically, these algorithms demonstrate benefits over the state-of-the-art.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough theoretical and practical treatment of leveraging public data to improve differentially private model training. The tight bounds and new algorithms represent significant advancements in the field.
However, the analysis is primarily focused on fundamental statistical problems like mean estimation and convex optimization. While these serve as important building blocks, it would be valuable to see how the insights translate to more complex, real-world machine learning tasks.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss potential limitations or risks of relying on public data. There may be concerns about the quality, representativeness, or unintended biases in the public data that could negatively impact the trained models. Further research is needed to understand these tradeoffs.
Conclusion
This work makes important progress in understanding the optimal performance and practical techniques for training differentially private models with access to public data. The theoretical bounds and new algorithms provide a solid foundation for further research and development in this area.
As differentially private machine learning becomes more widely adopted, the ability to leverage public data while preserving privacy will be crucial. This paper represents a significant step forward in realizing the full potential of DP in real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
0
Optimal Differentially Private Model Training with Public Data
Andrew Lowy, Zeman Li, Tianjian Huang, Meisam Razaviyayn
Differential privacy (DP) ensures that training a machine learning model does not leak private data. In practice, we may have access to auxiliary public data that is free of privacy concerns. In this work, we assume access to a given amount of public data and settle the following fundamental open questions: 1. What is the optimal (worst-case) error of a DP model trained over a private data set while having access to side public data? 2. How can we harness public data to improve DP model training in practice? We consider these questions in both the local and central models of pure and approximate DP. To answer the first question, we prove tight (up to log factors) lower and upper bounds that characterize the optimal error rates of three fundamental problems: mean estimation, empirical risk minimization, and stochastic convex optimization. We show that the optimal error rates can be attained (up to log factors) by either discarding private data and training a public model, or treating public data like it is private and using an optimal DP algorithm. To address the second question, we develop novel algorithms that are even more optimal (i.e. better constants) than the asymptotically optimal approaches described above. For local DP mean estimation, our algorithm is optimal including constants. Empirically, our algorithms show benefits over the state-of-the-art.
Read more9/11/2024
🏷️
0
Optimal Locally Private Nonparametric Classification with Public Data
Yuheng Ma, Hanfang Yang
In this work, we investigate the problem of public data assisted non-interactive Local Differentially Private (LDP) learning with a focus on non-parametric classification. Under the posterior drift assumption, we for the first time derive the mini-max optimal convergence rate with LDP constraint. Then, we present a novel approach, the locally differentially private classification tree, which attains the mini-max optimal convergence rate. Furthermore, we design a data-driven pruning procedure that avoids parameter tuning and provides a fast converging estimator. Comprehensive experiments conducted on synthetic and real data sets show the superior performance of our proposed methods. Both our theoretical and experimental findings demonstrate the effectiveness of public data compared to private data, which leads to practical suggestions for prioritizing non-private data collection.
Read more6/4/2024
0
Too Good to be True? Turn Any Model Differentially Private With DP-Weights
David Zagardo
Imagine training a machine learning model with Differentially Private Stochastic Gradient Descent (DP-SGD), only to discover post-training that the noise level was either too high, crippling your model's utility, or too low, compromising privacy. The dreaded realization hits: you must start the lengthy training process from scratch. But what if you could avoid this retraining nightmare? In this study, we introduce a groundbreaking approach (to our knowledge) that applies differential privacy noise to the model's weights after training. We offer a comprehensive mathematical proof for this novel approach's privacy bounds, use formal methods to validate its privacy guarantees, and empirically evaluate its effectiveness using membership inference attacks and performance evaluations. This method allows for a single training run, followed by post-hoc noise adjustments to achieve optimal privacy-utility trade-offs. We compare this novel fine-tuned model (DP-Weights model) to a traditional DP-SGD model, demonstrating that our approach yields statistically similar performance and privacy guarantees. Our results validate the efficacy of post-training noise application, promising significant time savings and flexibility in fine-tuning differential privacy parameters, making it a practical alternative for deploying differentially private models in real-world scenarios.
Read more7/1/2024
🔄
0
Beyond the Mean: Differentially Private Prototypes for Private Transfer Learning
Dariush Wahdany, Matthew Jagielski, Adam Dziedzic, Franziska Boenisch
Machine learning (ML) models have been shown to leak private information from their training datasets. Differential Privacy (DP), typically implemented through the differential private stochastic gradient descent algorithm (DP-SGD), has become the standard solution to bound leakage from the models. Despite recent improvements, DP-SGD-based approaches for private learning still usually struggle in the high privacy ($varepsilonle1)$ and low data regimes, and when the private training datasets are imbalanced. To overcome these limitations, we propose Differentially Private Prototype Learning (DPPL) as a new paradigm for private transfer learning. DPPL leverages publicly pre-trained encoders to extract features from private data and generates DP prototypes that represent each private class in the embedding space and can be publicly released for inference. Since our DP prototypes can be obtained from only a few private training data points and without iterative noise addition, they offer high-utility predictions and strong privacy guarantees even under the notion of pure DP. We additionally show that privacy-utility trade-offs can be further improved when leveraging the public data beyond pre-training of the encoder: in particular, we can privately sample our DP prototypes from the publicly available data points used to train the encoder. Our experimental evaluation with four state-of-the-art encoders, four vision datasets, and under different data and imbalancedness regimes demonstrate DPPL's high performance under strong privacy guarantees in challenging private learning setups.
Read more6/13/2024