Optimal Kernel Choice for Score Function-based Causal Discovery

Read original: arXiv:2407.10132 - Published 7/16/2024 by Wenjie Wang, Biwei Huang, Feng Liu, Xinge You, Tongliang Liu, Kun Zhang, Mingming Gong

Background

Optimal Kernel Choice

The research paper "Optimal Kernel Choice for Score Function-based Causal Discovery" explores the important problem of selecting the most appropriate kernel function for score-based causal discovery algorithms. Kernel functions are a crucial component in these algorithms, as they determine how the data is represented and compared.

Plain English Explanation

Causal discovery is the process of uncovering the underlying causal relationships between variables in a dataset. Score-based causal discovery algorithms use a scoring function to evaluate the likelihood of different causal structures. The choice of kernel function, which defines how the data is transformed and compared, can significantly impact the performance of these algorithms.

The paper investigates the problem of selecting the optimal kernel function for score-based causal discovery. The authors recognize that the choice of kernel is not straightforward and can have a significant impact on the accuracy and reliability of the causal discoveries. They aim to provide guidance on how to select the most appropriate kernel function for a given problem.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a theoretical analysis of the effect of the kernel function on the score function-based causal discovery process. The authors derive bounds on the estimation error of the score function, which depend on the properties of the kernel function, such as its reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS) norm. They show that the optimal kernel function can be characterized as the one that minimizes this estimation error bound.

The authors also propose a practical algorithm for kernel selection, which involves estimating the RKHS norm of the causal effects using a leave-one-out cross-validation approach. This allows them to select the kernel function that minimizes the estimated RKHS norm, and therefore the bound on the score function estimation error.

Debiased Collaborative Filtering: Kernel-Based Causal Balancing and Bias-Variance-Covariance Decomposition of Kernel Scores in Generative Models are related works that explore the role of kernel functions in causal discovery and generative modeling, respectively.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis of the kernel selection problem in score function-based causal discovery, and proposes a practical algorithm for kernel selection. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

The analysis assumes the availability of a sufficiently large dataset, which may not always be the case in real-world applications. It would be valuable to investigate the performance of the proposed approach in small-sample scenarios.
The paper focuses on the estimation error of the score function, but does not explicitly consider the impact of the kernel choice on the downstream task of recovering the true causal structure. It would be useful to analyze the relationship between the kernel-induced estimation error and the overall accuracy of the causal discoveries.
The proposed kernel selection algorithm relies on leave-one-out cross-validation, which can be computationally expensive for large datasets. Alternative, more efficient methods for kernel selection may be worth exploring.

Machine Learning-Based System Reliability Analysis: Gaussian and Limitations of Kernel Dependence Maximization for Feature Selection are two relevant papers that discuss the challenges and limitations of kernel-based methods in different contexts.

Conclusion

The research paper "Optimal Kernel Choice for Score Function-based Causal Discovery" presents an important contribution to the field of causal discovery by addressing the problem of kernel selection for score-based algorithms. The theoretical analysis and practical kernel selection algorithm provided in the paper can help practitioners choose the most appropriate kernel function for their specific causal discovery tasks, leading to more accurate and reliable causal inferences.

The potential limitations and areas for further research identified in the critical analysis suggest that while this work represents a significant step forward, there is still room for improvement and refinement of kernel-based causal discovery methods. Continued research in this direction, as well as the exploration of alternative approaches, can further advance the state of the art in this important field of study.

Optimizing Data-Driven Causal Discovery Using Knowledge is another relevant paper that explores ways to incorporate domain knowledge to improve the performance of causal discovery algorithms.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Optimal Kernel Choice for Score Function-based Causal Discovery

Wenjie Wang, Biwei Huang, Feng Liu, Xinge You, Tongliang Liu, Kun Zhang, Mingming Gong

Score-based methods have demonstrated their effectiveness in discovering causal relationships by scoring different causal structures based on their goodness of fit to the data. Recently, Huang et al. proposed a generalized score function that can handle general data distributions and causal relationships by modeling the relations in reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS). The selection of an appropriate kernel within this score function is crucial for accurately characterizing causal relationships and ensuring precise causal discovery. However, the current method involves manual heuristic selection of kernel parameters, making the process tedious and less likely to ensure optimality. In this paper, we propose a kernel selection method within the generalized score function that automatically selects the optimal kernel that best fits the data. Specifically, we model the generative process of the variables involved in each step of the causal graph search procedure as a mixture of independent noise variables. Based on this model, we derive an automatic kernel selection method by maximizing the marginal likelihood of the variables involved in each search step. We conduct experiments on both synthetic data and real-world benchmarks, and the results demonstrate that our proposed method outperforms heuristic kernel selection methods.

7/16/2024

🤔

Debiased Collaborative Filtering with Kernel-Based Causal Balancing

Haoxuan Li, Chunyuan Zheng, Yanghao Xiao, Peng Wu, Zhi Geng, Xu Chen, Peng Cui

Debiased collaborative filtering aims to learn an unbiased prediction model by removing different biases in observational datasets. To solve this problem, one of the simple and effective methods is based on the propensity score, which adjusts the observational sample distribution to the target one by reweighting observed instances. Ideally, propensity scores should be learned with causal balancing constraints. However, existing methods usually ignore such constraints or implement them with unreasonable approximations, which may affect the accuracy of the learned propensity scores. To bridge this gap, in this paper, we first analyze the gaps between the causal balancing requirements and existing methods such as learning the propensity with cross-entropy loss or manually selecting functions to balance. Inspired by these gaps, we propose to approximate the balancing functions in reproducing kernel Hilbert space and demonstrate that, based on the universal property and representer theorem of kernel functions, the causal balancing constraints can be better satisfied. Meanwhile, we propose an algorithm that adaptively balances the kernel function and theoretically analyze the generalization error bound of our methods. We conduct extensive experiments to demonstrate the effectiveness of our methods, and to promote this research direction, we have released our project at https://github.com/haoxuanli-pku/ICLR24-Kernel-Balancing.

5/1/2024

🤷

A Bias-Variance-Covariance Decomposition of Kernel Scores for Generative Models

Sebastian G. Gruber, Florian Buettner

Generative models, like large language models, are becoming increasingly relevant in our daily lives, yet a theoretical framework to assess their generalization behavior and uncertainty does not exist. Particularly, the problem of uncertainty estimation is commonly solved in an ad-hoc and task-dependent manner. For example, natural language approaches cannot be transferred to image generation. In this paper, we introduce the first bias-variance-covariance decomposition for kernel scores. This decomposition represents a theoretical framework from which we derive a kernel-based variance and entropy for uncertainty estimation. We propose unbiased and consistent estimators for each quantity which only require generated samples but not the underlying model itself. Based on the wide applicability of kernels, we demonstrate our framework via generalization and uncertainty experiments for image, audio, and language generation. Specifically, kernel entropy for uncertainty estimation is more predictive of performance on CoQA and TriviaQA question answering datasets than existing baselines and can also be applied to closed-source models.

7/11/2024

Score matching through the roof: linear, nonlinear, and latent variables causal discovery

Francesco Montagna, Philipp M. Faller, Patrick Bloebaum, Elke Kirschbaum, Francesco Locatello

Causal discovery from observational data holds great promise, but existing methods rely on strong assumptions about the underlying causal structure, often requiring full observability of all relevant variables. We tackle these challenges by leveraging the score function $nabla log p(X)$ of observed variables for causal discovery and propose the following contributions. First, we generalize the existing results of identifiability with the score to additive noise models with minimal requirements on the causal mechanisms. Second, we establish conditions for inferring causal relations from the score even in the presence of hidden variables; this result is two-faced: we demonstrate the score's potential as an alternative to conditional independence tests to infer the equivalence class of causal graphs with hidden variables, and we provide the necessary conditions for identifying direct causes in latent variable models. Building on these insights, we propose a flexible algorithm for causal discovery across linear, nonlinear, and latent variable models, which we empirically validate.

7/29/2024