Out-of-distribution Evidence-aware Fake News Detection via Dual Adversarial Debiasing
0
🔎
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a novel "Dual Adversarial Learning (DAL)" approach to address biases in evidence-aware fake news detection models.
- These models suffer from spurious correlations between news/evidence content and true/fake news labels, making them hard to generalize to out-of-distribution (OOD) situations.
- DAL incorporates news-aspect and evidence-aspect debiasing discriminators to mitigate the impact of content biases, while also optimizing the main fake news predictor to improve news-evidence reasoning.
Plain English Explanation
Fake news detection is a crucial task, but current models that use evidence to make their decisions can be biased. They may pick up on patterns in the content of the news and the evidence that don't actually reflect whether the news is true or fake. This can make the models perform poorly when faced with new, different types of news and evidence they haven't seen before.
To address this, the researchers developed a new approach called "Dual Adversarial Learning" (DAL). DAL uses two additional components, called "debiasing discriminators," to identify and reduce the impact of these content biases. One discriminator looks at the news content, and the other looks at the evidence content. They both try to predict whether the news is true or fake, but in a way that removes the influence of the specific words and patterns in the content.
At the same time, DAL also trains the main fake news prediction model to better understand the relationship between the news and the evidence, rather than just relying on biased content cues. This allows the model to make more accurate decisions, even when faced with new types of news and evidence that it hasn't seen before.
The researchers tested DAL on several existing fake news detection models and found that it significantly improved their performance, especially in challenging out-of-distribution situations. By addressing the content biases, DAL helps these models become more robust and reliable for real-world fake news detection.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel "Dual Adversarial Learning (DAL)" approach to address the biases in evidence-aware fake news detection models. These models often suffer from spurious correlations between news/evidence contents and true/fake news labels, making them hard to generalize to out-of-distribution (OOD) situations.
To mitigate these content biases, DAL incorporates news-aspect and evidence-aspect debiasing discriminators, whose targets are both true/fake news labels. DAL then reversely optimizes these debiasing discriminators to reduce the impact of news and evidence content biases. Simultaneously, DAL optimizes the main fake news predictor, allowing the news-evidence interaction module to be learned more effectively.
This process teaches the evidence-aware fake news detection model to better conduct news-evidence reasoning and minimize the influence of content biases. Importantly, the proposed DAL approach is a plug-and-play module that can be applied to existing detection model backbones.
The researchers conducted comprehensive experiments under two OOD settings, evaluating DAL with four different evidence-aware fake news detection backbones. The results demonstrate that DAL significantly and consistently outperforms the original backbones and some competitive debiasing methods, highlighting its effectiveness in addressing content biases and improving OOD generalization.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thoughtful approach to addressing the critical issue of content biases in evidence-aware fake news detection models. By incorporating the news-aspect and evidence-aspect debiasing discriminators, DAL effectively mitigates the impact of spurious correlations between content and labels, as highlighted in the survey on out-of-distribution and adversarial examples.
One potential limitation, as mentioned in the paper, is the need for further investigation into the specific types of content biases that DAL can address. The interpretable detection of out-of-context misinformation approach could provide additional insights in this direction.
Moreover, the impact of input perturbations on model robustness is an important consideration that could be explored in the context of DAL's performance under more diverse OOD scenarios. The study on adapting fake news detection to the era of large-scale misinformation could offer valuable guidance in this area.
Overall, the DAL approach represents a promising step towards building more robust and reliable evidence-aware fake news detection models, with the potential to address the noisy elephant in the room that is the challenge of out-of-distribution generalization.
Conclusion
The paper introduces a novel "Dual Adversarial Learning (DAL)" approach to address the content biases in evidence-aware fake news detection models. By incorporating news-aspect and evidence-aspect debiasing discriminators, DAL effectively mitigates the impact of spurious correlations between content and true/fake news labels, improving the model's ability to generalize to out-of-distribution situations.
The comprehensive experiments demonstrate that DAL significantly outperforms the original detection model backbones and other debiasing methods, making it a promising solution for building more robust and reliable evidence-aware fake news detection systems. The insights gained from this research could have important implications for combating the spread of misinformation and disinformation in the digital age.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔎
0
Out-of-distribution Evidence-aware Fake News Detection via Dual Adversarial Debiasing
Qiang Liu, Junfei Wu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang
Evidence-aware fake news detection aims to conduct reasoning between news and evidence, which is retrieved based on news content, to find uniformity or inconsistency. However, we find evidence-aware detection models suffer from biases, i.e., spurious correlations between news/evidence contents and true/fake news labels, and are hard to be generalized to Out-Of-Distribution (OOD) situations. To deal with this, we propose a novel Dual Adversarial Learning (DAL) approach. We incorporate news-aspect and evidence-aspect debiasing discriminators, whose targets are both true/fake news labels, in DAL. Then, DAL reversely optimizes news-aspect and evidence-aspect debiasing discriminators to mitigate the impact of news and evidence content biases. At the same time, DAL also optimizes the main fake news predictor, so that the news-evidence interaction module can be learned. This process allows us to teach evidence-aware fake news detection models to better conduct news-evidence reasoning, and minimize the impact of content biases. To be noted, our proposed DAL approach is a plug-and-play module that works well with existing backbones. We conduct comprehensive experiments under two OOD settings, and plug DAL in four evidence-aware fake news detection backbones. Results demonstrate that, DAL significantly and stably outperforms the original backbones and some competitive debiasing methods.
Read more4/16/2024
0
DAAD: Dynamic Analysis and Adaptive Discriminator for Fake News Detection
Xinqi Su, Yawen Cui, Ajian Liu, Xun Lin, Yuhao Wang, Haochen Liang, Wenhui Li, Zitong Yu
In current web environment, fake news spreads rapidly across online social networks, posing serious threats to society. Existing multimodal fake news detection (MFND) methods can be classified into knowledge-based and semantic-based approaches. However, these methods are overly dependent on human expertise and feedback, lacking flexibility. To address this challenge, we propose a Dynamic Analysis and Adaptive Discriminator (DAAD) approach for fake news detection. For knowledge-based methods, we introduce the Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) algorithm to leverage the self-reflective capabilities of large language models (LLMs) for prompt optimization, providing richer, domain-specific details and guidance to the LLMs, while enabling more flexible integration of LLM comment on news content. For semantic-based methods, we define four typical deceit patterns: emotional exaggeration, logical inconsistency, image manipulation, and semantic inconsistency, to reveal the mechanisms behind fake news creation. To detect these patterns, we carefully design four discriminators and expand them in depth and breadth, using the soft-routing mechanism to explore optimal detection models. Experimental results on three real-world datasets demonstrate the superiority of our approach. The code will be available at: https://github.com/SuXinqi/DAAD.
Read more8/21/2024
0
Explainable Fake News Detection With Large Language Model via Defense Among Competing Wisdom
Bo Wang, Jing Ma, Hongzhan Lin, Zhiwei Yang, Ruichao Yang, Yuan Tian, Yi Chang
Most fake news detection methods learn latent feature representations based on neural networks, which makes them black boxes to classify a piece of news without giving any justification. Existing explainable systems generate veracity justifications from investigative journalism, which suffer from debunking delayed and low efficiency. Recent studies simply assume that the justification is equivalent to the majority opinions expressed in the wisdom of crowds. However, the opinions typically contain some inaccurate or biased information since the wisdom of crowds is uncensored. To detect fake news from a sea of diverse, crowded and even competing narratives, in this paper, we propose a novel defense-based explainable fake news detection framework. Specifically, we first propose an evidence extraction module to split the wisdom of crowds into two competing parties and respectively detect salient evidences. To gain concise insights from evidences, we then design a prompt-based module that utilizes a large language model to generate justifications by inferring reasons towards two possible veracities. Finally, we propose a defense-based inference module to determine veracity via modeling the defense among these justifications. Extensive experiments conducted on two real-world benchmarks demonstrate that our proposed method outperforms state-of-the-art baselines in terms of fake news detection and provides high-quality justifications.
Read more6/21/2024
0
Detect, Investigate, Judge and Determine: A Novel LLM-based Framework for Few-shot Fake News Detection
Ye Liu, Jiajun Zhu, Kai Zhang, Haoyu Tang, Yanghai Zhang, Xukai Liu, Qi Liu, Enhong Chen
Few-Shot Fake News Detection (FS-FND) aims to distinguish inaccurate news from real ones in extremely low-resource scenarios. This task has garnered increased attention due to the widespread dissemination and harmful impact of fake news on social media. Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated competitive performance with the help of their rich prior knowledge and excellent in-context learning abilities. However, existing methods face significant limitations, such as the Understanding Ambiguity and Information Scarcity, which significantly undermine the potential of LLMs. To address these shortcomings, we propose a Dual-perspective Augmented Fake News Detection (DAFND) model, designed to enhance LLMs from both inside and outside perspectives. Specifically, DAFND first identifies the keywords of each news article through a Detection Module. Subsequently, DAFND creatively designs an Investigation Module to retrieve inside and outside valuable information concerning to the current news, followed by another Judge Module to derive its respective two prediction results. Finally, a Determination Module further integrates these two predictions and derives the final result. Extensive experiments on two publicly available datasets show the efficacy of our proposed method, particularly in low-resource settings.
Read more7/15/2024