PaRCE: Probabilistic and Reconstruction-Based Competency Estimation for Safe Navigation Under Perception Uncertainty
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces PaRCE, a framework for estimating the competency of a perception system in autonomous navigation tasks.
- PaRCE combines probabilistic and reconstruction-based approaches to provide statistical safety assurances about the navigational capabilities of the perception system.
- The key ideas are to model perception uncertainty, estimate the competency of the perception system, and use this to inform safe navigation planning.
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a new framework called PaRCE that aims to help autonomous vehicles navigate safely, even in situations where the perception system (e.g., cameras, sensors) is uncertain about its surroundings.
The core idea is to model the uncertainty in the perception system and then use that information to estimate how capable the system is at perceiving its environment. This "competency estimation" allows the autonomous vehicle to plan its movements in a way that accounts for the limitations of its sensors.
For example, if the perception system is unsure about the exact location of an obstacle, the competency estimation would reflect that uncertainty. The navigation system could then plan a route that gives the obstacle a wider berth, providing a safer and more cautious approach.
By bridging the gap between perception uncertainty and navigation planning, PaRCE aims to enable autonomous vehicles to navigate reliably and with strong statistical guarantees about their safety, even in challenging environments where the perception system may not be 100% accurate.
Technical Explanation
The PaRCE framework combines two key elements:
-
Probabilistic Modeling: PaRCE models the uncertainty in the perception system using probabilistic techniques. This allows it to quantify the reliability of the perception outputs, rather than treating them as deterministic ground truth.
-
Reconstruction-Based Competency Estimation: PaRCE uses a reconstruction-based approach to estimate the "competency" of the perception system - i.e., how well it can accurately perceive the environment. This competency estimate is then used to inform the navigation planning.
The paper presents detailed algorithms for implementing these two components and integrating them into a complete navigation system. Experiments show that PaRCE can significantly improve the safety and reliability of autonomous navigation, compared to approaches that do not explicitly account for perception uncertainty.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thoughtful and well-designed approach to addressing the challenge of safe navigation under perception uncertainty. A few potential areas for further research or consideration:
-
Validation in Real-World Scenarios: The experiments in the paper use simulated environments. It would be valuable to see how well PaRCE performs in more complex, real-world autonomous driving scenarios.
-
Computational Efficiency: The reconstruction-based competency estimation may add significant computational overhead. Optimizing the efficiency of this component could be an area for improvement.
-
Generalization to Other Perception Modalities: The paper focuses on camera-based perception. Extending the approach to handle a wider range of sensors (e.g., lidar, radar) could broaden the applicability of PaRCE.
-
Robustness to Adversarial Attacks: The paper does not address the potential for malicious actors to exploit perception vulnerabilities. Integrating adversarial robustness mechanisms could be an important area for future research.
Overall, the PaRCE framework represents a promising step forward in enabling safe and reliable autonomous navigation, and the insights from this paper could have significant implications for the development of advanced self-driving systems.
Conclusion
The PaRCE framework introduced in this paper addresses a critical challenge in autonomous navigation: ensuring safety and reliability even when the perception system is subject to uncertainty.
By modeling perception uncertainty and using that information to estimate the competency of the perception system, PaRCE enables autonomous vehicles to plan their movements in a way that accounts for the limitations of their sensors. This approach has the potential to significantly improve the safety and trustworthiness of self-driving technologies, paving the way for their wider adoption and real-world deployment.
The insights and techniques presented in this paper represent an important step forward in the field of safe and reliable autonomous navigation, and could have far-reaching implications for the development of advanced mobility solutions that can navigate complex environments with confidence.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
PaRCE: Probabilistic and Reconstruction-Based Competency Estimation for Safe Navigation Under Perception Uncertainty
Sara Pohland, Claire Tomlin
Perception-based navigation systems are useful for unmanned ground vehicle (UGV) navigation in complex terrains, where traditional depth-based navigation schemes are insufficient. However, these data-driven methods are highly dependent on their training data and can fail in surprising and dramatic ways with little warning. To ensure the safety of the vehicle and the surrounding environment, it is imperative that the navigation system is able to recognize the predictive uncertainty of the perception model and respond safely and effectively in the face of uncertainty. In an effort to enable safe navigation under perception uncertainty, we develop a probabilistic and reconstruction-based competency estimation (PaRCE) method to estimate the model's level of familiarity with an input image as a whole and with specific regions in the image. We find that the overall competency score can correctly predict correctly classified, misclassified, and out-of-distribution (OOD) samples. We also confirm that the regional competency maps can accurately distinguish between familiar and unfamiliar regions across images. We then use this competency information to develop a planning and control scheme that enables effective navigation while maintaining a low probability of error. We find that the competency-aware scheme greatly reduces the number of collisions with unfamiliar obstacles, compared to a baseline controller with no competency awareness. Furthermore, the regional competency information is very valuable in enabling efficient navigation.
Read more9/11/2024
🏋️
0
Perceive With Confidence: Statistical Safety Assurances for Navigation with Learning-Based Perception
Anushri Dixit, Zhiting Mei, Meghan Booker, Mariko Storey-Matsutani, Allen Z. Ren, Anirudha Majumdar
Rapid advances in perception have enabled large pre-trained models to be used out of the box for transforming high-dimensional, noisy, and partial observations of the world into rich occupancy representations. However, the reliability of these models and consequently their safe integration onto robots remains unknown when deployed in environments unseen during training. In this work, we address this challenge by rigorously quantifying the uncertainty of pre-trained perception systems for object detection via a novel calibration technique based on conformal prediction. Crucially, this procedure guarantees robustness to distribution shifts in states when perceptual outputs are used in conjunction with a planner. As a result, the calibrated perception system can be used in combination with any safe planner to provide an end-to-end statistical assurance on safety in unseen environments. We evaluate the resulting approach, Perceive with Confidence (PwC), in simulation and on hardware where a quadruped robot navigates through previously unseen indoor, static environments. These experiments validate the safety assurances for obstacle avoidance provided by PwC and demonstrate up to $40%$ improvements in empirical safety compared to baselines.
Read more7/10/2024
0
Understanding the Dependence of Perception Model Competency on Regions in an Image
Sara Pohland, Claire Tomlin
While deep neural network (DNN)-based perception models are useful for many applications, these models are black boxes and their outputs are not yet well understood. To confidently enable a real-world, decision-making system to utilize such a perception model without human intervention, we must enable the system to reason about the perception model's level of competency and respond appropriately when the model is incompetent. In order for the system to make an intelligent decision about the appropriate action when the model is incompetent, it would be useful for the system to understand why the model is incompetent. We explore five novel methods for identifying regions in the input image contributing to low model competency, which we refer to as image cropping, segment masking, pixel perturbation, competency gradients, and reconstruction loss. We assess the ability of these five methods to identify unfamiliar objects, recognize regions associated with unseen classes, and identify unexplored areas in an environment. We find that the competency gradients and reconstruction loss methods show great promise in identifying regions associated with low model competency, particularly when aspects of the image that are unfamiliar to the perception model are causing this reduction in competency. Both of these methods boast low computation times and high levels of accuracy in detecting image regions that are unfamiliar to the model, allowing them to provide potential utility in decision-making pipelines. The code for reproducing our methods and results is available on GitHub: https://github.com/sarapohland/explainable-competency.
Read more7/16/2024
📈
0
Closing the Perception-Action Loop for Semantically Safe Navigation in Semi-Static Environments
Jingxing Qian, Siqi Zhou, Nicholas Jianrui Ren, Veronica Chatrath, Angela P. Schoellig
Autonomous robots navigating in changing environments demand adaptive navigation strategies for safe long-term operation. While many modern control paradigms offer theoretical guarantees, they often assume known extrinsic safety constraints, overlooking challenges when deployed in real-world environments where objects can appear, disappear, and shift over time. In this paper, we present a closed-loop perception-action pipeline that bridges this gap. Our system encodes an online-constructed dense map, along with object-level semantic and consistency estimates into a control barrier function (CBF) to regulate safe regions in the scene. A model predictive controller (MPC) leverages the CBF-based safety constraints to adapt its navigation behaviour, which is particularly crucial when potential scene changes occur. We test the system in simulations and real-world experiments to demonstrate the impact of semantic information and scene change handling on robot behavior, validating the practicality of our approach.
Read more4/24/2024