Perceive With Confidence: Statistical Safety Assurances for Navigation with Learning-Based Perception

Overview

• This paper addresses the challenge of integrating pre-trained perception systems onto robots in a safe and reliable manner, even when operating in environments that are different from those used during training.
• The key contribution is a novel calibration technique based on conformal prediction that quantifies the uncertainty of pre-trained object detection models.
• The calibrated perception system can be used in conjunction with any safe planner to provide end-to-end statistical guarantees on safety in unseen environments.
• The approach, called Perceive with Confidence (PwC), is evaluated in simulation and on a quadruped robot navigating through previously unseen indoor environments.

Plain English Explanation

Modern AI models can be very good at perceiving the world around them, transforming noisy sensor data into rich representations that capture the state of the environment. This has enabled these models to be used "off-the-shelf" on robots, without the need for extensive custom training.

However, the reliability of these pre-trained perception models when deployed in new, unseen environments is often unknown. This poses a challenge for safely integrating these models onto robots, as we need to be confident that the robot's actions based on the perception outputs will not lead to collisions or other unsafe behaviors.

This paper addresses this challenge by developing a technique to quantify the uncertainty of pre-trained object detection models. The key idea is to calibrate the model's outputs, providing a measure of how confident it is in its detections. This calibrated perception system can then be used in conjunction with a safe planner to provide end-to-end statistical guarantees on the robot's safety, even in environments that are different from those used during training.

The authors evaluate this approach, called Perceive with Confidence (PwC), in simulation and on a physical quadruped robot navigating through previously unseen indoor environments. The results show that PwC can significantly improve the empirical safety of the robot's navigation compared to baseline methods.

Technical Explanation

The key technical contribution of this paper is a novel calibration technique for pre-trained object detection models based on the principles of conformal prediction. Conformal prediction is a framework for quantifying the uncertainty of machine learning models in a way that provides statistical guarantees, even in the presence of distribution shifts.

The authors apply this technique to calibrate the outputs of a pre-trained object detection model, producing prediction intervals that capture the true object locations with a specified confidence level. Crucially, this calibration process is designed to be robust to distribution shifts in the states encountered by the robot, ensuring that the statistical guarantees hold even when operating in environments that differ from the training data.

The calibrated perception system is then integrated with a safe planner to provide end-to-end statistical assurances on safety in unseen environments. The authors evaluate this approach, called Perceive with Confidence (PwC), in simulation and on a physical quadruped robot navigating through previously unseen indoor environments. The experiments demonstrate up to 40% improvements in empirical safety compared to baseline methods.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising approach for addressing the challenge of safely integrating pre-trained perception systems onto robots. The key strengths of the work include the rigorous mathematical foundations of the calibration technique, the demonstrated robustness to distribution shifts, and the end-to-end safety guarantees provided by the integration with a safe planner.

However, the paper also acknowledges several limitations and potential areas for further research. For example, the current approach is limited to static environments, and the authors note that extending the technique to dynamic environments with moving obstacles would be an important next step. Additionally, the experiments were conducted in relatively simple indoor environments, and the performance of the approach in more complex, real-world settings remains to be explored.

Another potential concern is the computational overhead of the calibration process, which could limit the practical deployability of the approach on resource-constrained robotic platforms. The authors do not provide a detailed analysis of the computational complexity or runtime of the calibration algorithm.

Finally, while the paper demonstrates significant improvements in empirical safety compared to baseline methods, the authors acknowledge that the statistical guarantees provided by the approach may be conservative, potentially leading to overly cautious robot behavior in some situations. Investigating ways to balance safety and performance would be an interesting direction for future research.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach, called Perceive with Confidence (PwC), that enables the safe integration of pre-trained perception systems onto robots. By calibrating the outputs of object detection models using conformal prediction, PwC can provide end-to-end statistical guarantees on the safety of the robot's behavior, even in environments that differ from the training data.

The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach, with significant improvements in empirical safety compared to baseline methods. While the current implementation has some limitations, the underlying principles and techniques developed in this work represent an important step towards providing safety assurances for robotic systems with unknown dynamics. As pre-trained perception models become increasingly ubiquitous in robotics, approaches like PwC will be crucial for ensuring the safe and reliable deployment of these systems in the real world.