The Power of the Noisy Channel: Unsupervised End-to-End Task-Oriented Dialogue with LLMs
2404.15219
0
0
🤷
Abstract
Training task-oriented dialogue systems typically requires turn-level annotations for interacting with their APIs: e.g. a dialogue state and the system actions taken at each step. These annotations can be costly to produce, error-prone, and require both domain and annotation expertise. With advances in LLMs, we hypothesize unlabelled data and a schema definition are sufficient for building a working task-oriented dialogue system, completely unsupervised. Using only (1) a well-defined API schema (2) a set of unlabelled dialogues between a user and agent, we develop a novel approach for inferring turn-level annotations as latent variables using a noisy channel model. We iteratively improve these pseudo-labels with expectation-maximization (EM), and use the inferred labels to train an end-to-end dialogue agent. Evaluating our approach on the MultiWOZ benchmark, our method more than doubles the dialogue success rate of a strong GPT-3.5 baseline.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a novel approach to train task-oriented dialogue systems without the need for costly turn-level annotations.
- The method relies on a well-defined API schema and a set of unlabelled dialogues between a user and an agent.
- It uses a noisy channel model to infer turn-level annotations as latent variables, which are then iteratively improved using expectation-maximization (EM).
- The inferred labels are used to train an end-to-end dialogue agent.
- Evaluation on the MultiWOZ benchmark shows the approach more than doubles the dialogue success rate of a strong GPT-3.5 baseline.
Plain English Explanation
Building effective task-oriented dialogue systems typically requires detailed annotations for each step of the conversation, such as the current dialogue state and the actions the system should take. However, creating these annotations can be time-consuming, error-prone, and require specialized domain and annotation expertise.
This research proposes a new way to train dialogue systems that doesn't need these detailed annotations. Instead, the method only requires a well-defined schema for the task's application programming interface (API) and a set of unlabelled dialogues between a user and an agent.
The key idea is to use a statistical model called a "noisy channel model" to infer the missing annotations as hidden variables. This model is then iteratively improved using a technique called expectation-maximization (EM). The inferred annotations are then used to train an end-to-end dialogue agent.
When tested on a common benchmark called MultiWOZ, the researchers found their approach more than doubled the success rate of a strong baseline system based on the powerful GPT-3.5 language model. This suggests their unsupervised method can be an effective way to build high-performing task-oriented dialogue systems without the need for costly manual annotations.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel approach to train task-oriented dialogue systems without relying on turn-level annotations. The method only requires (1) a well-defined API schema and (2) a set of unlabelled dialogues between a user and an agent.
The core of the approach is a noisy channel model that infers the missing turn-level annotations (e.g., dialogue state, system actions) as latent variables. This model is iteratively improved using expectation-maximization (EM), and the inferred labels are used to train an end-to-end dialogue agent.
Specifically, the authors formulate the problem as learning a mapping from the user's utterance and the current state to the system's response, where the state and actions are treated as latent variables. They use the EM algorithm to alternate between inferring the latent variables and updating the dialogue policy parameters.
Evaluating on the MultiWOZ benchmark, the authors show their approach more than doubles the dialogue success rate of a strong GPT-3.5 baseline. This demonstrates the effectiveness of their unsupervised method for building high-performing task-oriented dialogue systems without the need for costly manual annotations.
The work builds on recent advances in large language models and leveraging unlabelled data for dialogue state tracking, as well as research on rethinking the evaluation of dialogue systems and adding speech abilities to language models.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for training task-oriented dialogue systems without the need for costly turn-level annotations. The use of a noisy channel model to infer latent annotations is an intriguing idea that appears to work well in practice.
However, the authors do note some limitations. For example, the method relies on having a well-defined API schema, which may not always be available. Additionally, the quality of the inferred annotations could be affected by the complexity of the dialogues and the ability of the noisy channel model to accurately capture the underlying patterns.
It would be useful to see further analysis on the types of dialogues and tasks where this approach works best, as well as comparisons to other unsupervised or semi-supervised methods for dialogue system training. Exploring ways to relax the requirement for a predefined API schema could also expand the applicability of the technique.
Overall, the research represents an important step towards more efficient and scalable training of task-oriented dialogue systems. The strong performance gains demonstrated on the MultiWOZ benchmark are a promising indication of the method's potential, and the authors are encouraged to continue this line of work.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to train task-oriented dialogue systems without relying on costly turn-level annotations. By using a well-defined API schema and a set of unlabelled dialogues, the method is able to infer the missing annotations as latent variables using a noisy channel model, which is then iteratively improved.
The evaluation on the MultiWOZ benchmark shows this unsupervised approach can more than double the dialogue success rate of a strong GPT-3.5 baseline. This suggests the technique could be an effective way to build high-performing task-oriented dialogue systems without the need for manual annotations, a significant advancement in the field.
While the method has some limitations, such as the requirement for a predefined API schema, the research represents an important step towards more efficient and scalable training of dialogue systems. Further exploration of this approach and comparisons to other unsupervised techniques could yield valuable insights for the broader dialogue systems community.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤔
Investigating Low-Cost LLM Annotation for~Spoken Dialogue Understanding Datasets
Lucas Druart (LIA), Valentin Vielzeuf (LIA), Yannick Est`eve (LIA)
0
0
In spoken Task-Oriented Dialogue (TOD) systems, the choice of the semantic representation describing the users' requests is key to a smooth interaction. Indeed, the system uses this representation to reason over a database and its domain knowledge to choose its next action. The dialogue course thus depends on the information provided by this semantic representation. While textual datasets provide fine-grained semantic representations, spoken dialogue datasets fall behind. This paper provides insights into automatic enhancement of spoken dialogue datasets' semantic representations. Our contributions are three fold: (1) assess the relevance of Large Language Model fine-tuning, (2) evaluate the knowledge captured by the produced annotations and (3) highlight semi-automatic annotation implications.
6/21/2024
🤷
Unsupervised Flow Discovery from Task-oriented Dialogues
Patr'icia Ferreira, Daniel Martins, Ana Alves, Catarina Silva, Hugo Gonc{c}alo Oliveira
0
0
The design of dialogue flows is a critical but time-consuming task when developing task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems. We propose an approach for the unsupervised discovery of flows from dialogue history, thus making the process applicable to any domain for which such an history is available. Briefly, utterances are represented in a vector space and clustered according to their semantic similarity. Clusters, which can be seen as dialogue states, are then used as the vertices of a transition graph for representing the flows visually. We present concrete examples of flows, discovered from MultiWOZ, a public TOD dataset. We further elaborate on their significance and relevance for the underlying conversations and introduce an automatic validation metric for their assessment. Experimental results demonstrate the potential of the proposed approach for extracting meaningful flows from task-oriented conversations.
5/3/2024
💬
AnnoLLM: Making Large Language Models to Be Better Crowdsourced Annotators
Xingwei He, Zhenghao Lin, Yeyun Gong, A-Long Jin, Hang Zhang, Chen Lin, Jian Jiao, Siu Ming Yiu, Nan Duan, Weizhu Chen
0
0
Many natural language processing (NLP) tasks rely on labeled data to train machine learning models with high performance. However, data annotation is time-consuming and expensive, especially when the task involves a large amount of data or requires specialized domains. Recently, GPT-3.5 series models have demonstrated remarkable few-shot and zero-shot ability across various NLP tasks. In this paper, we first claim that large language models (LLMs), such as GPT-3.5, can serve as an excellent crowdsourced annotator when provided with sufficient guidance and demonstrated examples. Accordingly, we propose AnnoLLM, an annotation system powered by LLMs, which adopts a two-step approach, explain-then-annotate. Concretely, we first prompt LLMs to provide explanations for why the specific ground truth answer/label was assigned for a given example. Then, we construct the few-shot chain-of-thought prompt with the self-generated explanation and employ it to annotate the unlabeled data with LLMs. Our experiment results on three tasks, including user input and keyword relevance assessment, BoolQ, and WiC, demonstrate that AnnoLLM surpasses or performs on par with crowdsourced annotators. Furthermore, we build the first conversation-based information retrieval dataset employing AnnoLLM. This dataset is designed to facilitate the development of retrieval models capable of retrieving pertinent documents for conversational text. Human evaluation has validated the dataset's high quality.
4/8/2024
💬
Leveraging Large Language Models for Knowledge-free Weak Supervision in Clinical Natural Language Processing
Enshuo Hsu, Kirk Roberts
0
0
The performance of deep learning-based natural language processing systems is based on large amounts of labeled training data which, in the clinical domain, are not easily available or affordable. Weak supervision and in-context learning offer partial solutions to this issue, particularly using large language models (LLMs), but their performance still trails traditional supervised methods with moderate amounts of gold-standard data. In particular, inferencing with LLMs is computationally heavy. We propose an approach leveraging fine-tuning LLMs and weak supervision with virtually no domain knowledge that still achieves consistently dominant performance. Using a prompt-based approach, the LLM is used to generate weakly-labeled data for training a downstream BERT model. The weakly supervised model is then further fine-tuned on small amounts of gold standard data. We evaluate this approach using Llama2 on three different n2c2 datasets. With no more than 10 gold standard notes, our final BERT models weakly supervised by fine-tuned Llama2-13B consistently outperformed out-of-the-box PubMedBERT by 4.7% to 47.9% in F1 scores. With only 50 gold standard notes, our models achieved close performance to fully fine-tuned systems.
6/12/2024