Preble: Efficient Distributed Prompt Scheduling for LLM Serving

Overview

• Large language models (LLMs) are now used to solve complex problems, with prompts including domain-specific instructions, tool usages, and long context like textbook chapters.
• These prompts often have repetitive parts across requests, and their attention computation results could be reused.
• However, current LLM serving systems treat each request in isolation, missing the opportunity for computation reuse.

Plain English Explanation

The paper introduces a new system called Preble that aims to improve the efficiency of serving large language models (LLMs) by taking advantage of the repetitive parts in the prompts used to query these models.

Prompts to LLMs have become more complex over time, often including domain-specific instructions, illustrations of tool usage, and even long passages of text like textbook chapters. While these prompts may have many similar elements across different requests, current LLM serving systems treat each request in isolation, missing the opportunity to reuse the computation done for those repetitive parts.

Preble is designed to address this problem by being the first distributed LLM serving platform that specifically targets and optimizes for prompt sharing. The researchers performed a study on five popular LLM workloads and used the insights to design a distributed scheduling system that co-optimizes computation reuse and load balancing.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes Preble, a distributed LLM serving platform that targets and optimizes for prompt sharing. The authors first conducted a study on five popular LLM workloads to understand the characteristics of real-world prompts. Based on the study results, they designed a distributed scheduling system that co-optimizes computation reuse and load balancing.

The key elements of Preble's architecture and evaluation are:

1. Prompt Parsing and Caching: Preble parses the incoming prompts to identify repetitive components, which are then cached for reuse across requests.
2. Distributed Scheduling: Preble's scheduling system assigns requests to workers in a way that maximizes computation reuse while maintaining good load balancing.
3. Evaluation: The authors evaluated Preble on two open-source LLM models (GPT-2 and BERT) using real workloads and request arrival patterns, running on 2 to 8 GPUs. Preble outperformed the state-of-the-art in average latency by 1.5X to 14.5X and in p99 latency by 2X to 10X.

The paper builds on related work in areas such as efficient multi-prompt evaluation, modular attention reuse, and low-latency large language model serving [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/loongserve-efficiently-serving-long-context-large-language].

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling solution to the problem of inefficient LLM serving, with Preble demonstrating significant performance improvements over the state-of-the-art. However, the authors acknowledge some limitations and areas for further research:

1. Prompt Complexity: The study focused on five popular LLM workloads, but the diversity and complexity of real-world prompts may be broader, requiring further evaluation.
2. Scalability: While Preble shows good performance on 2 to 8 GPUs, its scalability to larger deployments with more compute resources needs to be explored.
3. Generalization: The paper evaluates Preble on two open-source LLM models (GPT-2 and BERT). Its effectiveness on other LLM architectures and future models remains to be seen.

Additionally, one could question the reliance on the ability to accurately parse and identify repetitive components in prompts, as this may not always be a trivial task, especially for more complex prompts. The paper could have also discussed potential security and privacy implications of caching and reusing computation results across user requests.

Conclusion

The Preble system presents a promising approach to improving the efficiency of serving large language models by taking advantage of the repetitive components in prompts. By designing a distributed scheduling system that co-optimizes computation reuse and load balancing, the researchers were able to achieve significant performance improvements over the state-of-the-art.

While the paper highlights some limitations and areas for further research, the core idea of Preble is a valuable contribution to the field of LLM serving, and the results suggest that there is substantial room for optimization beyond the current isolated request handling approaches. As LLMs continue to grow in complexity and importance, systems like Preble will become increasingly crucial for enabling their efficient and scalable deployment.