Preventing Catastrophic Overfitting in Fast Adversarial Training: A Bi-level Optimization Perspective
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a new method for preventing "catastrophic overfitting" in fast adversarial training of deep neural networks.
- Catastrophic overfitting is a problem where the model becomes overly specialized to adversarial examples, leading to poor performance on normal data.
- The proposed approach uses a bi-level optimization technique to balance normal and adversarial training, preventing this issue.
Plain English Explanation
Adversarial training is a technique used to make deep learning models more robust to adversarial attacks - small, carefully crafted changes to the input data that can trick the model into making mistakes. However, a common problem with fast adversarial training is "catastrophic overfitting", where the model becomes so good at identifying and defending against adversarial examples that it starts to perform poorly on normal, everyday data.
The researchers in this paper introduce a new method to prevent this catastrophic overfitting. Their approach uses a "bi-level optimization" technique, which means they optimize the model in two steps. First, they update the model to perform well on normal data. Then, they fine-tune the model to also be robust against adversarial examples, but they constrain this fine-tuning process to avoid the model becoming too specialized and losing its ability to handle regular data.
By balancing these two goals - performing well on normal data and being robust to adversarial attacks - the researchers are able to train models that are both accurate and secure, without suffering from the catastrophic overfitting problem. This is an important advancement, as it makes adversarial training more practical and effective for real-world applications of deep learning.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a bi-level optimization approach to prevent catastrophic overfitting in fast adversarial training. The key idea is to optimize the model in two steps:
-
Normal training: First, the model is trained on normal (non-adversarial) data to ensure good performance on regular inputs. This is the "upper-level" optimization problem.
-
Adversarial fine-tuning: Next, the model is fine-tuned to be robust against adversarial examples. However, this "lower-level" optimization is constrained to prevent the model from becoming too specialized and losing its ability to handle normal data.
This bi-level optimization approach allows the model to achieve both high accuracy on regular data and strong robustness to adversarial attacks, without suffering from catastrophic overfitting. The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on several benchmark datasets and show that it outperforms previous approaches to mitigating catastrophic overfitting.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a well-designed and thorough evaluation of the proposed bi-level optimization method for preventing catastrophic overfitting in fast adversarial training. The authors consider a range of datasets and model architectures, and they compare their approach to several strong baselines.
One potential limitation of the work is that the bi-level optimization procedure can be computationally intensive, as it requires alternating between the normal training and adversarial fine-tuning steps. The authors mention that this can lead to longer training times, which may be a concern for some real-world applications.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential for the bi-level optimization approach to be combined with other techniques for improving the stability and generalization of adversarial training, such as layer-aware analysis of catastrophic overfitting, exploiting layered intrinsic dimensionality, or logit calibration. Exploring these synergies could lead to even more robust and stable adversarial training methods.
Overall, this paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of adversarial machine learning, and the proposed bi-level optimization approach represents an important step towards making adversarial training more practical and effective for real-world applications.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new bi-level optimization method for preventing catastrophic overfitting in fast adversarial training of deep neural networks. By alternating between optimizing the model for normal data performance and adversarial robustness, the approach is able to achieve high accuracy on regular inputs while also maintaining strong resistance to adversarial attacks.
The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on several benchmark datasets, showing that it outperforms previous techniques for mitigating catastrophic overfitting. This is an important advancement, as it helps to make adversarial training more practical and applicable for real-world deep learning systems that need to be both accurate and secure.
While the bi-level optimization approach does come with some additional computational cost, the benefits it provides in terms of preventing catastrophic overfitting make it a promising direction for further research and development in the field of adversarial machine learning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Preventing Catastrophic Overfitting in Fast Adversarial Training: A Bi-level Optimization Perspective
Zhaoxin Wang, Handing Wang, Cong Tian, Yaochu Jin
Adversarial training (AT) has become an effective defense method against adversarial examples (AEs) and it is typically framed as a bi-level optimization problem. Among various AT methods, fast AT (FAT), which employs a single-step attack strategy to guide the training process, can achieve good robustness against adversarial attacks at a low cost. However, FAT methods suffer from the catastrophic overfitting problem, especially on complex tasks or with large-parameter models. In this work, we propose a FAT method termed FGSM-PCO, which mitigates catastrophic overfitting by averting the collapse of the inner optimization problem in the bi-level optimization process. FGSM-PCO generates current-stage AEs from the historical AEs and incorporates them into the training process using an adaptive mechanism. This mechanism determines an appropriate fusion ratio according to the performance of the AEs on the training model. Coupled with a loss function tailored to the training framework, FGSM-PCO can alleviate catastrophic overfitting and help the recovery of an overfitted model to effective training. We evaluate our algorithm across three models and three datasets to validate its effectiveness. Comparative empirical studies against other FAT algorithms demonstrate that our proposed method effectively addresses unresolved overfitting issues in existing algorithms.
Read more7/18/2024
0
Eliminating Catastrophic Overfitting Via Abnormal Adversarial Examples Regularization
Runqi Lin, Chaojian Yu, Tongliang Liu
Single-step adversarial training (SSAT) has demonstrated the potential to achieve both efficiency and robustness. However, SSAT suffers from catastrophic overfitting (CO), a phenomenon that leads to a severely distorted classifier, making it vulnerable to multi-step adversarial attacks. In this work, we observe that some adversarial examples generated on the SSAT-trained network exhibit anomalous behaviour, that is, although these training samples are generated by the inner maximization process, their associated loss decreases instead, which we named abnormal adversarial examples (AAEs). Upon further analysis, we discover a close relationship between AAEs and classifier distortion, as both the number and outputs of AAEs undergo a significant variation with the onset of CO. Given this observation, we re-examine the SSAT process and uncover that before the occurrence of CO, the classifier already displayed a slight distortion, indicated by the presence of few AAEs. Furthermore, the classifier directly optimizing these AAEs will accelerate its distortion, and correspondingly, the variation of AAEs will sharply increase as a result. In such a vicious circle, the classifier rapidly becomes highly distorted and manifests as CO within a few iterations. These observations motivate us to eliminate CO by hindering the generation of AAEs. Specifically, we design a novel method, termed Abnormal Adversarial Examples Regularization (AAER), which explicitly regularizes the variation of AAEs to hinder the classifier from becoming distorted. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our method can effectively eliminate CO and further boost adversarial robustness with negligible additional computational overhead.
Read more9/17/2024
0
Layer-Aware Analysis of Catastrophic Overfitting: Revealing the Pseudo-Robust Shortcut Dependency
Runqi Lin, Chaojian Yu, Bo Han, Hang Su, Tongliang Liu
Catastrophic overfitting (CO) presents a significant challenge in single-step adversarial training (AT), manifesting as highly distorted deep neural networks (DNNs) that are vulnerable to multi-step adversarial attacks. However, the underlying factors that lead to the distortion of decision boundaries remain unclear. In this work, we delve into the specific changes within different DNN layers and discover that during CO, the former layers are more susceptible, experiencing earlier and greater distortion, while the latter layers show relative insensitivity. Our analysis further reveals that this increased sensitivity in former layers stems from the formation of pseudo-robust shortcuts, which alone can impeccably defend against single-step adversarial attacks but bypass genuine-robust learning, resulting in distorted decision boundaries. Eliminating these shortcuts can partially restore robustness in DNNs from the CO state, thereby verifying that dependence on them triggers the occurrence of CO. This understanding motivates us to implement adaptive weight perturbations across different layers to hinder the generation of pseudo-robust shortcuts, consequently mitigating CO. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our proposed method, Layer-Aware Adversarial Weight Perturbation (LAP), can effectively prevent CO and further enhance robustness.
Read more9/17/2024
0
New!FedProphet: Memory-Efficient Federated Adversarial Training via Theoretic-Robustness and Low-Inconsistency Cascade Learning
Minxue Tang, Yitu Wang, Jingyang Zhang, Louis DiValentin, Aolin Ding, Amin Hass, Yiran Chen, Hai Helen Li
Federated Learning (FL) provides a strong privacy guarantee by enabling local training across edge devices without training data sharing, and Federated Adversarial Training (FAT) further enhances the robustness against adversarial examples, promoting a step toward trustworthy artificial intelligence. However, FAT requires a large model to preserve high accuracy while achieving strong robustness, and it is impractically slow when directly training with memory-constrained edge devices due to the memory-swapping latency. Moreover, existing memory-efficient FL methods suffer from poor accuracy and weak robustness in FAT because of inconsistent local and global models, i.e., objective inconsistency. In this paper, we propose FedProphet, a novel FAT framework that can achieve memory efficiency, adversarial robustness, and objective consistency simultaneously. FedProphet partitions the large model into small cascaded modules such that the memory-constrained devices can conduct adversarial training module-by-module. A strong convexity regularization is derived to theoretically guarantee the robustness of the whole model, and we show that the strong robustness implies low objective inconsistency in FedProphet. We also develop a training coordinator on the server of FL, with Adaptive Perturbation Adjustment for utility-robustness balance and Differentiated Module Assignment for objective inconsistency mitigation. FedProphet empirically shows a significant improvement in both accuracy and robustness compared to previous memory-efficient methods, achieving almost the same performance of end-to-end FAT with 80% memory reduction and up to 10.8x speedup in training time.
Read more9/16/2024