PromptKD: Unsupervised Prompt Distillation for Vision-Language Models

Read original: arXiv:2403.02781 - Published 8/14/2024 by Zheng Li, Xiang Li, Xinyi Fu, Xin Zhang, Weiqiang Wang, Shuo Chen, Jian Yang

PromptKD: Unsupervised Prompt Distillation for Vision-Language Models

Overview

This paper introduces PromptKD, an unsupervised method for distilling knowledge from vision-language models into more compact, student-friendly prompts.
PromptKD uses a combination of knowledge distillation and prompt learning to create prompts that can efficiently transfer the capabilities of large, powerful models to smaller, more lightweight models.
The key idea is to learn prompts that can elicit similar outputs from the student model as the teacher model, without requiring the student to have the same complex architecture.

Plain English Explanation

PromptKD is a technique that allows you to take the knowledge from a large, powerful AI model and transfer it to a smaller, more lightweight model. This is useful because the smaller model can then be deployed on devices with limited computing power, like phones or embedded systems, while still performing well on a variety of tasks.

The way PromptKD works is by learning special "prompts" - short pieces of text that, when given as input to the smaller model, cause it to produce outputs that are very similar to what the larger model would produce. This allows the smaller model to effectively "mimic" the behavior of the larger model without having the same complex internal architecture.

This prompt-based knowledge distillation is done in an unsupervised way, meaning the smaller model doesn't need any labeled training data - it just learns to match the outputs of the larger model as closely as possible. This makes PromptKD a flexible and efficient way to deploy powerful AI capabilities on a wide range of platforms and devices.

Technical Explanation

The key components of PromptKD are:

Prompt Learning: The method learns a set of prompts that can be used to elicit similar outputs from the student model as the teacher model. This is done by optimizing the prompts to minimize the difference between the student's output and the teacher's output.
Knowledge Distillation: PromptKD uses a knowledge distillation objective to transfer knowledge from the teacher model to the student model. This means the student model is trained to match the outputs of the teacher model as closely as possible, even though the student has a different, more compact architecture.
Unsupervised Training: The entire PromptKD process is done in an unsupervised way, without requiring any labeled training data. The model learns the prompts and performs the knowledge distillation solely based on the outputs of the teacher model.

The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of PromptKD on various vision-language tasks, showing that the student model can achieve performance close to the teacher model while being much smaller and more efficient. This makes PromptKD a promising approach for deploying powerful AI models on resource-constrained devices.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough evaluation of PromptKD and its limitations. Some key points:

The method relies on the assumption that the teacher model's outputs can be closely approximated by the student model using the learned prompts. This may not always be the case, especially for highly complex or domain-specific tasks.
The paper focuses on vision-language tasks, but it's unclear how well PromptKD would generalize to other domains, such as pure language or speech-based tasks.
The unsupervised nature of the training process means that the student model's performance is inherently limited by the teacher model's capabilities. If the teacher model has biases or limitations, these may be transferred to the student model as well.
The paper does not explore the long-term stability or generalization of the learned prompts, which could be important for real-world deployment.

Overall, PromptKD is a promising approach, but further research is needed to understand its limitations and potential areas for improvement, especially when scaling to more diverse tasks and domains.

Conclusion

The PromptKD method presented in this paper offers a novel way to distill the knowledge of large, powerful vision-language models into more compact, efficient student models. By learning prompts that can elicit similar outputs from the student, PromptKD enables the transfer of capabilities without requiring the student to have the same complex architecture.

This unsupervised prompt-based knowledge distillation has the potential to make powerful AI models more accessible and deployable on a wide range of devices and platforms, paving the way for more widespread adoption of advanced AI technologies. However, further research is needed to fully understand the limitations and potential issues with the approach, especially when scaling to more diverse tasks and domains.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

PromptKD: Unsupervised Prompt Distillation for Vision-Language Models

Zheng Li, Xiang Li, Xinyi Fu, Xin Zhang, Weiqiang Wang, Shuo Chen, Jian Yang

Prompt learning has emerged as a valuable technique in enhancing vision-language models (VLMs) such as CLIP for downstream tasks in specific domains. Existing work mainly focuses on designing various learning forms of prompts, neglecting the potential of prompts as effective distillers for learning from larger teacher models. In this paper, we introduce an unsupervised domain prompt distillation framework, which aims to transfer the knowledge of a larger teacher model to a lightweight target model through prompt-driven imitation using unlabeled domain images. Specifically, our framework consists of two distinct stages. In the initial stage, we pre-train a large CLIP teacher model using domain (few-shot) labels. After pre-training, we leverage the unique decoupled-modality characteristics of CLIP by pre-computing and storing the text features as class vectors only once through the teacher text encoder. In the subsequent stage, the stored class vectors are shared across teacher and student image encoders for calculating the predicted logits. Further, we align the logits of both the teacher and student models via KL divergence, encouraging the student image encoder to generate similar probability distributions to the teacher through the learnable prompts. The proposed prompt distillation process eliminates the reliance on labeled data, enabling the algorithm to leverage a vast amount of unlabeled images within the domain. Finally, the well-trained student image encoders and pre-stored text features (class vectors) are utilized for inference. To our best knowledge, we are the first to (1) perform unsupervised domain-specific prompt-driven knowledge distillation for CLIP, and (2) establish a practical pre-storing mechanism of text features as shared class vectors between teacher and student. Extensive experiments on 11 datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.

8/14/2024

Improving Zero-shot Generalization of Learned Prompts via Unsupervised Knowledge Distillation

Marco Mistretta, Alberto Baldrati, Marco Bertini, Andrew D. Bagdanov

Vision-Language Models (VLMs) demonstrate remarkable zero-shot generalization to unseen tasks, but fall short of the performance of supervised methods in generalizing to downstream tasks with limited data. Prompt learning is emerging as a parameter-efficient method for adapting VLMs, but state-of-the-art approaches require annotated samples. In this paper we propose a novel approach to prompt learning based on unsupervised knowledge distillation from more powerful models. Our approach, which we call Knowledge Distillation Prompt Learning (KDPL), can be integrated into existing prompt learning techniques and eliminates the need for labeled examples during adaptation. Our experiments on more than ten standard benchmark datasets demonstrate that KDPL is very effective at improving generalization of learned prompts for zero-shot domain generalization, zero-shot cross-dataset generalization, and zero-shot base-to-novel class generalization problems. KDPL requires no ground-truth labels for adaptation, and moreover we show that even in the absence of any knowledge of training class names it can be used to effectively transfer knowledge. The code is publicly available at https://github.com/miccunifi/KDPL.

7/31/2024

PromptKD: Distilling Student-Friendly Knowledge for Generative Language Models via Prompt Tuning

Gyeongman Kim, Doohyuk Jang, Eunho Yang

Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have raised concerns about inference costs, increasing the need for research into model compression. While knowledge distillation (KD) is a prominent method for this, research on KD for generative language models like LLMs is relatively sparse, and the approach of distilling student-friendly knowledge, which has shown promising performance in KD for classification models, remains unexplored in generative language models. To explore this approach, we propose PromptKD, a simple yet effective method that utilizes prompt tuning - for the first time in KD - to enable generative language models to transfer student-friendly knowledge. Unlike previous works in classification that require fine-tuning the entire teacher model for extracting student-friendly knowledge, PromptKD achieves similar effects by adding a small number of prompt tokens and tuning only the prompt with student guidance. Extensive experiments on instruction-following datasets show that PromptKD achieves state-of-the-art performance while adding only 0.0007% of the teacher's parameters as prompts. Further analysis suggests that distilling student-friendly knowledge alleviates exposure bias effectively throughout the entire training process, leading to performance enhancements.

6/26/2024

Revisiting Prompt Pretraining of Vision-Language Models

Zhenyuan Chen, Lingfeng Yang, Shuo Chen, Zhaowei Chen, Jiajun Liang, Xiang Li

Prompt learning is an effective method to customize Vision-Language Models (VLMs) for various downstream tasks, involving tuning very few parameters of input prompt tokens. Recently, prompt pretraining in large-scale dataset (e.g., ImageNet-21K) has played a crucial role in prompt learning for universal visual discrimination. However, we revisit and observe that the limited learnable prompts could face underfitting risks given the extensive images during prompt pretraining, simultaneously leading to poor generalization. To address the above issues, in this paper, we propose a general framework termed Revisiting Prompt Pretraining (RPP), which targets at improving the fitting and generalization ability from two aspects: prompt structure and prompt supervision. For prompt structure, we break the restriction in common practice where query, key, and value vectors are derived from the shared learnable prompt token. Instead, we introduce unshared individual query, key, and value learnable prompts, thereby enhancing the model's fitting capacity through increased parameter diversity. For prompt supervision, we additionally utilize soft labels derived from zero-shot probability predictions provided by a pretrained Contrastive Language Image Pretraining (CLIP) teacher model. These soft labels yield more nuanced and general insights into the inter-class relationships, thereby endowing the pretraining process with better generalization ability. RPP produces a more resilient prompt initialization, enhancing its robust transferability across diverse visual recognition tasks. Experiments across various benchmarks consistently confirm the state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance of our pretrained prompts. Codes and models will be made available soon.

9/11/2024