Provable Acceleration of Nesterov's Accelerated Gradient Method over Heavy Ball Method in Training Over-Parameterized Neural Networks
2208.03941
0
0
🏋️
Abstract
Due to its simplicity and efficiency, the first-order gradient method has been extensively employed in training neural networks. Although the optimization problem of the neural network is non-convex, recent research has proved that the first-order method is capable of attaining a global minimum during training over-parameterized neural networks, where the number of parameters is significantly larger than that of training instances. Momentum methods, including the heavy ball (HB) method and Nesterov's accelerated gradient (NAG) method, are the workhorse of first-order gradient methods owning to their accelerated convergence. In practice, NAG often exhibits superior performance than HB. However, current theoretical works fail to distinguish their convergence difference in training neural networks. To fill this gap, we consider the training problem of the two-layer ReLU neural network under over-parameterization and random initialization. Leveraging high-resolution dynamical systems and neural tangent kernel (NTK) theory, our result not only establishes tighter upper bounds of the convergence rate for both HB and NAG, but also provides the first theoretical guarantee for the acceleration of NAG over HB in training neural networks. Finally, we validate our theoretical results on three benchmark datasets.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- First-order gradient methods, such as the heavy ball (HB) and Nesterov's accelerated gradient (NAG) methods, are widely used in training neural networks.
- Despite neural networks having non-convex optimization problems, recent research has shown that first-order methods can reach global minima in over-parameterized neural networks.
- Momentum methods like HB and NAG exhibit accelerated convergence, with NAG often outperforming HB in practice. However, current theoretical work has not been able to explain this difference.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a common technique used to train artificial neural networks called first-order gradient methods. These methods, which include the heavy ball (HB) and Nesterov's accelerated gradient (NAG) methods, work by gradually adjusting the network's parameters in the direction that reduces the overall error or "loss" of the network.
Even though neural networks have complex, non-convex optimization problems, recent research has shown that these first-order gradient methods can still find the global minimum (the best possible configuration of the network's parameters) when the network has many more parameters than training examples (a condition known as "over-parameterization").
The momentum methods, HB and NAG, are particularly effective because they can accelerate the convergence of the optimization process, meaning they can find the global minimum more quickly than simpler gradient descent methods. In practice, NAG often performs better than HB, but the reasons for this difference have not been well understood theoretically.
Technical Explanation
This paper aims to provide a theoretical explanation for the observed performance difference between HB and NAG when training over-parameterized two-layer ReLU neural networks with random initialization.
The researchers leveraged advanced mathematical techniques, including high-resolution dynamical systems and neural tangent kernel (NTK) theory, to derive tighter upper bounds on the convergence rates of both HB and NAG in this setting. Importantly, their analysis provides the first theoretical guarantee that NAG can accelerate the training process compared to HB for neural networks.
To validate their theoretical findings, the researchers conducted experiments on three benchmark datasets, confirming the superior performance of NAG over HB in practice.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a valuable theoretical contribution by providing a rigorous analysis of the convergence properties of HB and NAG in the context of training over-parameterized neural networks. This helps to bridge the gap between the observed practical performance of these methods and the lack of theoretical understanding.
However, the analysis is limited to a specific neural network architecture (two-layer ReLU) and the over-parameterized regime. It would be interesting to see if the results generalize to deeper or more complex network architectures, as well as to settings where the network is not over-parameterized.
Additionally, the paper does not address potential challenges or limitations that may arise in applying these methods to real-world neural network training scenarios, such as the impact of noisy gradients, variable batch sizes, or other practical considerations.
Nonetheless, the insights provided in this paper contribute to a better understanding of the convergence behavior of first-order gradient methods in training neural networks, and may inform the development of more efficient optimization algorithms in the future.
Conclusion
This paper presents a theoretical analysis that explains the superior performance of Nesterov's accelerated gradient (NAG) method over the heavy ball (HB) method when training over-parameterized two-layer ReLU neural networks. By leveraging advanced mathematical techniques, the researchers were able to derive tighter convergence rate bounds for both methods and provide the first theoretical guarantee for the acceleration of NAG over HB.
The findings of this work contribute to a deeper understanding of the optimization dynamics of neural networks and may inform the development of more efficient training algorithms in the field of deep learning. As the field continues to evolve, further research exploring the generalization of these results to more complex network architectures and real-world training scenarios would be valuable.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔗
Momentum-based gradient descent methods for Lie groups
C'edric M. Campos, David Mart'in de Diego, Jos'e Torrente
0
0
Polyak's Heavy Ball (PHB; Polyak, 1964), a.k.a. Classical Momentum, and Nesterov's Accelerated Gradient (NAG; Nesterov, 1983) are well know examples of momentum-descent methods for optimization. While the latter outperforms the former, solely generalizations of PHB-like methods to nonlinear spaces have been described in the literature. We propose here a generalization of NAG-like methods for Lie group optimization based on the variational one-to-one correspondence between classical and accelerated momentum methods (Campos et al., 2023). Numerical experiments are shown.
4/16/2024
🏅
Accelerated Policy Gradient: On the Convergence Rates of the Nesterov Momentum for Reinforcement Learning
Yen-Ju Chen, Nai-Chieh Huang, Ching-Pei Lee, Ping-Chun Hsieh
0
0
Various acceleration approaches for Policy Gradient (PG) have been analyzed within the realm of Reinforcement Learning (RL). However, the theoretical understanding of the widely used momentum-based acceleration method on PG remains largely open. In response to this gap, we adapt the celebrated Nesterov's accelerated gradient (NAG) method to policy optimization in RL, termed textit{Accelerated Policy Gradient} (APG). To demonstrate the potential of APG in achieving fast convergence, we formally prove that with the true gradient and under the softmax policy parametrization, APG converges to an optimal policy at rates: (i) $tilde{O}(1/t^2)$ with constant step sizes; (ii) $O(e^{-ct})$ with exponentially-growing step sizes. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first characterization of the convergence rates of NAG in the context of RL. Notably, our analysis relies on one interesting finding: Regardless of the parameter initialization, APG ends up entering a locally nearly-concave regime, where APG can significantly benefit from the momentum, within finite iterations. Through numerical validation and experiments on the Atari 2600 benchmarks, we confirm that APG exhibits a $tilde{O}(1/t^2)$ rate with constant step sizes and a linear convergence rate with exponentially-growing step sizes, significantly improving convergence over the standard PG.
6/7/2024
🏋️
Approximation and Gradient Descent Training with Neural Networks
G. Welper
0
0
It is well understood that neural networks with carefully hand-picked weights provide powerful function approximation and that they can be successfully trained in over-parametrized regimes. Since over-parametrization ensures zero training error, these two theories are not immediately compatible. Recent work uses the smoothness that is required for approximation results to extend a neural tangent kernel (NTK) optimization argument to an under-parametrized regime and show direct approximation bounds for networks trained by gradient flow. Since gradient flow is only an idealization of a practical method, this paper establishes analogous results for networks trained by gradient descent.
5/21/2024
Linear convergence of forward-backward accelerated algorithms without knowledge of the modulus of strong convexity
Bowen Li, Bin Shi, Ya-xiang Yuan
0
0
A significant milestone in modern gradient-based optimization was achieved with the development of Nesterov's accelerated gradient descent (NAG) method. This forward-backward technique has been further advanced with the introduction of its proximal generalization, commonly known as the fast iterative shrinkage-thresholding algorithm (FISTA), which enjoys widespread application in image science and engineering. Nonetheless, it remains unclear whether both NAG and FISTA exhibit linear convergence for strongly convex functions. Remarkably, these algorithms demonstrate convergence without requiring any prior knowledge of strongly convex modulus, and this intriguing characteristic has been acknowledged as an open problem in the comprehensive review [Chambolle and Pock, 2016, Appendix B]. In this paper, we address this question by utilizing the high-resolution ordinary differential equation (ODE) framework. Expanding upon the established phase-space representation, we emphasize the distinctive approach employed in crafting the Lyapunov function, which involves a dynamically adapting coefficient of kinetic energy that evolves throughout the iterations. Furthermore, we highlight that the linear convergence of both NAG and FISTA is independent of the parameter $r$. Additionally, we demonstrate that the square of the proximal subgradient norm likewise advances towards linear convergence.
4/10/2024