On provable privacy vulnerabilities of graph representations

Read original: arXiv:2402.04033 - Published 5/24/2024 by Ruofan Wu, Guanhua Fang, Qiying Pan, Mingyang Zhang, Tengfei Liu, Weiqiang Wang

📉

Overview

Graph representation learning (GRL) is crucial for extracting insights from complex network structures
However, GRL raises security concerns due to potential privacy vulnerabilities in these representations
This paper investigates the structural vulnerabilities in graph neural models where sensitive topological information can be inferred through edge reconstruction attacks

Plain English Explanation

Graph representation learning (GRL) is a technique used to extract meaningful insights from complex network data, such as social media connections or communication networks. However, this process can also expose sensitive information about the network structure, potentially compromising the privacy of individuals or organizations.

The paper examines a type of attack called similarity-based edge reconstruction attack (SERA), where an attacker can infer sensitive topological information by analyzing the graph representations produced by GRL models. The researchers provide a theoretical analysis of SERA, showing that it can perfectly reconstruct sparse graphs as the graph size increases.

Conversely, the paper finds that graph sparsity is a critical factor that limits the effectiveness of SERA, as demonstrated through analysis and experiments on dense stochastic block models. Additionally, the researchers explore the resilience of private graph representations produced via a noisy aggregation (NAG) mechanism against SERA attacks. They show that the NAG approach can effectively mitigate SERA attacks.

The paper also empirically examines instances where SERA can be used as a tool to understand the trade-off between privacy and utility in graph representations, providing insights into the relationship between privacy and performance in GRL.

Technical Explanation

The paper primarily focuses on the theoretical underpinnings of similarity-based edge reconstruction attacks (SERA) on graph neural models. The researchers provide a non-asymptotic analysis of SERA's reconstruction capacities, demonstrating that such attacks can perfectly reconstruct sparse graphs as the graph size increases.

Through analysis and experiments on dense stochastic block models, the paper establishes that graph sparsity is a critical factor for SERA's effectiveness. The researchers also explore the resilience of private graph representations produced via a noisy aggregation (NAG) mechanism against SERA attacks, providing theoretical analysis and empirical assessments that confirm the mitigation of SERA using NAG.

Additionally, the paper empirically delineates instances where SERA can function as an instrument for elucidating the trade-off between privacy and utility in graph representations, shedding light on the interplay between privacy protection and model performance in the context of GRL.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive theoretical and empirical analysis of the structural vulnerabilities in graph neural models, particularly in the context of edge reconstruction attacks. The researchers' insights into the role of graph sparsity and the effectiveness of the NAG mechanism in mitigating SERA attacks are valuable contributions to the field.

However, the paper does not address potential limitations or caveats of the research, such as the impact of different graph topologies or the scalability of the NAG mechanism for large-scale networks. Additionally, the paper does not delve into the broader societal implications of these privacy vulnerabilities in graph representations, which could be an area for further exploration.

Readers should critically evaluate the research findings and consider the potential trade-offs between privacy protection and model utility in the context of their specific applications. As with any security-related research, it is essential to balance the need for transparency and the mitigation of potential harms.

Conclusion

This paper offers a detailed investigation into the structural vulnerabilities of graph neural models, highlighting the potential for sensitive topological information to be inferred through edge reconstruction attacks. The researchers' theoretical and empirical analyses provide valuable insights into the role of graph sparsity and the effectiveness of the noisy aggregation mechanism in mitigating these attacks.

The findings of this study have important implications for the development of secure and privacy-preserving graph representation learning techniques, which are increasingly crucial for extracting insights from complex network data. By understanding the trade-offs between privacy and utility, researchers and practitioners can work towards designing GRL models that balance the need for accurate and informative representations with the imperative of protecting individual and organizational privacy.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

📉

On provable privacy vulnerabilities of graph representations

Ruofan Wu, Guanhua Fang, Qiying Pan, Mingyang Zhang, Tengfei Liu, Weiqiang Wang

Graph representation learning (GRL) is critical for extracting insights from complex network structures, but it also raises security concerns due to potential privacy vulnerabilities in these representations. This paper investigates the structural vulnerabilities in graph neural models where sensitive topological information can be inferred through edge reconstruction attacks. Our research primarily addresses the theoretical underpinnings of similarity-based edge reconstruction attacks (SERA), furnishing a non-asymptotic analysis of their reconstruction capacities. Moreover, we present empirical corroboration indicating that such attacks can perfectly reconstruct sparse graphs as graph size increases. Conversely, we establish that sparsity is a critical factor for SERA's effectiveness, as demonstrated through analysis and experiments on (dense) stochastic block models. Finally, we explore the resilience of private graph representations produced via noisy aggregation (NAG) mechanism against SERA. Through theoretical analysis and empirical assessments, we affirm the mitigation of SERA using NAG . In parallel, we also empirically delineate instances wherein SERA demonstrates both efficacy and deficiency in its capacity to function as an instrument for elucidating the trade-off between privacy and utility.

5/24/2024

ExGRG: Explicitly-Generated Relation Graph for Self-Supervised Representation Learning

Mahdi Naseri, Mahdi Biparva

Self-supervised Learning (SSL) has emerged as a powerful technique in pre-training deep learning models without relying on expensive annotated labels, instead leveraging embedded signals in unlabeled data. While SSL has shown remarkable success in computer vision tasks through intuitive data augmentation, its application to graph-structured data poses challenges due to the semantic-altering and counter-intuitive nature of graph augmentations. Addressing this limitation, this paper introduces a novel non-contrastive SSL approach to Explicitly Generate a compositional Relation Graph (ExGRG) instead of relying solely on the conventional augmentation-based implicit relation graph. ExGRG offers a framework for incorporating prior domain knowledge and online extracted information into the SSL invariance objective, drawing inspiration from the Laplacian Eigenmap and Expectation-Maximization (EM). Employing an EM perspective on SSL, our E-step involves relation graph generation to identify candidates to guide the SSL invariance objective, and M-step updates the model parameters by integrating the derived relational information. Extensive experimentation on diverse node classification datasets demonstrates the superiority of our method over state-of-the-art techniques, affirming ExGRG as an effective adoption of SSL for graph representation learning.

6/5/2024

Unveiling Privacy Vulnerabilities: Investigating the Role of Structure in Graph Data

Hanyang Yuan, Jiarong Xu, Cong Wang, Ziqi Yang, Chunping Wang, Keting Yin, Yang Yang

The public sharing of user information opens the door for adversaries to infer private data, leading to privacy breaches and facilitating malicious activities. While numerous studies have concentrated on privacy leakage via public user attributes, the threats associated with the exposure of user relationships, particularly through network structure, are often neglected. This study aims to fill this critical gap by advancing the understanding and protection against privacy risks emanating from network structure, moving beyond direct connections with neighbors to include the broader implications of indirect network structural patterns. To achieve this, we first investigate the problem of Graph Privacy Leakage via Structure (GPS), and introduce a novel measure, the Generalized Homophily Ratio, to quantify the various mechanisms contributing to privacy breach risks in GPS. Based on this insight, we develop a novel graph private attribute inference attack, which acts as a pivotal tool for evaluating the potential for privacy leakage through network structures under worst-case scenarios. To protect users' private data from such vulnerabilities, we propose a graph data publishing method incorporating a learnable graph sampling technique, effectively transforming the original graph into a privacy-preserving version. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our attack model poses a significant threat to user privacy, and our graph data publishing method successfully achieves the optimal privacy-utility trade-off compared to baselines.

7/29/2024

🧠

Local Differential Privacy in Graph Neural Networks: a Reconstruction Approach

Karuna Bhaila, Wen Huang, Yongkai Wu, Xintao Wu

Graph Neural Networks have achieved tremendous success in modeling complex graph data in a variety of applications. However, there are limited studies investigating privacy protection in GNNs. In this work, we propose a learning framework that can provide node privacy at the user level, while incurring low utility loss. We focus on a decentralized notion of Differential Privacy, namely Local Differential Privacy, and apply randomization mechanisms to perturb both feature and label data at the node level before the data is collected by a central server for model training. Specifically, we investigate the application of randomization mechanisms in high-dimensional feature settings and propose an LDP protocol with strict privacy guarantees. Based on frequency estimation in statistical analysis of randomized data, we develop reconstruction methods to approximate features and labels from perturbed data. We also formulate this learning framework to utilize frequency estimates of graph clusters to supervise the training procedure at a sub-graph level. Extensive experiments on real-world and semi-synthetic datasets demonstrate the validity of our proposed model.

8/7/2024