QROA: A Black-Box Query-Response Optimization Attack on LLMs
0
🛠️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces the Query-Response Optimization Attack (QROA), a method for exploiting large language models (LLMs) by generating harmful content through a black-box, query-only interaction.
- Unlike previous approaches, QROA does not require access to the model's internal data, and instead operates solely through the standard query-response interface of LLMs.
- The method iteratively updates tokens to maximize a designed reward function, inspired by deep Q-learning and Greedy coordinate descent.
- The researchers tested QROA on various LLMs, including Vicuna, Falcon, and [Mistral], achieving an Attack Success Rate (ASR) over 80%.
- They also tested the method against Llama2-chat, the fine-tuned version of Llama2 designed to resist Jailbreak attacks, and achieved good ASR with a suboptimal initial trigger seed.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) have become increasingly popular, but they can also be manipulated to generate harmful content. This study introduces a new technique called the Query-Response Optimization Attack (QROA) that can exploit LLMs through a simple interaction, without needing access to the model's internal workings.
The researchers developed a method that iteratively adjusts the words in a query to a language model, with the goal of generating a harmful response. This is inspired by techniques used in machine learning, like deep Q-learning and greedy coordinate descent.
The researchers tested this method on several different LLMs, including Vicuna, Falcon, and [Mistral]. They were able to get the models to generate harmful content over 80% of the time.
They also tested the method on Llama2-chat, a version of the Llama2 model that was designed to resist this kind of attack. Even in this case, they were able to achieve good success rates, though not as high as with the other models.
This research shows that even language models that are designed to be safe can be vulnerable to manipulation through careful optimization of the inputs. This highlights the need for more comprehensive testing and safeguards to ensure the safety of these powerful AI systems.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed the Query-Response Optimization Attack (QROA), a black-box, query-only method for exploiting large language models (LLMs) to generate harmful content. Unlike previous approaches, QROA does not require access to the model's logit information or other internal data, and instead operates solely through the standard query-response interface.
The method is inspired by deep Q-learning and Greedy coordinate descent. It iteratively updates the tokens in a query to maximize a designed reward function, which is aimed at generating a harmful response from the target LLM.
The researchers tested QROA on various LLMs, including Vicuna, Falcon, and [Mistral], achieving an Attack Success Rate (ASR) over 80%. They also tested the method against Llama2-chat, the fine-tuned version of Llama2 designed to resist Jailbreak attacks, and were able to achieve good ASR with a suboptimal initial trigger seed.
The results demonstrate the feasibility of generating jailbreak attacks against deployed LLMs in the public domain using black-box optimization methods, which is an important finding for the comprehensive safety testing of these models.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge that their method, while effective, has some limitations. They note that the initial trigger seed used in the attack on Llama2-chat was suboptimal, suggesting that further refinement of the optimization process could lead to even higher success rates.
Additionally, the paper does not address the potential for the QROA method to be detected and mitigated by advanced security measures implemented by LLM providers. It would be valuable for future research to explore the robustness of the QROA approach against various defense mechanisms, such as those described in Improved Generation of Adversarial Examples Against Safety-Aligned Language Models and Phantom: A General Trigger Attack for Retrieval-Augmented Language Models.
Furthermore, the paper focuses on the technical feasibility of the QROA method, but does not delve into the broader ethical and societal implications of such attacks. It would be important for future work to consider the potential real-world impact of these vulnerabilities and how they can be responsibly addressed.
Conclusion
This study introduces the Query-Response Optimization Attack (QROA), a black-box, query-only method for exploiting large language models (LLMs) to generate harmful content. The researchers demonstrated the effectiveness of QROA in achieving high Attack Success Rates (ASR) against various LLMs, including models designed to resist such attacks.
The findings of this research highlight the need for more comprehensive safety testing and robust defense mechanisms to ensure the reliable and responsible deployment of LLMs. As these powerful AI systems become more ubiquitous, it is crucial that their vulnerabilities are thoroughly understood and addressed to mitigate the potential for misuse and harm.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
0
QROA: A Black-Box Query-Response Optimization Attack on LLMs
Hussein Jawad (LaMME), Nicolas J. -B. BRUNEL (LaMME)
Large Language Models (LLMs) have surged in popularity in recent months, yet they possess concerning capabilities for generating harmful content when manipulated. This study introduces the Query-Response Optimization Attack (QROA), an optimization-based strategy designed to exploit LLMs through a black-box, query-only interaction. QROA adds an optimized trigger to a malicious instruction to compel the LLM to generate harmful content. Unlike previous approaches, QROA does not require access to the model's logit information or any other internal data and operates solely through the standard query-response interface of LLMs. Inspired by deep Q-learning and Greedy coordinate descent, the method iteratively updates tokens to maximize a designed reward function. We tested our method on various LLMs such as Vicuna, Falcon, and Mistral, achieving an Attack Success Rate (ASR) over 80%. We also tested the model against Llama2-chat, the fine-tuned version of Llama2 designed to resist Jailbreak attacks, achieving good ASR with a suboptimal initial trigger seed. This study demonstrates the feasibility of generating jailbreak attacks against deployed LLMs in the public domain using black-box optimization methods, enabling more comprehensive safety testing of LLMs.
Read more6/5/2024
0
Making Them Ask and Answer: Jailbreaking Large Language Models in Few Queries via Disguise and Reconstruction
Tong Liu, Yingjie Zhang, Zhe Zhao, Yinpeng Dong, Guozhu Meng, Kai Chen
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated notable success across various tasks, but the trustworthiness of LLMs is still an open problem. One specific threat is the potential to generate toxic or harmful responses. Attackers can craft adversarial prompts that induce harmful responses from LLMs. In this work, we pioneer a theoretical foundation in LLMs security by identifying bias vulnerabilities within the safety fine-tuning and design a black-box jailbreak method named DRA (Disguise and Reconstruction Attack), which conceals harmful instructions through disguise and prompts the model to reconstruct the original harmful instruction within its completion. We evaluate DRA across various open-source and closed-source models, showcasing state-of-the-art jailbreak success rates and attack efficiency. Notably, DRA boasts a 91.1% attack success rate on OpenAI GPT-4 chatbot.
Read more6/11/2024
0
Learning to Correct for QA Reasoning with Black-box LLMs
Jaehyung Kim, Dongyoung Kim, Yiming Yang
An open challenge in recent machine learning is about how to improve the reasoning capability of large language models (LLMs) in a black-box setting, i.e., without access to detailed information such as output token probabilities. Existing approaches either rely on accessibility (which is often unrealistic) or involve significantly increased train- and inference-time costs. This paper addresses those limitations or shortcomings by proposing a novel approach, namely CoBB (Correct for improving QA reasoning of Black-Box LLMs). It uses a trained adaptation model to perform a seq2seq mapping from the often-imperfect reasonings of the original black-box LLM to the correct or improved reasonings. Specifically, the adaptation model is initialized with a relatively small open-source LLM and adapted over a collection of sub-sampled training pairs. To select the representative pairs of correct and incorrect reasonings, we formulated the dataset construction as an optimization problem that minimizes the statistical divergence between the sampled subset and the entire collection, and solved it via a genetic algorithm. We then train the adaptation model over the sampled pairs by contrasting the likelihoods of correct and incorrect reasonings. Our experimental results demonstrate that CoBB significantly improves reasoning accuracy across various QA benchmarks, compared to the best-performing adaptation baselines.
Read more6/28/2024
👀
1
Defending Against Alignment-Breaking Attacks via Robustly Aligned LLM
Bochuan Cao, Yuanpu Cao, Lu Lin, Jinghui Chen
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant advancements and are now widely used across various domains. Unfortunately, there has been a rising concern that LLMs can be misused to generate harmful or malicious content. Though a line of research has focused on aligning LLMs with human values and preventing them from producing inappropriate content, such alignments are usually vulnerable and can be bypassed by alignment-breaking attacks via adversarially optimized or handcrafted jailbreaking prompts. In this work, we introduce a Robustly Aligned LLM (RA-LLM) to defend against potential alignment-breaking attacks. RA-LLM can be directly constructed upon an existing aligned LLM with a robust alignment checking function, without requiring any expensive retraining or fine-tuning process of the original LLM. Furthermore, we also provide a theoretical analysis for RA-LLM to verify its effectiveness in defending against alignment-breaking attacks. Through real-world experiments on open-source large language models, we demonstrate that RA-LLM can successfully defend against both state-of-the-art adversarial prompts and popular handcrafted jailbreaking prompts by reducing their attack success rates from nearly 100% to around 10% or less.
Read more6/13/2024