A Qualitative Study on Using ChatGPT for Software Security: Perception vs. Practicality
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Examines perceptions and practical applications of using ChatGPT for software security
- Qualitative study involving interviews with software security experts
- Explores the potential benefits and limitations of using large language models like ChatGPT for security tasks
Plain English Explanation
This research paper looks at how software security experts view the use of ChatGPT, a powerful AI language model, for tasks related to software security. The researchers conducted interviews with these experts to understand their perceptions and experiences with using ChatGPT in this context.
The key focus is on exploring the potential benefits that ChatGPT and similar large language models could offer for software security, as well as the practical challenges and limitations that may arise. For example, the researchers investigate whether ChatGPT could be used to assist with tasks like identifying software vulnerabilities, generating secure code, or automating certain security analyses.
By gathering insights directly from software security experts, the researchers aim to provide a nuanced understanding of the real-world applicability and limitations of using large language models like ChatGPT for security-critical tasks. This can help guide future research and development in this area, as well as inform security practitioners on the practical realities of leveraging these powerful AI tools.
Technical Explanation
The researchers conducted a qualitative study involving semi-structured interviews with 15 software security experts. The participants were selected based on their experience and expertise in areas such as vulnerability management, secure coding, and security analysis.
During the interviews, the researchers explored the participants' perceptions and experiences with using ChatGPT for various software security tasks. Topics covered included the potential benefits of using ChatGPT, such as automating certain security-related tasks or improving the consistency of code analysis, as well as the practical challenges and limitations, such as ensuring the reliability and trustworthiness of ChatGPT's outputs.
The researchers used a thematic analysis approach to identify key themes and patterns in the interview data. This allowed them to gain a deeper understanding of the software security experts' perceptions and the factors that shape their views on the use of large language models like ChatGPT for security-related tasks.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into the real-world perceptions and practical considerations of using ChatGPT for software security. However, it is important to note that the findings are based on a relatively small sample size of 15 participants, which may limit the generalizability of the results.
Additionally, the research focuses on the use of ChatGPT specifically, and it is unclear how the findings may translate to other large language models or AI-based tools for security tasks. Further research may be needed to explore the applicability of the insights to a broader range of AI-powered security solutions.
The paper also acknowledges that the study was conducted at a relatively early stage in the development and adoption of large language models for security-related applications. As the technology continues to evolve and mature, the perceptions and practical considerations of security experts may change over time, warranting further investigation.
Conclusion
This qualitative study provides valuable insights into the perceptions and practical considerations of using ChatGPT for software security tasks, as reported by a group of security experts. The findings suggest that while large language models like ChatGPT may offer potential benefits, there are also significant concerns and limitations that need to be addressed before they can be widely adopted for security-critical applications.
The research highlights the importance of engaging with domain experts to understand the real-world applicability and limitations of emerging AI technologies, particularly in sensitive and high-stakes areas like software security. The insights gained can help guide future research and development efforts, as well as inform security practitioners on the practical realities of leveraging these powerful AI tools.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
A Qualitative Study on Using ChatGPT for Software Security: Perception vs. Practicality
M. Mehdi Kholoosi, M. Ali Babar, Roland Croft
Artificial Intelligence (AI) advancements have enabled the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) that can perform a variety of tasks with remarkable semantic understanding and accuracy. ChatGPT is one such LLM that has gained significant attention due to its impressive capabilities for assisting in various knowledge-intensive tasks. Due to the knowledge-intensive nature of engineering secure software, ChatGPT's assistance is expected to be explored for security-related tasks during the development/evolution of software. To gain an understanding of the potential of ChatGPT as an emerging technology for supporting software security, we adopted a two-fold approach. Initially, we performed an empirical study to analyse the perceptions of those who had explored the use of ChatGPT for security tasks and shared their views on Twitter. It was determined that security practitioners view ChatGPT as beneficial for various software security tasks, including vulnerability detection, information retrieval, and penetration testing. Secondly, we designed an experiment aimed at investigating the practicality of this technology when deployed as an oracle in real-world settings. In particular, we focused on vulnerability detection and qualitatively examined ChatGPT outputs for given prompts within this prominent software security task. Based on our analysis, responses from ChatGPT in this task are largely filled with generic security information and may not be appropriate for industry use. To prevent data leakage, we performed this analysis on a vulnerability dataset compiled after the OpenAI data cut-off date from real-world projects covering 40 distinct vulnerability types and 12 programming languages. We assert that the findings from this study would contribute to future research aimed at developing and evaluating LLMs dedicated to software security.
Read more8/2/2024
🛠️
0
Exploring ChatGPT's Capabilities on Vulnerability Management
Peiyu Liu, Junming Liu, Lirong Fu, Kangjie Lu, Yifan Xia, Xuhong Zhang, Wenzhi Chen, Haiqin Weng, Shouling Ji, Wenhai Wang
Recently, ChatGPT has attracted great attention from the code analysis domain. Prior works show that ChatGPT has the capabilities of processing foundational code analysis tasks, such as abstract syntax tree generation, which indicates the potential of using ChatGPT to comprehend code syntax and static behaviors. However, it is unclear whether ChatGPT can complete more complicated real-world vulnerability management tasks, such as the prediction of security relevance and patch correctness, which require an all-encompassing understanding of various aspects, including code syntax, program semantics, and related manual comments. In this paper, we explore ChatGPT's capabilities on 6 tasks involving the complete vulnerability management process with a large-scale dataset containing 70,346 samples. For each task, we compare ChatGPT against SOTA approaches, investigate the impact of different prompts, and explore the difficulties. The results suggest promising potential in leveraging ChatGPT to assist vulnerability management. One notable example is ChatGPT's proficiency in tasks like generating titles for software bug reports. Furthermore, our findings reveal the difficulties encountered by ChatGPT and shed light on promising future directions. For instance, directly providing random demonstration examples in the prompt cannot consistently guarantee good performance in vulnerability management. By contrast, leveraging ChatGPT in a self-heuristic way -- extracting expertise from demonstration examples itself and integrating the extracted expertise in the prompt is a promising research direction. Besides, ChatGPT may misunderstand and misuse the information in the prompt. Consequently, effectively guiding ChatGPT to focus on helpful information rather than the irrelevant content is still an open problem.
Read more6/21/2024
✨
0
Beyond Code Generation: An Observational Study of ChatGPT Usage in Software Engineering Practice
Ranim Khojah, Mazen Mohamad, Philipp Leitner, Francisco Gomes de Oliveira Neto
Large Language Models (LLMs) are frequently discussed in academia and the general public as support tools for virtually any use case that relies on the production of text, including software engineering. Currently there is much debate, but little empirical evidence, regarding the practical usefulness of LLM-based tools such as ChatGPT for engineers in industry. We conduct an observational study of 24 professional software engineers who have been using ChatGPT over a period of one week in their jobs, and qualitatively analyse their dialogues with the chatbot as well as their overall experience (as captured by an exit survey). We find that, rather than expecting ChatGPT to generate ready-to-use software artifacts (e.g., code), practitioners more often use ChatGPT to receive guidance on how to solve their tasks or learn about a topic in more abstract terms. We also propose a theoretical framework for how (i) purpose of the interaction, (ii) internal factors (e.g., the user's personality), and (iii) external factors (e.g., company policy) together shape the experience (in terms of perceived usefulness and trust). We envision that our framework can be used by future research to further the academic discussion on LLM usage by software engineering practitioners, and to serve as a reference point for the design of future empirical LLM research in this domain.
Read more5/22/2024
0
Redefining Qualitative Analysis in the AI Era: Utilizing ChatGPT for Efficient Thematic Analysis
He Zhang, Chuhao Wu, Jingyi Xie, Yao Lyu, Jie Cai, John M. Carroll
AI tools, particularly large-scale language model (LLM) based applications such as ChatGPT, have the potential to simplify qualitative research. Through semi-structured interviews with seventeen participants, we identified challenges and concerns in integrating ChatGPT into the qualitative analysis process. Collaborating with thirteen qualitative researchers, we developed a framework for designing prompts to enhance the effectiveness of ChatGPT in thematic analysis. Our findings indicate that improving transparency, providing guidance on prompts, and strengthening users' understanding of LLMs' capabilities significantly enhance the users' ability to interact with ChatGPT. We also discovered and revealed the reasons behind researchers' shift in attitude towards ChatGPT from negative to positive. This research not only highlights the importance of well-designed prompts in LLM applications but also offers reflections for qualitative researchers on the perception of AI's role. Finally, we emphasize the potential ethical risks and the impact of constructing AI ethical expectations by researchers, particularly those who are novices, on future research and AI development.
Read more5/29/2024