Reconciling Security and Utility in Next-Generation Epidemic Risk Mitigation Systems

Read original: arXiv:2011.08069 - Published 5/10/2024 by Pierfrancesco Ingo, Nichole Boufford, Ming Cheng Jiang, Rowan Lindsay, Matthew Lentz, Gilles Barthe, Manuel Gomez-Rodriguez, Bernhard Scholkopf, Deepak Garg, Peter Druschel and 1 other

🐍

Overview

The paper presents Silmarillion, a system designed to enable effective contact tracing and epidemiological analysis during disease outbreaks, while preserving user privacy.
Silmarillion collects enriched data from Bluetooth encounters with strategically placed beacons, including location information and environmental conditions, without compromising user privacy.
The goal is to provide a balance between data collection for analytics and preserving user privacy, addressing the limitations of previous digital contact tracing systems.

Plain English Explanation

When diseases like COVID-19 spread, public health officials need to quickly identify who has been in contact with infected individuals to contain the outbreak. Digital contact tracing systems have been developed to help with this, but they've faced a tradeoff between collecting enough data for effective analysis and protecting people's privacy.

Silmarillion is a new system that aims to solve this problem. It uses Bluetooth technology to track when people's devices come into close contact with special beacons installed in strategic locations. These beacons also record information about the location, such as the type of place (e.g., office, restaurant) and environmental conditions.

This enriched data allows for more detailed analysis of how the disease is spreading, which can help public health officials make better decisions about containing the outbreak. At the same time, Silmarillion is designed to protect people's privacy just as much as manual contact tracing or other digital systems, so participants and non-participants are all treated the same way.

The researchers have built a prototype of Silmarillion and tested it, finding that it has low power consumption and fast response times, making it practical for real-world use. They've also done a small-scale deployment in a university building to demonstrate how it could work in practice.

Technical Explanation

Silmarillion is a contact tracing system that collects enriched data from Bluetooth encounters with strategically placed beacons, while preserving user privacy. The key elements of the system are:

Beacon Design: Silmarillion uses Bluetooth beacons installed in various locations to record encounters with nearby user devices. These beacons also collect contextual information about the location, such as GPS coordinates, type of location (e.g., office, restaurant), and environmental conditions (e.g., temperature, humidity).
Privacy-Preserving Protocols: Silmarillion employs privacy-preserving communication protocols to ensure that user data is protected. User devices only store encrypted, anonymized encounter data, and the beacons do not have any personal information about the users.
Enriched Data Collection: The combination of Bluetooth encounter data and contextual location information enables more detailed epidemiological analysis. This can help predict disease transmission patterns and provide personalized exposure risk notifications to users.
Prototype Implementation: The researchers have built a prototype of Silmarillion using low-cost IoT boards, demonstrating its feasibility in terms of power consumption and user latency for practical deployment.
Real-World Deployment: A small-scale deployment of Silmarillion within a university building has been conducted as a proof-of-concept, showing how the system can be used in a real-world setting.

Critical Analysis

The Silmarillion system addresses an important challenge in the design of digital contact tracing systems – balancing data collection for effective epidemiological analysis with preserving user privacy. By enriching the Bluetooth encounter data with contextual location information, the system can provide more detailed insights into disease transmission patterns.

However, the paper does not discuss the scalability of the system or the potential challenges in deploying it at a larger scale. Additionally, the small-scale deployment described in the paper may not be sufficient to fully evaluate the system's performance and user acceptance in a real-world setting.

Further research could explore the feasibility of Silmarillion in different environments, the impact of user adoption on the system's effectiveness, and any potential security vulnerabilities or privacy concerns that may arise in a large-scale deployment. Addressing these challenges could help ensure that Silmarillion is a practical and trustworthy solution for future disease outbreaks.

Conclusion

The Silmarillion system presents a promising approach to contact tracing that aims to reconcile the need for rich data collection with the preservation of user privacy. By integrating Bluetooth encounter data with contextual location information, the system can enable more accurate epidemiological analysis and personalized exposure risk notification, while still maintaining a high level of privacy protection.

The prototype implementation and small-scale deployment demonstrate the technical feasibility of Silmarillion, but further research is needed to evaluate its scalability and real-world effectiveness. Addressing potential challenges around security, privacy, and user acceptance could help ensure that Silmarillion, or similar privacy-preserving data generation approaches, become a valuable tool in the fight against future disease outbreaks.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🐍

Reconciling Security and Utility in Next-Generation Epidemic Risk Mitigation Systems

Pierfrancesco Ingo, Nichole Boufford, Ming Cheng Jiang, Rowan Lindsay, Matthew Lentz, Gilles Barthe, Manuel Gomez-Rodriguez, Bernhard Scholkopf, Deepak Garg, Peter Druschel, Aastha Mehta

Epidemics like the recent COVID-19 require proactive contact tracing and epidemiological analysis to predict and subsequently contain infection transmissions. The proactive measures require large scale data collection, which simultaneously raise concerns regarding users' privacy. Digital contact tracing systems developed in response to COVID-19 either collected extensive data for effective analytics at the cost of users' privacy or collected minimal data for the sake of user privacy but were ineffective in predicting and mitigating the epidemic risks. We present Silmarillion--in preparation for future epidemics--a system that reconciles user's privacy with rich data collection for higher utility. In Silmarillion, user devices record Bluetooth encounters with beacons installed in strategic locations. The beacons further enrich the encounters with geo-location, location type, and environment conditions at the beacon installation site. This enriched information enables detailed scientific analysis of disease parameters as well as more accurate personalized exposure risk notification. At the same time, Silmarillion provides privacy to all participants and non-participants at the same level as that guaranteed in digital and manual contact tracing. We describe the design of Silmarillion and its communication protocols that ensure user privacy and data security. We also evaluate a prototype of Silmarillion built using low-end IoT boards, showing that the power consumption and user latencies are adequately low for a practical deployment. Finally, we briefly report on a small-scale deployment within a university building as a proof-of-concept.

5/10/2024

DNA: Differentially private Neural Augmentation for contact tracing

Rob Romijnders, Christos Louizos, Yuki M. Asano, Max Welling

The COVID19 pandemic had enormous economic and societal consequences. Contact tracing is an effective way to reduce infection rates by detecting potential virus carriers early. However, this was not generally adopted in the recent pandemic, and privacy concerns are cited as the most important reason. We substantially improve the privacy guarantees of the current state of the art in decentralized contact tracing. Whereas previous work was based on statistical inference only, we augment the inference with a learned neural network and ensure that this neural augmentation satisfies differential privacy. In a simulator for COVID19, even at epsilon=1 per message, this can significantly improve the detection of potentially infected individuals and, as a result of targeted testing, reduce infection rates. This work marks an important first step in integrating deep learning into contact tracing while maintaining essential privacy guarantees.

4/23/2024

🔄

Effectiveness of probabilistic contact tracing in epidemic containment: the role of super-spreaders and transmission path reconstruction

A. P. Muntoni, F. Mazza, A. Braunstein, G. Catania, L. Dall'Asta

The recent COVID-19 pandemic underscores the significance of early-stage non-pharmacological intervention strategies. The widespread use of masks and the systematic implementation of contact tracing strategies provide a potentially equally effective and socially less impactful alternative to more conventional approaches, such as large-scale mobility restrictions. However, manual contact tracing faces strong limitations in accessing the network of contacts, and the scalability of currently implemented protocols for smartphone-based digital contact tracing becomes impractical during the rapid expansion phases of the outbreaks, due to the surge in exposure notifications and associated tests. A substantial improvement in digital contact tracing can be obtained through the integration of probabilistic techniques for risk assessment that can more effectively guide the allocation of new diagnostic tests. In this study, we first quantitatively analyze the diagnostic and social costs associated with these containment measures based on contact tracing, employing three state-of-the-art models of SARS-CoV-2 spreading. Our results suggest that probabilistic techniques allow for more effective mitigation at a lower cost. Secondly, our findings reveal a remarkable efficacy of probabilistic contact-tracing techniques in performing backward and multi-step tracing and capturing super-spreading events.

9/2/2024

SoK: Can Trajectory Generation Combine Privacy and Utility?

Erik Buchholz, Alsharif Abuadbba, Shuo Wang, Surya Nepal, Salil S. Kanhere

While location trajectories represent a valuable data source for analyses and location-based services, they can reveal sensitive information, such as political and religious preferences. Differentially private publication mechanisms have been proposed to allow for analyses under rigorous privacy guarantees. However, the traditional protection schemes suffer from a limiting privacy-utility trade-off and are vulnerable to correlation and reconstruction attacks. Synthetic trajectory data generation and release represent a promising alternative to protection algorithms. While initial proposals achieve remarkable utility, they fail to provide rigorous privacy guarantees. This paper proposes a framework for designing a privacy-preserving trajectory publication approach by defining five design goals, particularly stressing the importance of choosing an appropriate Unit of Privacy. Based on this framework, we briefly discuss the existing trajectory protection approaches, emphasising their shortcomings. This work focuses on the systematisation of the state-of-the-art generative models for trajectories in the context of the proposed framework. We find that no existing solution satisfies all requirements. Thus, we perform an experimental study evaluating the applicability of six sequential generative models to the trajectory domain. Finally, we conclude that a generative trajectory model providing semantic guarantees remains an open research question and propose concrete next steps for future research.

6/28/2024