SoK: Can Trajectory Generation Combine Privacy and Utility?
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper examines the challenge of balancing privacy and utility in trajectory generation models.
- It provides a comprehensive survey of the state-of-the-art in this emerging research area.
- The paper explores various techniques, including differential privacy, generative adversarial networks, and global-to-local trajectory generation.
- The goal is to enable the generation of synthetic trajectory data that preserves the statistical properties of the original data while protecting individual privacy.
Plain English Explanation
Trajectory data, such as the paths taken by people or vehicles, can provide valuable insights for urban planning, traffic management, and other applications. However, this data can also reveal sensitive information about individuals' locations and movements. Researchers are exploring ways to generate synthetic trajectory data that maintains the statistical properties of the original data, but protects the privacy of the individuals.
One approach is to use differential privacy, which adds noise to the data in a controlled way to obscure individual identities. Another is generative adversarial networks, which train a neural network to generate realistic-looking synthetic data that is difficult to distinguish from the original. A third method is global-to-local trajectory generation, which models the overall shape of trajectories first and then adds local details.
The goal of this research is to find the right balance between preserving the utility of the trajectory data for analysis and protecting the privacy of the individuals whose movements are represented in the data.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by providing background on trajectory datasets and the privacy challenges they present. It then reviews various technical approaches for preserving privacy while maintaining the utility of trajectory data:
- Differential Privacy: Techniques like Optimizing Privacy-Utility Tradeoffs for Group Interests through Differentially Private Synthetic Data Generation add noise to the data in a controlled way to obscure individual identities while preserving aggregate statistics.
- Generative Adversarial Networks: Methods such as ST-DPGAN: A Privacy-Preserving Framework for Spatio-Temporal Data Publishing with Utility Guarantee use generative models to create synthetic trajectory data that is statistically similar to the original but harder to link back to individuals.
- Global-to-Local Trajectory Generation: Approaches like G2LTraj: A Global-to-Local Generation Approach for Trajectory Data model the overall shape of trajectories first and then add local details, helping to preserve high-level patterns while obscuring individual movements.
The paper also discusses the challenges and limitations of these approaches, such as the difficulty of precisely quantifying the privacy-utility tradeoff and the potential for bias in the synthetic data.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive overview of the state-of-the-art in trajectory privacy research, highlighting the key technical approaches and their trade-offs. However, it acknowledges that precisely quantifying the privacy-utility tradeoff remains a significant challenge, and that further research is needed to develop more robust and generalizable solutions.
One potential limitation is that the paper focuses primarily on technical solutions, without addressing the broader societal implications of trajectory privacy. For example, it does not discuss the ethical considerations around the use of personal movement data, or the potential for these techniques to be misused by governments or other powerful entities.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential for these techniques to be combined or applied in different contexts, such as protecting the privacy of location data from other sources, such as GPS or mobile apps.
Conclusion
This paper offers a valuable survey of the current state of research on balancing privacy and utility in trajectory generation models. The various technical approaches it covers, such as differential privacy, generative adversarial networks, and global-to-local generation, demonstrate the progress being made in this important and challenging area.
While the paper acknowledges the ongoing difficulties in precisely quantifying the privacy-utility tradeoff, it highlights the potential for these techniques to enable the use of trajectory data in a wide range of applications while protecting the privacy of individuals. As the field continues to evolve, this research will likely play a crucial role in shaping the responsible development and deployment of trajectory-based technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
SoK: Can Trajectory Generation Combine Privacy and Utility?
Erik Buchholz, Alsharif Abuadbba, Shuo Wang, Surya Nepal, Salil S. Kanhere
While location trajectories represent a valuable data source for analyses and location-based services, they can reveal sensitive information, such as political and religious preferences. Differentially private publication mechanisms have been proposed to allow for analyses under rigorous privacy guarantees. However, the traditional protection schemes suffer from a limiting privacy-utility trade-off and are vulnerable to correlation and reconstruction attacks. Synthetic trajectory data generation and release represent a promising alternative to protection algorithms. While initial proposals achieve remarkable utility, they fail to provide rigorous privacy guarantees. This paper proposes a framework for designing a privacy-preserving trajectory publication approach by defining five design goals, particularly stressing the importance of choosing an appropriate Unit of Privacy. Based on this framework, we briefly discuss the existing trajectory protection approaches, emphasising their shortcomings. This work focuses on the systematisation of the state-of-the-art generative models for trajectories in the context of the proposed framework. We find that no existing solution satisfies all requirements. Thus, we perform an experimental study evaluating the applicability of six sequential generative models to the trajectory domain. Finally, we conclude that a generative trajectory model providing semantic guarantees remains an open research question and propose concrete next steps for future research.
Read more6/28/2024
0
Synthetic Data: Revisiting the Privacy-Utility Trade-off
Fatima Jahan Sarmin, Atiquer Rahman Sarkar, Yang Wang, Noman Mohammed
Synthetic data has been considered a better privacy-preserving alternative to traditionally sanitized data across various applications. However, a recent article challenges this notion, stating that synthetic data does not provide a better trade-off between privacy and utility than traditional anonymization techniques, and that it leads to unpredictable utility loss and highly unpredictable privacy gain. The article also claims to have identified a breach in the differential privacy guarantees provided by PATEGAN and PrivBayes. When a study claims to refute or invalidate prior findings, it is crucial to verify and validate the study. In our work, we analyzed the implementation of the privacy game described in the article and found that it operated in a highly specialized and constrained environment, which limits the applicability of its findings to general cases. Our exploration also revealed that the game did not satisfy a crucial precondition concerning data distributions, which contributed to the perceived violation of the differential privacy guarantees offered by PATEGAN and PrivBayes. We also conducted a privacy-utility trade-off analysis in a more general and unconstrained environment. Our experimentation demonstrated that synthetic data achieves a more favorable privacy-utility trade-off compared to the provided implementation of k-anonymization, thereby reaffirming earlier conclusions.
Read more7/12/2024
0
Synthetic Trajectory Generation Through Convolutional Neural Networks
Jesse Merhi, Erik Buchholz, Salil S. Kanhere
Location trajectories provide valuable insights for applications from urban planning to pandemic control. However, mobility data can also reveal sensitive information about individuals, such as political opinions, religious beliefs, or sexual orientations. Existing privacy-preserving approaches for publishing this data face a significant utility-privacy trade-off. Releasing synthetic trajectory data generated through deep learning offers a promising solution. Due to the trajectories' sequential nature, most existing models are based on recurrent neural networks (RNNs). However, research in generative adversarial networks (GANs) largely employs convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for image generation. This discrepancy raises the question of whether advances in computer vision can be applied to trajectory generation. In this work, we introduce a Reversible Trajectory-to-CNN Transformation (RTCT) that adapts trajectories into a format suitable for CNN-based models. We integrated this transformation with the well-known DCGAN in a proof-of-concept (PoC) and evaluated its performance against an RNN-based trajectory GAN using four metrics across two datasets. The PoC was superior in capturing spatial distributions compared to the RNN model but had difficulty replicating sequential and temporal properties. Although the PoC's utility is not sufficient for practical applications, the results demonstrate the transformation's potential to facilitate the use of CNNs for trajectory generation, opening up avenues for future research. To support continued research, all source code has been made available under an open-source license.
Read more7/25/2024
0
PateGail: A Privacy-Preserving Mobility Trajectory Generator with Imitation Learning
Huandong Wang, Changzheng Gao, Yuchen Wu, Depeng Jin, Lina Yao, Yong Li
Generating human mobility trajectories is of great importance to solve the lack of large-scale trajectory data in numerous applications, which is caused by privacy concerns. However, existing mobility trajectory generation methods still require real-world human trajectories centrally collected as the training data, where there exists an inescapable risk of privacy leakage. To overcome this limitation, in this paper, we propose PateGail, a privacy-preserving imitation learning model to generate mobility trajectories, which utilizes the powerful generative adversary imitation learning model to simulate the decision-making process of humans. Further, in order to protect user privacy, we train this model collectively based on decentralized mobility data stored in user devices, where personal discriminators are trained locally to distinguish and reward the real and generated human trajectories. In the training process, only the generated trajectories and their rewards obtained based on personal discriminators are shared between the server and devices, whose privacy is further preserved by our proposed perturbation mechanisms with theoretical proof to satisfy differential privacy. Further, to better model the human decision-making process, we propose a novel aggregation mechanism of the rewards obtained from personal discriminators. We theoretically prove that under the reward obtained based on the aggregation mechanism, our proposed model maximizes the lower bound of the discounted total rewards of users. Extensive experiments show that the trajectories generated by our model are able to resemble real-world trajectories in terms of five key statistical metrics, outperforming state-of-the-art algorithms by over 48.03%. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the synthetic trajectories are able to efficiently support practical applications, including mobility prediction and location recommendation.
Read more7/25/2024