On Recovering Higher-order Interactions from Protein Language Models

Overview

• Protein language models can predict 3D protein structures and variant properties with state-of-the-art performance by leveraging evolutionary information.
• However, understanding the complex mutational interactions that drive these model predictions is challenging, as it requires querying a vast sequence space.
• While approaches to reduce computational complexity exist, they often limit the interpretability of the model to single and pairwise interactions.
• This paper presents a framework to systematically analyze the Fourier properties of the protein language model ESM2 and demonstrate its ability to recover complex interactions in a computationally efficient manner.

Plain English Explanation

Proteins are the building blocks of life, and their 3D structures and properties are crucial for understanding how they function. Protein language models have become a powerful tool for predicting these properties, as they can leverage the wealth of evolutionary information stored in protein sequences.

However, the complex web of interactions between different parts of a protein (known as mutational interactions) that govern the model's predictions can be difficult to understand. Traditionally, researchers have had to exhaustively test all possible combinations of mutations, which quickly becomes computationally intractable as the number of sites increases.

While some approaches have been developed to reduce the computational complexity, they often come at the cost of interpretability, limiting the analysis to only single or pairwise interactions.

In this paper, the researchers present a new framework that allows them to systematically analyze the Fourier properties of the protein language model ESM2. By doing so, they can identify regions where the model's predictions are dominated by sparse, easy-to-interpret interactions, as well as regions with more complex, dense interactions.

Through validation on two sample proteins, the researchers demonstrate that they can recover all of the relevant interactions using just a tiny fraction of the full sequence space, reducing the computational time by a factor of 15,000. This breakthrough could pave the way for a better understanding of how these powerful language models make their predictions, ultimately leading to more robust and interpretable models for protein engineering and design.

Technical Explanation

The researchers developed a framework to perform a systematic Fourier analysis of the protein language model ESM2, which has demonstrated state-of-the-art performance in 3D structure and zero-shot variant prediction.

Extracting and explaining the complex mutational interactions that govern ESM2's predictions is challenging, as it would require querying the entire amino acid space for n sites using 20^n sequences, which is computationally expensive even for moderate values of n (e.g., n~10).

While approaches to lower the sample complexity exist, such as those used for protein binding affinity prediction under multiple substitutions, they often limit the interpretability of the model to just single and pairwise interactions.

The researchers hypothesized that by analyzing the Fourier properties of ESM2, they could identify regions in the sparsity-ruggedness plane where the model's predictions are dominated by sparse, easy-to-interpret interactions, as well as regions with more complex, dense interactions.

To test this, they applied the ESM2 model to three different proteins (GFP, TP53, and GB1) across various sites, covering a total of 228 experiments. They found that ESM2's predictions were dominated by three distinct regions in the sparsity-ruggedness plane, two of which were better suited for sparse Fourier transforms.

Validations on two sample proteins demonstrated that the researchers could recover all relevant interactions with R^2=0.72 in the more sparse region and R^2=0.66 in the more dense region, using only 7 million out of ~10^13 ESM2 samples. This represents a staggering reduction in computational time by a factor of 15,000.

Critical Analysis

The researchers provide a compelling approach to systematically analyze the Fourier properties of protein language models like ESM2, allowing them to identify regions where the model's predictions are dominated by sparse, interpretable interactions. This is a significant advancement over previous methods that were limited to single and pairwise interactions.

However, the researchers acknowledge that the assumption of sparsity may not always hold, and there may be other metrics beyond sparsity that are needed to assess the utility of Fourier algorithms for extracting interactions from language models.

Additionally, the validation experiments were conducted on a limited set of three proteins, and it would be valuable to see the framework applied to a wider range of proteins to further assess its generalizability.

Future research could also explore the potential of this approach to inform the design of more interpretable protein language models, perhaps by incorporating the Fourier properties directly into the model architecture or training process.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel framework for systematically analyzing the Fourier properties of protein language models, which enables the efficient recovery of complex mutational interactions that drive the models' predictions. By identifying regions in the sparsity-ruggedness plane where the model is dominated by sparse, interpretable interactions, the researchers were able to dramatically reduce the computational complexity required to extract these insights.

The implications of this work are significant, as it paves the way for a better understanding of how these powerful language models make their predictions, ultimately leading to more robust and interpretable models for protein engineering and design. The ability to quickly and accurately recover the underlying interactions that govern a model's behavior is a crucial step towards unlocking the full potential of protein language models in various applications, from drug discovery to synthetic biology.