Relaxed Quantile Regression: Prediction Intervals for Asymmetric Noise

Overview

• Constructing valid prediction intervals is essential for quantifying uncertainty in regression tasks, especially for high-stakes decisions where simple point predictions are insufficient.
• Quantile regression is a leading approach for obtaining such intervals, but it has limitations in terms of the a priori choice of specific quantiles to learn.
• The paper proposes a new method called Relaxed Quantile Regression (RQR) that removes this arbitrary constraint while maintaining the strengths of quantile regression.

Plain English Explanation

When making predictions, it's often not enough to just give a single number as the answer. In many real-world situations, we need to know the range of possible values that the true answer could fall within, and how likely it is that the true answer will be in that range.

Quantile regression is a popular method for creating these prediction intervals. It works by estimating the distribution of possible outputs, and then using that to define a range that the true answer will fall within with a certain probability, like 95%.

However, quantile regression has a limitation – you have to choose the specific percentiles (like the 2.5th and 97.5th) that you want to use to define the interval ahead of time. This can lead to problems, like the intervals being symmetrical around the median even when the true distribution is skewed.

The new method proposed in this paper, called Relaxed Quantile Regression (RQR), removes this constraint. Instead of fixing the percentiles, RQR learns them directly from the data. This gives more flexibility to create prediction intervals that better match the true underlying distribution.

The researchers show that this added flexibility leads to prediction intervals with improved properties, like narrower average width, while still maintaining the essential coverage guarantees of quantile regression.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces Relaxed Quantile Regression (RQR), a direct alternative to quantile regression for constructing prediction intervals. Quantile regression is a well-established approach that works by estimating the quantiles of the conditional distribution of the target variable, allowing for the construction of prediction intervals with guaranteed coverage.

However, quantile regression requires the specific quantiles to be chosen a priori. This can lead to suboptimal intervals, either being arbitrarily symmetric around the median (which is often not the case for realistic, skewed distributions) or requiring the learning of an excessive number of quantiles.

RQR removes this constraint by directly learning the quantile levels from the data, rather than fixing them. This added flexibility allows the method to adapt the prediction intervals to better match the true underlying distribution. The authors demonstrate through both theoretical analysis and empirical evaluation that RQR can produce prediction intervals with improved desirable qualities, such as narrower average width, while still providing the essential coverage guarantees of quantile regression.

The technical details of the RQR approach involve formulating the problem as a constrained optimization task, where the quantile levels are learned jointly with the regression function. The authors provide a computationally efficient algorithm for solving this optimization problem and show that RQR maintains the interpretability and assumption-free nature of quantile regression.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a well-motivated and technically sound approach to addressing the limitations of quantile regression for constructing prediction intervals. The key innovation of RQR, namely the relaxation of the a priori quantile choice constraint, is a clever and principled solution that maintains the strengths of quantile regression.

One potential area for further research mentioned in the paper is the extension of RQR to handle heteroskedastic and nonlinear regression settings. Additionally, it would be interesting to explore the performance of RQR in the context of conformal prediction and confidence region construction, where the flexibility of RQR could potentially lead to improvements.

While the paper provides a thorough theoretical and empirical evaluation of RQR, it would be valuable to see further validation of the method's performance on a broader range of real-world datasets and applications. Demonstrating the practical significance and impact of RQR in high-stakes decision-making scenarios would strengthen the case for its adoption.

Conclusion

The paper presents Relaxed Quantile Regression (RQR), a novel approach for constructing prediction intervals that addresses the limitations of the widely used quantile regression method. By removing the arbitrary constraint of pre-specifying the quantile levels, RQR gains added flexibility to better adapt the prediction intervals to the true underlying distribution of the target variable.

The researchers show that this flexibility leads to intervals with improved properties, such as narrower average width, while still maintaining the essential coverage guarantees of quantile regression. This advancement in uncertainty quantification could have significant implications for high-stakes decision-making in a variety of real-world applications where simple point predictions are insufficient.

The technical merits of the RQR approach, along with the opportunities for further research and validation, suggest that this work represents an important step forward in the field of regression-based uncertainty modeling.