Removing Spurious Concepts from Neural Network Representations via Joint Subspace Estimation

Read original: arXiv:2310.11991 - Published 7/24/2024 by Floris Holstege, Bram Wouters, Noud van Giersbergen, Cees Diks

🧠

Overview

Neural networks often struggle with out-of-distribution generalization due to spurious correlations.
Existing methods to mitigate this by removing spurious concepts can inadvertently harm model performance.
This paper proposes an iterative algorithm to separate spurious from main-task concepts in neural network representations.
The algorithm is evaluated on benchmark datasets for computer vision and natural language processing, outperforming existing concept removal methods.

Plain English Explanation

When neural networks are trained on data, they can pick up on patterns that are not actually relevant to the main task. These "spurious correlations" can cause the model to perform poorly when applied to new, out-of-distribution data. A common approach to address this is to try to remove the spurious concepts from the neural network's representation of the data. However, existing methods for doing this tend to be overzealous, inadvertently eliminating features that are actually important for the model's main task, which then harms the model's overall performance.

The researchers in this paper propose a new iterative algorithm that aims to more precisely separate the spurious concepts from the main-task concepts in the neural network's representation. The key idea is to jointly identify two low-dimensional subspaces - one for the spurious concepts and one for the main-task concepts - and then use this to guide the removal of just the spurious aspects.

The researchers evaluate this algorithm on some standard benchmark datasets for computer vision and natural language processing, and show that it outperforms the existing concept removal methods. This suggests it is a promising approach for improving the out-of-distribution robustness of neural networks.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes an iterative algorithm for separating spurious from main-task concepts in the neural network representation of data. The key steps are:

Identify a set of candidate spurious and main-task concept directions in the neural network representation using an unsupervised technique.
Iteratively refine these directions by jointly optimizing for two low-dimensional orthogonal subspaces - one for the spurious concepts and one for the main-task concepts.
Use the identified subspaces to remove the spurious concepts from the neural network representation, while preserving the main-task concepts.

The algorithm is evaluated on benchmark datasets for computer vision (Waterbirds, CelebA) and natural language processing (MultiNLI). The results show that it outperforms existing concept removal methods in terms of improving the out-of-distribution generalization performance of the neural networks.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a well-designed approach for addressing the challenge of spurious correlations in neural networks. The iterative algorithm for separating spurious and main-task concepts is a clever and principled solution.

One potential limitation is that the method relies on being able to identify a set of candidate spurious and main-task concept directions in the initial step. The effectiveness of this step could depend on the specific dataset and task. The authors acknowledge this and suggest further research is needed to make this initial step more robust.

Additionally, while the evaluation on benchmark datasets is thorough, it would be interesting to see how the algorithm performs on more real-world, messy datasets where spurious correlations may be more prevalent and harder to identify.

Overall, this is an impressive piece of research that makes a valuable contribution to the challenge of improving the out-of-distribution robustness of neural networks. The proposed algorithm seems like a promising approach that warrants further investigation and refinement.

Conclusion

This paper presents an iterative algorithm for separating spurious from main-task concepts in neural network representations, which helps to improve the out-of-distribution generalization performance of the models. By jointly identifying orthogonal subspaces for the spurious and main-task concepts, the algorithm can selectively remove the spurious aspects while preserving the features that are relevant to the main task.

Evaluated on benchmark datasets, the proposed method outperforms existing concept removal techniques, demonstrating its potential as a useful tool for enhancing the robustness of neural networks. As deep learning models continue to be deployed in real-world applications, addressing the challenge of spurious correlations will be crucial for ensuring reliable and trustworthy performance. This research represents an important step forward in that direction.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🧠

Removing Spurious Concepts from Neural Network Representations via Joint Subspace Estimation

Floris Holstege, Bram Wouters, Noud van Giersbergen, Cees Diks

Out-of-distribution generalization in neural networks is often hampered by spurious correlations. A common strategy is to mitigate this by removing spurious concepts from the neural network representation of the data. Existing concept-removal methods tend to be overzealous by inadvertently eliminating features associated with the main task of the model, thereby harming model performance. We propose an iterative algorithm that separates spurious from main-task concepts by jointly identifying two low-dimensional orthogonal subspaces in the neural network representation. We evaluate the algorithm on benchmark datasets for computer vision (Waterbirds, CelebA) and natural language processing (MultiNLI), and show that it outperforms existing concept removal methods

7/24/2024

Out of spuriousity: Improving robustness to spurious correlations without group annotations

Phuong Quynh Le, Jorg Schlotterer, Christin Seifert

Machine learning models are known to learn spurious correlations, i.e., features having strong relations with class labels but no causal relation. Relying on those correlations leads to poor performance in the data groups without these correlations and poor generalization ability. To improve the robustness of machine learning models to spurious correlations, we propose an approach to extract a subnetwork from a fully trained network that does not rely on spurious correlations. The subnetwork is found by the assumption that data points with the same spurious attribute will be close to each other in the representation space when training with ERM, then we employ supervised contrastive loss in a novel way to force models to unlearn the spurious connections. The increase in the worst-group performance of our approach contributes to strengthening the hypothesis that there exists a subnetwork in a fully trained dense network that is responsible for using only invariant features in classification tasks, therefore erasing the influence of spurious features even in the setup of multi spurious attributes and no prior knowledge of attributes labels.

7/23/2024

🤖

Linear Adversarial Concept Erasure

Shauli Ravfogel, Michael Twiton, Yoav Goldberg, Ryan Cotterell

Modern neural models trained on textual data rely on pre-trained representations that emerge without direct supervision. As these representations are increasingly being used in real-world applications, the inability to emph{control} their content becomes an increasingly important problem. We formulate the problem of identifying and erasing a linear subspace that corresponds to a given concept, in order to prevent linear predictors from recovering the concept. We model this problem as a constrained, linear maximin game, and show that existing solutions are generally not optimal for this task. We derive a closed-form solution for certain objectives, and propose a convex relaxation, method, that works well for others. When evaluated in the context of binary gender removal, the method recovers a low-dimensional subspace whose removal mitigates bias by intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation. We show that the method is highly expressive, effectively mitigating bias in deep nonlinear classifiers while maintaining tractability and interpretability.

9/14/2024

Unsupervised Concept Discovery Mitigates Spurious Correlations

Md Rifat Arefin, Yan Zhang, Aristide Baratin, Francesco Locatello, Irina Rish, Dianbo Liu, Kenji Kawaguchi

Models prone to spurious correlations in training data often produce brittle predictions and introduce unintended biases. Addressing this challenge typically involves methods relying on prior knowledge and group annotation to remove spurious correlations, which may not be readily available in many applications. In this paper, we establish a novel connection between unsupervised object-centric learning and mitigation of spurious correlations. Instead of directly inferring subgroups with varying correlations with labels, our approach focuses on discovering concepts: discrete ideas that are shared across input samples. Leveraging existing object-centric representation learning, we introduce CoBalT: a concept balancing technique that effectively mitigates spurious correlations without requiring human labeling of subgroups. Evaluation across the benchmark datasets for sub-population shifts demonstrate superior or competitive performance compared state-of-the-art baselines, without the need for group annotation. Code is available at https://github.com/rarefin/CoBalT.

7/17/2024