Revisit Few-shot Intent Classification with PLMs: Direct Fine-tuning vs. Continual Pre-training

Overview

• This paper explores the task of few-shot intent detection, which involves training a deep learning model to classify utterances based on their underlying intents using only a small amount of labeled data.
• The current approach is to use continual pre-training, where pre-trained language models are fine-tuned on external resources before being used as utterance encoders for training an intent classifier.
• The authors show that continual pre-training may not be essential, as the overfitting problem of pre-trained language models on this task may not be as serious as expected.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at the problem of few-shot intent detection. This is when you have a deep learning model that needs to classify short phrases or sentences (called "utterances") based on their underlying meaning or "intent," but you only have a small amount of labeled data to train the model.

The typical approach to this problem is to first pre-train the language model on a larger dataset, then fine-tune it on the specific intent detection task. This "continual pre-training" is thought to help the model avoid overfitting on the small dataset.

However, the authors found that directly fine-tuning the pre-trained model on the limited data can actually work quite well, and the performance gap compared to continual pre-training methods decreases as more labeled data becomes available.

To get the most out of the limited data, the authors also propose a context augmentation method and use sequential self-distillation to further boost the model's performance.

Technical Explanation

The paper examines the few-shot intent detection task, where the goal is to build a model that can classify short utterances into different intents using only a small amount of labeled data. The authors show that the common approach of continual pre-training - fine-tuning pre-trained language models (PLMs) on external resources before using them as utterance encoders - may not be essential for this task.

Through experiments, the researchers found that directly fine-tuning PLMs on the limited labeled data can already yield decent results, and the performance gap compared to continual pre-training methods diminishes as the amount of labeled data increases. To maximize the use of the scarce data, the authors propose a context augmentation method and leverage sequential self-distillation, which further boosts the model's performance.

The paper presents comprehensive experiments on real-world benchmarks, demonstrating that with just two or more labeled samples per class, the direct fine-tuning approach outperforms many strong baselines that rely on external data sources for continual pre-training.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling argument that continual pre-training may not be as essential for few-shot intent detection as previously thought. The authors provide strong empirical evidence that directly fine-tuning pre-trained language models can yield competitive results, especially as the amount of labeled data increases.

One potential limitation of the study is that it focuses on a specific task (intent detection) and may not generalize to other few-shot learning scenarios. The authors acknowledge this and encourage further research to explore the broader applicability of their findings.

Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the underlying reasons why direct fine-tuning can be effective in this context. Further analysis or theoretical insights into the model's behavior and the factors contributing to its performance would help strengthen the conclusions.

Nevertheless, the paper makes a valuable contribution by challenging the prevalent assumption that continual pre-training is necessary for few-shot tasks. The authors' findings and proposed techniques, such as context augmentation and sequential self-distillation, offer promising directions for improving few-shot learning in natural language processing.

Conclusion

This paper presents an interesting alternative to the common approach of continual pre-training for few-shot intent detection. The authors demonstrate that directly fine-tuning pre-trained language models on limited labeled data can yield strong results, challenging the prevailing assumption that extensive pre-training is required.

The proposed techniques, including context augmentation and sequential self-distillation, provide effective ways to maximize the utility of scarce data and boost the model's performance. These findings have the potential to significantly streamline the development of few-shot intent detection systems, reducing the need for resource-intensive pre-training on external datasets.

Overall, this work offers valuable insights and practical solutions for researchers and practitioners working on few-shot learning problems in natural language processing. The results encourage a reconsideration of the role of continual pre-training and highlight the importance of exploring alternative approaches to address the challenges of learning from limited data.