Safe Interval RRT* for Scalable Multi-Robot Path Planning in Continuous Space
2404.01752
0
0
Abstract
In this paper, we consider the problem of Multi-Robot Path Planning (MRPP) in continuous space to find conflict-free paths. The difficulty of the problem arises from two primary factors. First, the involvement of multiple robots leads to combinatorial decision-making, which escalates the search space exponentially. Second, the continuous space presents potentially infinite states and actions. For this problem, we propose a two-level approach where the low level is a sampling-based planner Safe Interval RRT* (SI-RRT*) that finds a collision-free trajectory for individual robots. The high level can use any method that can resolve inter-robot conflicts where we employ two representative methods that are Prioritized Planning (SI-CPP) and Conflict Based Search (SI-CCBS). Experimental results show that SI-RRT* can find a high-quality solution quickly with a small number of samples. SI-CPP exhibits improved scalability while SI-CCBS produces higher-quality solutions compared to the state-of-the-art planners for continuous space. Compared to the most scalable existing algorithm, SI-CPP achieves a success rate that is up to 94% higher with 100 robots while maintaining solution quality (i.e., flowtime, the sum of travel times of all robots) without significant compromise. SI-CPP also decreases the makespan up to 45%. SI-CCBS decreases the flowtime by 9% compared to the competitor, albeit exhibiting a 14% lower success rate.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Presents a new algorithm called "Safe Interval RRT*" for scalable multi-robot path planning in continuous space
- Addresses challenges of traditional multi-robot planning approaches, including computational complexity and inability to handle dynamic obstacles
- Introduces a decentralized planning framework that allows robots to plan their paths efficiently and avoid collisions with each other and dynamic obstacles
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new algorithm called "Safe Interval RRT*" that aims to solve the problem of multi-robot path planning in continuous space. Traditional multi-robot planning approaches often struggle with computational complexity and the ability to handle dynamic obstacles, which can limit their scalability and real-world applicability.
The proposed algorithm takes a decentralized approach, allowing each robot to plan its own path efficiently while also considering the potential movements of other robots and dynamic obstacles. By using a "safe interval" concept, the robots can coordinate their actions and avoid collisions, without the need for a centralized planner to manage the entire system.
This decentralized approach helps to improve the scalability of multi-robot planning, as each robot can plan its path independently and in parallel. Additionally, the ability to handle dynamic obstacles makes the algorithm more suitable for real-world scenarios, where the environment and other agents may be constantly changing.
Technical Explanation
The key idea behind the "Safe Interval RRT*" algorithm is to extend the traditional Rapidly-exploring Random Tree (RRT*) algorithm to work in a multi-robot setting. RRT* is a popular algorithm for single-robot path planning, as it can efficiently explore the search space and find optimal paths.
The researchers introduce the concept of "safe intervals" to allow the robots to coordinate their actions and avoid collisions. Each robot maintains a "safe interval" around its current position, which represents the region of space that the robot can safely occupy without colliding with other robots or dynamic obstacles. By considering these safe intervals during the planning process, the robots can find paths that avoid potential conflicts and ensure safe operation.
The algorithm works by having each robot independently plan its path using the RRT* approach, while also considering the safe intervals of the other robots. This decentralized planning allows for efficient and scalable multi-robot coordination, as each robot can plan its own path without the need for a centralized planner.
The researchers also introduce several enhancements to the basic RRT* algorithm, such as a "lazy collision checking" approach and a "warm-start" technique, to improve the overall planning efficiency and convergence speed.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to the problem of multi-robot path planning in continuous space, addressing some of the key limitations of traditional methods. The decentralized planning framework and the use of "safe intervals" are particularly interesting, as they allow for efficient and scalable coordination without the need for a centralized planner.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations of the approach. For example, the algorithm assumes that the robots have perfect information about the positions and movements of the other robots and dynamic obstacles, which may not always be the case in real-world scenarios. The ability to handle uncertainty and partial information could be an area for further research.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the algorithm's performance in scenarios with a large number of robots or highly dynamic environments. Further testing and evaluation would be needed to assess the scalability and robustness of the approach.
Overall, the "Safe Interval RRT*" algorithm represents an interesting and promising approach to the problem of multi-robot path planning, but there are still opportunities for further research and development to address potential limitations and improve its real-world applicability.
Conclusion
The "Safe Interval RRT*" algorithm presented in this paper offers a novel solution to the challenge of multi-robot path planning in continuous space. By introducing a decentralized planning framework and the concept of "safe intervals," the algorithm aims to address the computational complexity and dynamic obstacle handling issues that have plagued traditional multi-robot planning approaches.
The key innovations of the algorithm, including its ability to coordinate robot actions without a centralized planner and its handling of dynamic obstacles, have the potential to enable more scalable and robust multi-robot systems. While the paper identifies several areas for further research, the "Safe Interval RRT*" algorithm represents an important step forward in the field of multi-robot planning and could have significant implications for a wide range of real-world applications, from autonomous transportation to search and rescue operations.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Visibility-Aware RRT* for Safety-Critical Navigation of Perception-Limited Robots in Unknown Environments
Taekyung Kim, Dimitra Panagou
0
0
Safe autonomous navigation in unknown environments remains a critical challenge for robots with limited sensing capabilities. While safety-critical control techniques, such as Control Barrier Functions (CBFs), have been proposed to ensure safety, their effectiveness relies on the assumption that the robot has complete knowledge of its surroundings. In reality, robots often operate with restricted field-of-view and finite sensing range, which can lead to collisions with unknown obstacles if the planning algorithm is agnostic to these limitations. To address this issue, we introduce the visibility-aware RRT* algorithm that combines sampling-based planning with CBFs to generate safe and efficient global reference paths in partially unknown environments. The algorithm incorporates a collision avoidance CBF and a novel visibility CBF, which guarantees that the robot remains within locally collision-free regions, enabling timely detection and avoidance of unknown obstacles. We conduct extensive experiments interfacing the path planners with two different safety-critical controllers, wherein our method outperforms all other compared baselines across both safety and efficiency aspects.
6/13/2024
New!Hierarchical Large Scale Multirobot Path (Re)Planning
Lishuo Pan, Kevin Hsu, Nora Ayanian
0
0
We consider a large-scale multi-robot path planning problem in a cluttered environment. Our approach achieves real-time replanning by dividing the workspace into cells and utilizing a hierarchical planner. Specifically, multi-commodity flow-based high-level planners route robots through the cells to reduce congestion, while an anytime low-level planner computes collision-free paths for robots within each cell in parallel. Despite resulting in longer paths compared to the baseline multi-agent pathfinding algorithm, our method produces a solution with significant improvement in computation time. Specifically, we show empirical results of a 500-times speedup in computation time compared to the baseline multi-agent pathfinding approach on the environments we study. We account for the robot's embodiment and support non-stop execution when replanning continuously. We demonstrate the real-time performance of our algorithm with up to 142 robots in simulation, and a representative 32 physical Crazyflie nano-quadrotor experiment.
7/4/2024
Search-based versus Sampling-based Robot Motion Planning: A Comparative Study
Georgios Sotirchos, Zlatan Ajanovic
0
0
Robot motion planning is a challenging domain as it involves dealing with high-dimensional and continuous search space. In past decades, a wide variety of planning algorithms have been developed to tackle this problem, sometimes in isolation without comparing to each other. In this study, we benchmark two such prominent types of algorithms: OMPL's sampling-based RRT-Connect and SMPL's search-based ARA* with motion primitives. To compare these two fundamentally different approaches fairly, we adapt them to ensure the same planning conditions and benchmark them on the same set of planning scenarios. Our findings suggest that sampling-based planners like RRT-Connect show more consistent performance across the board in high-dimensional spaces, whereas search-based planners like ARA* have the capacity to perform significantly better when used with a suitable action-space sampling scheme. Through this study, we hope to showcase the effort required to properly benchmark motion planners from different paradigms thereby contributing to a more nuanced understanding of their capabilities and limitations. The code is available at https://github.com/gsotirchos/benchmarking_planners
6/18/2024
🎲
Towards a Safe Real-Time Motion Planning Framework for Autonomous Driving Systems: An MPPI Approach
Mehdi Testouri, Gamal Elghazaly, Raphael Frank
0
0
Planning safe trajectories in Autonomous Driving Systems (ADS) is a complex problem to solve in real-time. The main challenge to solve this problem arises from the various conditions and constraints imposed by road geometry, semantics and traffic rules, as well as the presence of dynamic agents. Recently, Model Predictive Path Integral (MPPI) has shown to be an effective framework for optimal motion planning and control in robot navigation in unstructured and highly uncertain environments. In this paper, we formulate the motion planning problem in ADS as a nonlinear stochastic dynamic optimization problem that can be solved using an MPPI strategy. The main technical contribution of this work is a method to handle obstacles within the MPPI formulation safely. In this method, obstacles are approximated by circles that can be easily integrated into the MPPI cost formulation while considering safety margins. The proposed MPPI framework has been efficiently implemented in our autonomous vehicle and experimentally validated using three different primitive scenarios. Experimental results show that generated trajectories are safe, feasible and perfectly achieve the planning objective. The video results as well as the open-source implementation are available at: https://gitlab.uni.lu/360lab-public/mppi
5/7/2024