Scalable Learning of Item Response Theory Models

Read original: arXiv:2403.00680 - Published 8/16/2024 by Susanne Frick, Amer Krivov{s}ija, Alexander Munteanu
Total Score

0

Scalable Learning of Item Response Theory Models

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Presents a scalable approach for learning Item Response Theory (IRT) models
  • Aims to address the computational challenges in estimating parameters for large-scale IRT models
  • Proposes an efficient algorithm that can handle datasets with millions of responses

Plain English Explanation

Imagine you're a teacher grading a test with hundreds of multiple-choice questions. Item Response Theory (IRT) is a statistical model that can help you understand how each question relates to the students' overall knowledge. However, as the number of questions and students grows, it becomes computationally challenging to estimate the parameters of the IRT model.

This paper introduces a new, more scalable approach to learning IRT models. The key idea is to divide the data into smaller, manageable subsets and then combine the results in an efficient way. This allows the model to be trained on much larger datasets than was previously possible. The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on datasets with millions of responses, showing that it can accurately estimate the parameters of the IRT model while being much faster than traditional methods.

By making IRT models more scalable, this research could have important implications for educational assessments, adaptive learning systems, and other applications where understanding the relationship between test items and latent traits is crucial.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a new algorithm for learning Item Response Theory (IRT) models in a scalable way. IRT models are widely used in educational assessment and psychometrics to model the relationship between test items and the latent traits they measure (e.g., student knowledge).

The key challenge is that estimating the parameters of IRT models can be computationally expensive, especially for large-scale datasets with millions of responses. To address this, the authors propose a divide-and-conquer approach that partitions the data into smaller subsets, estimates the parameters on each subset independently, and then combines the results in an efficient way.

Specifically, the algorithm:

  1. Divides the data into smaller subsets, either randomly or based on item/person attributes.
  2. Estimates the IRT model parameters independently on each subset using a gradient-based optimization method.
  3. Combines the parameter estimates from the subsets using a weighted averaging scheme.

The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on several large-scale educational datasets, showing that it can accurately estimate the IRT model parameters while being significantly faster than traditional methods. They also provide theoretical analysis to justify the correctness and convergence properties of the algorithm.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling solution to the scalability challenges in learning IRT models. The divide-and-conquer approach is intuitive and well-executed, and the authors provide thorough empirical and theoretical justification for its effectiveness.

One potential limitation is that the performance of the algorithm may depend on how the data is partitioned into subsets. The authors explore random and attribute-based partitioning, but there may be other effective strategies worth investigating. Additionally, the paper does not address the impact of missing data, which is common in real-world educational assessments.

Further research could also explore ways to incorporate additional side information, such as item content or student demographic data, to improve the accuracy and interpretability of the IRT models. Leveraging language models for this purpose could be a fruitful direction.

Overall, this work makes an important contribution to the field of psychometrics by enabling the application of IRT models to much larger and more complex datasets, which could have significant implications for educational assessment and personalized learning.

Conclusion

This paper presents a scalable algorithm for learning Item Response Theory (IRT) models, a widely used statistical framework in educational assessment and psychometrics. By partitioning the data into smaller subsets, estimating the model parameters on each subset independently, and then combining the results, the authors have developed an approach that can handle datasets with millions of responses.

The key innovation is the divide-and-conquer strategy, which allows the computationally expensive parameter estimation process to be parallelized and scaled up. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on several large-scale educational datasets, showing that it can accurately estimate the IRT model parameters while being significantly faster than traditional methods.

This work has important implications for the widespread adoption of IRT models in real-world applications, where the scale and complexity of the data have often posed significant challenges. By making IRT models more scalable, this research could enable more sophisticated and personalized educational assessments, adaptive learning systems, and other applications that rely on understanding the relationship between test items and latent traits.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Scalable Learning of Item Response Theory Models
Total Score

0

Scalable Learning of Item Response Theory Models

Susanne Frick, Amer Krivov{s}ija, Alexander Munteanu

Item Response Theory (IRT) models aim to assess latent abilities of $n$ examinees along with latent difficulty characteristics of $m$ test items from categorical data that indicates the quality of their corresponding answers. Classical psychometric assessments are based on a relatively small number of examinees and items, say a class of $200$ students solving an exam comprising $10$ problems. More recent global large scale assessments such as PISA, or internet studies, may lead to significantly increased numbers of participants. Additionally, in the context of Machine Learning where algorithms take the role of examinees and data analysis problems take the role of items, both $n$ and $m$ may become very large, challenging the efficiency and scalability of computations. To learn the latent variables in IRT models from large data, we leverage the similarity of these models to logistic regression, which can be approximated accurately using small weighted subsets called coresets. We develop coresets for their use in alternating IRT training algorithms, facilitating scalable learning from large data.

Read more

8/16/2024

AutoIRT: Calibrating Item Response Theory Models with Automated Machine Learning
Total Score

0

New!AutoIRT: Calibrating Item Response Theory Models with Automated Machine Learning

James Sharpnack, Phoebe Mulcaire, Klinton Bicknell, Geoff LaFlair, Kevin Yancey

Item response theory (IRT) is a class of interpretable factor models that are widely used in computerized adaptive tests (CATs), such as language proficiency tests. Traditionally, these are fit using parametric mixed effects models on the probability of a test taker getting the correct answer to a test item (i.e., question). Neural net extensions of these models, such as BertIRT, require specialized architectures and parameter tuning. We propose a multistage fitting procedure that is compatible with out-of-the-box Automated Machine Learning (AutoML) tools. It is based on a Monte Carlo EM (MCEM) outer loop with a two stage inner loop, which trains a non-parametric AutoML grade model using item features followed by an item specific parametric model. This greatly accelerates the modeling workflow for scoring tests. We demonstrate its effectiveness by applying it to the Duolingo English Test, a high stakes, online English proficiency test. We show that the resulting model is typically more well calibrated, gets better predictive performance, and more accurate scores than existing methods (non-explanatory IRT models and explanatory IRT models like BERT-IRT). Along the way, we provide a brief survey of machine learning methods for calibration of item parameters for CATs.

Read more

9/16/2024

Standing on the shoulders of giants
Total Score

0

Standing on the shoulders of giants

Lucas Felipe Ferraro Cardoso, Jos'e de Sousa Ribeiro Filho, Vitor Cirilo Araujo Santos, Regiane Silva Kawasaki Frances, Ronnie Cley de Oliveira Alves

Although fundamental to the advancement of Machine Learning, the classic evaluation metrics extracted from the confusion matrix, such as precision and F1, are limited. Such metrics only offer a quantitative view of the models' performance, without considering the complexity of the data or the quality of the hit. To overcome these limitations, recent research has introduced the use of psychometric metrics such as Item Response Theory (IRT), which allows an assessment at the level of latent characteristics of instances. This work investigates how IRT concepts can enrich a confusion matrix in order to identify which model is the most appropriate among options with similar performance. In the study carried out, IRT does not replace, but complements classical metrics by offering a new layer of evaluation and observation of the fine behavior of models in specific instances. It was also observed that there is 97% confidence that the score from the IRT has different contributions from 66% of the classical metrics analyzed.

Read more

9/9/2024

On Evaluation of Vision Datasets and Models using Human Competency Frameworks
Total Score

0

On Evaluation of Vision Datasets and Models using Human Competency Frameworks

Rahul Ramachandran, Tejal Kulkarni, Charchit Sharma, Deepak Vijaykeerthy, Vineeth N Balasubramanian

Evaluating models and datasets in computer vision remains a challenging task, with most leaderboards relying solely on accuracy. While accuracy is a popular metric for model evaluation, it provides only a coarse assessment by considering a single model's score on all dataset items. This paper explores Item Response Theory (IRT), a framework that infers interpretable latent parameters for an ensemble of models and each dataset item, enabling richer evaluation and analysis beyond the single accuracy number. Leveraging IRT, we assess model calibration, select informative data subsets, and demonstrate the usefulness of its latent parameters for analyzing and comparing models and datasets in computer vision.

Read more

9/9/2024