Semantic Change Characterization with LLMs using Rhetorics

Overview

• This paper explores using large language models (LLMs) and rhetorical analysis to better understand how word meanings change over time.
• The researchers investigate whether LLMs can capture nuanced semantic shifts and characterize them using rhetorical devices like metaphor, analogy, and repetition.
• The findings provide insights into the potential of LLMs for semantic change analysis and have implications for applications like historical linguistics and content moderation.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at how the meanings of words can change over time, and whether advanced AI language models can be used to study and understand these changes. The researchers wanted to see if these language models, which are trained on huge amounts of text data, could pick up on subtle shifts in how words are used and characterized.

For example, the meaning of a word like ["<a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/analyzing-role-semantic-representations-era-large-language">gay</a>"] has evolved significantly over the past century, shifting from "cheerful" to primarily referring to sexuality. The researchers used techniques like metaphor, analogy, and repetition to see if the AI models could detect and describe these kinds of nuanced semantic changes.

Their findings suggest that these advanced language models do have the potential to provide useful insights into how word meanings evolve, which could be valuable for fields like historical linguistics and content moderation. By understanding how language changes over time, we may be able to build AI systems that can better navigate the complexities of human communication.

Technical Explanation

The core of the paper's methodology is using large language models (LLMs) to analyze how the meanings of words change over time, characterizing these semantic shifts through the lens of rhetorical devices like metaphor, analogy, and repetition.

The researchers first curated a dataset of word pairs with known semantic changes, drawn from historical linguistics literature. They then fine-tuned several prominent LLM architectures, including GPT-3 and BERT, on this dataset to see how well the models could capture and describe the semantic shifts.

The key innovation was using rhetorical techniques as a framework for the analysis. For example, the researchers looked at how the models might use metaphorical language to explain how a word's meaning has evolved, or what analogies the models draw to contextualize a semantic change. Patterns in the models' use of repetition were also analyzed as an indicator of changing word significance.

Through extensive experimentation and evaluation, the paper demonstrates that LLMs can indeed learn to effectively characterize semantic changes using these rhetorical lenses. The models were able to generate insightful, human-like explanations for how word meanings have shifted over time.

Critical Analysis

One potential limitation discussed in the paper is the reliance on a curated dataset of known semantic changes. While this allowed the researchers to rigorously evaluate the models, it may not fully reflect the messiness and complexity of real-world language evolution. Further testing on more organic, noisy data could be valuable.

Additionally, the paper acknowledges that the rhetorical framework, while powerful, may not capture all the nuances of semantic change. There may be other linguistic and contextual factors that also play a key role. Combining this approach with other analytical techniques could lead to even richer insights.

That said, the findings are quite compelling and suggest exciting possibilities for using advanced language models to study historical linguistics and potentially aid in applications like content moderation. As language continues to evolve, tools that can track and characterize these changes will become increasingly valuable.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach to understanding semantic change using large language models and rhetorical analysis. The results demonstrate that LLMs can learn to effectively capture and describe nuanced shifts in word meanings over time, using techniques like metaphor, analogy, and repetition.

The implications of this research extend beyond just academic interest. By developing a better understanding of how language evolves, we may be able to build AI systems that are more adept at navigating the complexities of human communication, with applications in areas like historical linguistics, content moderation, and beyond. As the world continues to be transformed by rapid technological and social change, tools that can keep pace with shifting language will only grow more important.