On Semidefinite Relaxations for Matrix-Weighted State-Estimation Problems in Robotics

Overview

• Recent progress in "certifiable perception" methods for robotics, which use convex relaxations to find global optima
• Many of these relaxations rely on simplifying assumptions like isotropic noise
• This paper explores the limitations of semidefinite relaxations for matrix-weighted (anisotropic) state estimation problems

Plain English Explanation

Robots and other autonomous systems often need to estimate their own position and orientation, a problem known as "state estimation." Researchers have developed "certifiable perception" methods that can provably find the globally optimal state estimate.

However, these methods often make simplifying assumptions, like assuming the sensor noise is the same in all directions ("isotropic"). In reality, sensor noise is sometimes different in different directions ("anisotropic"). This paper looks at what happens when we try to use certifiable perception with anisotropic noise.

The key finding is that the convex relaxations used in these methods can lose their "tightness" - meaning they no longer find the truly global optimum - when dealing with anisotropic noise. The authors show this theoretically and demonstrate it in experiments.

They also find that a state-of-the-art relaxation for a related problem (SLAM) cannot be used when matrix weights are involved. The authors provide an alternative formulation that regains tightness, but only with the addition of some extra constraints.

Technical Explanation

The paper explores the tightness of semidefinite relaxations for matrix-weighted (anisotropic) state estimation problems. Many certifiable perception methods, such as those described in "Toward Globally Optimal State Estimation Using Automatically Rearranged Measurements," rely on convex relaxations to find globally optimal solutions.

However, these relaxations often assume isotropic (equal in all directions) measurement noise. The authors show that matrix-weighted factors, which capture anisotropic noise, can cause these relaxations to lose tightness - meaning they no longer find the true global optimum. They demonstrate this both theoretically and empirically.

Specifically, the authors establish a connection between the posterior uncertainty of the state estimate and the dual variable of the convex relaxation. This connection allows them to identify factors contributing to the loss of tightness, such as redundant constraints. They show that by adding these redundant constraints, the tightness of the relaxation can be regained.

As a second technical contribution, the paper shows that the state-of-the-art relaxation for scalar-weighted SLAM cannot be used when matrix weights are involved. The authors provide an alternate formulation and demonstrate its tightness, but only when the aforementioned redundant constraints are added.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough analysis of the limitations of semidefinite relaxations for matrix-weighted state estimation problems. The theoretical insights and empirical demonstrations are compelling and raise important concerns about the applicability of certifiable perception methods in realistic scenarios with anisotropic noise.

While the authors propose solutions to regain tightness, such as adding redundant constraints, these additional steps increase the complexity of the optimization problem. It would be valuable to further explore the trade-offs between tightness, computational efficiency, and practical considerations in real-world deployments.

Additionally, the paper focuses on state estimation, but many perception problems in robotics involve other types of estimation, such as image restoration or system identification. It would be interesting to see if similar limitations and solutions apply in these other domains.

Overall, this paper highlights important limitations in the application of convex relaxation techniques and encourages further research into maintaining the robustness and resilience of certifiable perception methods under more realistic conditions.

Conclusion

This paper provides a critical examination of the tightness of semidefinite relaxations for matrix-weighted state estimation problems, a common scenario in robotics and autonomous systems. The authors demonstrate both theoretically and empirically that these relaxations can lose their global optimality guarantees when dealing with anisotropic (directional) measurement noise.

By establishing a connection between the posterior uncertainty and the dual variables of the convex relaxation, the paper sheds light on the factors contributing to this loss of tightness. The authors also show that the state-of-the-art relaxation for scalar-weighted SLAM cannot be directly extended to the matrix-weighted case, requiring a new formulation.

These findings are significant for the field of certifiable perception, as they highlight the need to carefully consider the assumptions and limitations of convex relaxation techniques when deploying them in realistic applications. The insights provided in this paper can guide future research towards more robust and reliable state estimation methods for autonomous systems operating in complex, noisy environments.