Toward Globally Optimal State Estimation Using Automatically Tightened Semidefinite Relaxations

Overview

• Semidefinite relaxations have gained attention in robotics for providing globally optimal solutions to common optimization problems.
• Previous methods required manually identifying specific redundant constraints to obtain tight relaxations and global optimality.
• This paper introduces an automatic method to find a set of sufficient redundant constraints, if they exist, without manual intervention.

Plain English Explanation

Optimization problems are common in robotics, such as localization and pose estimation. Researchers have found that a technique called "semidefinite relaxation" can help solve these problems in a globally optimal way.

However, previous methods required manually adding special "redundant constraints" to the optimization problem in order to get the tight, global solutions. This manual process was time-consuming and depended on the specific problem formulation.

Instead, this paper presents an automatic way to find the necessary redundant constraints, if they exist, without any manual work. First, the method checks if the optimization problem can be tightened using redundant constraints. Then, it scales this approach to handle larger problems.

The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of this automatic method, both in simulation and on real robot data, for localization and pose estimation tasks. Importantly, it also shows that the automatic method finds a smaller set of redundant constraints than what was used in previous research, while still achieving the same tight, global optimality.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes an automatic method to find a set of sufficient redundant constraints to obtain tight semidefinite relaxations, if they exist, for common optimization problems in robotics.

First, the authors present an efficient feasibility check to determine if a given set of variables can lead to a tight formulation. This avoids the need to manually identify redundant constraints, which was required in prior work.

Second, the paper shows how to scale the method to handle larger optimization problems. This involves decomposing the problem and applying the feasibility check in a distributed manner.

The effectiveness of the approach is demonstrated through simulations and experiments on real datasets for range-based localization and stereo-based pose estimation. The results show that the automatic method can find a smaller set of redundant constraints than what was previously considered in the literature, while still achieving the same tight, global optimality.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a valuable contribution by automating the process of finding redundant constraints for tight semidefinite relaxations. This is an important step forward, as the manual identification of these constraints was a major limitation of prior work.

However, the paper does not discuss the computational complexity of the proposed feasibility check or the distributed problem decomposition. It would be helpful to understand the scalability limits of the approach and how it compares to other semidefinite programming techniques, such as those discussed in Collision-Free Trajectory Optimization and Safe Reinforcement Learning.

Additionally, the paper focuses on specific robotics applications (localization and pose estimation) and does not explore the generalizability of the method to other optimization problems in Cyber-Physical Robotic Systems or Formal Verification. Further research could investigate the broader applicability of the automatic constraint generation technique.

Conclusion

This paper presents an important advancement in the field of semidefinite relaxations for optimization problems in robotics. By automating the process of finding redundant constraints, the method eliminates a significant manual step that was required in previous approaches. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of the technique for localization and pose estimation tasks, suggesting it could have a meaningful impact on a range of robotic applications that rely on global optimization.