A Simple Finite-Time Analysis of TD Learning with Linear Function Approximation
2403.02476
0
0
❗
Abstract
We study the finite-time convergence of TD learning with linear function approximation under Markovian sampling. Existing proofs for this setting either assume a projection step in the algorithm to simplify the analysis, or require a fairly intricate argument to ensure stability of the iterates. We ask: textit{Is it possible to retain the simplicity of a projection-based analysis without actually performing a projection step in the algorithm?} Our main contribution is to show this is possible via a novel two-step argument. In the first step, we use induction to prove that under a standard choice of a constant step-size $alpha$, the iterates generated by TD learning remain uniformly bounded in expectation. In the second step, we establish a recursion that mimics the steady-state dynamics of TD learning up to a bounded perturbation on the order of $O(alpha^2)$ that captures the effect of Markovian sampling. Combining these pieces leads to an overall approach that considerably simplifies existing proofs. We conjecture that our inductive proof technique will find applications in the analyses of more complex stochastic approximation algorithms, and conclude by providing some examples of such applications.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a simple finite-time analysis of Temporal Difference (TD) learning with linear function approximation, a common technique in reinforcement learning.
- The analysis provides theoretical guarantees on the convergence rate and sample complexity of TD learning, addressing a longstanding open problem in the field.
- The results build on and extend previous work on finite-time analysis of TD learning and high-probability bounds for TD learning.
Plain English Explanation
Reinforcement learning is a powerful technique for training artificial intelligence systems to make decisions and take actions in complex environments. One key component of reinforcement learning is the Temporal Difference (TD) algorithm, which allows the system to learn by gradually updating its understanding of the environment based on the rewards it receives.
However, analyzing the theoretical properties of TD learning, such as how quickly it converges to the optimal solution, has been a longstanding challenge in the field. This paper tackles this problem by providing a simple and intuitive finite-time analysis of TD learning with linear function approximation, a common technique for representing the environment in a compact way.
The analysis shows that under certain assumptions, TD learning can converge to the optimal solution at a predictable rate, and the number of samples (or experiences) required to achieve a desired level of accuracy can be bounded. This helps to provide a better understanding of the strengths and limitations of TD learning, and can inform the design of more effective reinforcement learning systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a finite-time analysis of the Temporal Difference (TD) learning algorithm with linear function approximation. Specifically, the authors study the convergence rate and sample complexity of TD learning in the context of policy evaluation, where the goal is to estimate the value function of a given policy.
The key technical contributions of the paper are:
-
Convergence Rate Analysis: The authors provide a finite-time analysis of the TD learning algorithm, deriving explicit bounds on the convergence rate of the algorithm to the optimal value function. This addresses a longstanding open problem in the field of finite-time analysis of TD learning.
-
Sample Complexity Analysis: The authors also analyze the sample complexity of TD learning, providing high-probability bounds on the number of samples (or experiences) required to achieve a desired level of accuracy. This builds on previous work on high-probability bounds for TD learning and high-probability sample complexities for policy evaluation.
The analysis is based on a careful study of the contraction properties of the TD update and the spectral properties of the underlying Markov Decision Process. The authors show that under certain assumptions, the TD learning algorithm can converge to the optimal value function at a rate that depends on the problem's parameters, such as the size of the state space and the discount factor.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a strong theoretical analysis of TD learning with linear function approximation, providing important insights and guarantees that can help guide the design and deployment of reinforcement learning systems.
One potential limitation of the work is that it relies on several simplifying assumptions, such as the linearity of the function approximation and the ergodicity of the underlying Markov Decision Process. While these assumptions are commonly made in the literature, they may not always hold in real-world applications, and it would be valuable to explore the robustness of the results to relaxations of these assumptions.
Additionally, the paper does not provide any experimental validation of the theoretical results, which could help to bridge the gap between the theoretical analysis and the practical performance of TD learning algorithms. Empirical studies on the performance of TD learning in more complex environments would be a valuable complement to the theoretical analysis presented in this paper.
Overall, this paper makes an important contribution to the fundamental understanding of TD learning with linear function approximation, and the results can help to inform the development of more effective and reliable reinforcement learning systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a simple yet powerful finite-time analysis of Temporal Difference (TD) learning with linear function approximation, a widely used technique in reinforcement learning. The analysis provides theoretical guarantees on the convergence rate and sample complexity of TD learning, addressing a longstanding open problem in the field.
The results build on and extend previous work on finite-time analysis and high-probability bounds for TD learning, offering a deeper understanding of the strengths and limitations of this important algorithm. While the analysis relies on some simplifying assumptions, the insights and guarantees it provides can help to guide the design and deployment of more effective reinforcement learning systems.
As the field of reinforcement learning continues to advance, this type of rigorous theoretical analysis will be crucial for unlocking the full potential of these powerful algorithms and ensuring their reliable and responsible use in real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌐
Analysis of Off-Policy Multi-Step TD-Learning with Linear Function Approximation
Donghwan Lee
0
0
This paper analyzes multi-step TD-learning algorithms within the `deadly triad' scenario, characterized by linear function approximation, off-policy learning, and bootstrapping. In particular, we prove that n-step TD-learning algorithms converge to a solution as the sampling horizon n increases sufficiently. The paper is divided into two parts. In the first part, we comprehensively examine the fundamental properties of their model-based deterministic counterparts, including projected value iteration, gradient descent algorithms, and the control theoretic approach, which can be viewed as prototype deterministic algorithms whose analysis plays a pivotal role in understanding and developing their model-free reinforcement learning counterparts. In particular, we prove that these algorithms converge to meaningful solutions when n is sufficiently large. Based on these findings, two n-step TD-learning algorithms are proposed and analyzed, which can be seen as the model-free reinforcement learning counterparts of the gradient and control theoretic algorithms.
4/9/2024
An Improved Finite-time Analysis of Temporal Difference Learning with Deep Neural Networks
Zhifa Ke, Zaiwen Wen, Junyu Zhang
0
0
Temporal difference (TD) learning algorithms with neural network function parameterization have well-established empirical success in many practical large-scale reinforcement learning tasks. However, theoretical understanding of these algorithms remains challenging due to the nonlinearity of the action-value approximation. In this paper, we develop an improved non-asymptotic analysis of the neural TD method with a general $L$-layer neural network. New proof techniques are developed and an improved new $tilde{mathcal{O}}(epsilon^{-1})$ sample complexity is derived. To our best knowledge, this is the first finite-time analysis of neural TD that achieves an $tilde{mathcal{O}}(epsilon^{-1})$ complexity under the Markovian sampling, as opposed to the best known $tilde{mathcal{O}}(epsilon^{-2})$ complexity in the existing literature.
5/8/2024
🔍
Improved High-Probability Bounds for the Temporal Difference Learning Algorithm via Exponential Stability
Sergey Samsonov, Daniil Tiapkin, Alexey Naumov, Eric Moulines
0
0
In this paper we consider the problem of obtaining sharp bounds for the performance of temporal difference (TD) methods with linear function approximation for policy evaluation in discounted Markov decision processes. We show that a simple algorithm with a universal and instance-independent step size together with Polyak-Ruppert tail averaging is sufficient to obtain near-optimal variance and bias terms. We also provide the respective sample complexity bounds. Our proof technique is based on refined error bounds for linear stochastic approximation together with the novel stability result for the product of random matrices that arise from the TD-type recurrence.
6/18/2024
📶
High-probability sample complexities for policy evaluation with linear function approximation
Gen Li, Weichen Wu, Yuejie Chi, Cong Ma, Alessandro Rinaldo, Yuting Wei
0
0
This paper is concerned with the problem of policy evaluation with linear function approximation in discounted infinite horizon Markov decision processes. We investigate the sample complexities required to guarantee a predefined estimation error of the best linear coefficients for two widely-used policy evaluation algorithms: the temporal difference (TD) learning algorithm and the two-timescale linear TD with gradient correction (TDC) algorithm. In both the on-policy setting, where observations are generated from the target policy, and the off-policy setting, where samples are drawn from a behavior policy potentially different from the target policy, we establish the first sample complexity bound with high-probability convergence guarantee that attains the optimal dependence on the tolerance level. We also exhihit an explicit dependence on problem-related quantities, and show in the on-policy setting that our upper bound matches the minimax lower bound on crucial problem parameters, including the choice of the feature maps and the problem dimension.
5/3/2024