Size Aware Cross-shape Scribble Supervision for Medical Image Segmentation

Read original: arXiv:2408.13639 - Published 8/27/2024 by Jing Yuan, Tania Stathaki

Size Aware Cross-shape Scribble Supervision for Medical Image Segmentation

Overview

Medical image segmentation is an important task in healthcare
Scribble supervision, where users provide sparse scribble annotations, can be a cost-effective way to train segmentation models
This paper proposes a "Size Aware Cross-shape Scribble Supervision" method to improve scribble-based segmentation

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on the challenge of medical image segmentation, which is the process of automatically identifying different structures or regions within medical images like X-rays or MRIs. This is an important task for healthcare, as it can help doctors better understand and diagnose medical conditions.

Traditional supervised learning approaches to medical image segmentation require large datasets of fully annotated images, which can be time-consuming and expensive to obtain. As an alternative, the authors propose using scribble supervision, where users provide sparse, hand-drawn scribbles on images to indicate the regions of interest. This can be a more cost-effective way to train segmentation models.

The key innovation in this paper is a "Size Aware Cross-shape Scribble Supervision" method. This approach takes into account the size of the structures being segmented and uses that information to improve the model's performance on scribble-supervised segmentation tasks. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on several medical image segmentation benchmarks.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a novel method called "Size Aware Cross-shape Scribble Supervision" (SACSS) for medical image segmentation using sparse scribble annotations. The key ideas are:

Size Awareness: The authors observe that the size of the structures being segmented can have a significant impact on the performance of scribble-based segmentation. Their method explicitly models the size information of the target objects.
Cross-shape Supervision: Rather than just using scribbles of the same shape as the target objects, the SACSS method leverages scribbles of different shapes (e.g., lines, dots) to provide more diverse supervision signals to the model.

The authors design a neural network architecture that takes the medical image and the scribble annotations as input, and outputs the segmentation mask. The network includes size-aware attention modules that capture the size information of the target objects, as well as a cross-shape supervision loss that encourages the model to learn from scribbles of different shapes.

The authors evaluate their SACSS method on several medical image segmentation datasets and compare it to other scribble-based and fully-supervised approaches. The results show that SACSS outperforms these baselines, demonstrating the effectiveness of the size-aware and cross-shape supervision techniques.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a well-designed and thorough study on the use of scribble supervision for medical image segmentation. The key strengths of the work include:

Thoughtful Problem Formulation: The authors identify an important practical challenge in medical image segmentation and propose a novel solution to address it.
Innovative Methodological Contributions: The size-aware and cross-shape supervision techniques are compelling and well-motivated contributions to the field of weak supervision for segmentation.
Rigorous Experimental Evaluation: The authors conduct a comprehensive set of experiments to validate their method on multiple medical image segmentation benchmarks.

However, some potential limitations and areas for further research include:

Generalization to Other Domains: While the focus on medical images is well-justified, it would be interesting to see how the SACSS method performs on scribble-supervised segmentation tasks in other domains, such as natural images.
Sensitivity to Scribble Quality: The paper does not extensively explore the impact of the quality and placement of the scribble annotations on the model's performance. Further investigation into this area could yield valuable insights.
Interpretability and Explainability: The paper does not provide much analysis on the inner workings of the size-aware attention modules and how they contribute to the model's performance. Improving the interpretability of the method could enhance its practical utility.

Overall, the paper presents a compelling and well-executed approach to scribble-supervised medical image segmentation, with promising results and interesting avenues for future research.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel "Size Aware Cross-shape Scribble Supervision" method for medical image segmentation. By explicitly modeling the size information of the target objects and leveraging scribbles of different shapes, the authors demonstrate significant performance improvements over other scribble-based and fully-supervised approaches.

The work highlights the potential of weak supervision techniques, such as scribble annotation, to reduce the cost and effort required for training medical image segmentation models. The size-aware and cross-shape supervision innovations presented in this paper represent an important step forward in this direction, with potential applications in a wide range of healthcare and medical imaging tasks.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Size Aware Cross-shape Scribble Supervision for Medical Image Segmentation

Jing Yuan, Tania Stathaki

Scribble supervision, a common form of weakly supervised learning, involves annotating pixels using hand-drawn curve lines, which helps reduce the cost of manual labelling. This technique has been widely used in medical image segmentation tasks to fasten network training. However, scribble supervision has limitations in terms of annotation consistency across samples and the availability of comprehensive groundtruth information. Additionally, it often grapples with the challenge of accommodating varying scale targets, particularly in the context of medical images. In this paper, we propose three novel methods to overcome these challenges, namely, 1) the cross-shape scribble annotation method; 2) the pseudo mask method based on cross shapes; and 3) the size-aware multi-branch method. The parameter and structure design are investigated in depth. Experimental results show that the proposed methods have achieved significant improvement in mDice scores across multiple polyp datasets. Notably, the combination of these methods outperforms the performance of state-of-the-art scribble supervision methods designed for medical image segmentation.

8/27/2024

Scribbles for All: Benchmarking Scribble Supervised Segmentation Across Datasets

Wolfgang Boettcher, Lukas Hoyer, Ozan Unal, Jan Eric Lenssen, Bernt Schiele

In this work, we introduce Scribbles for All, a label and training data generation algorithm for semantic segmentation trained on scribble labels. Training or fine-tuning semantic segmentation models with weak supervision has become an important topic recently and was subject to significant advances in model quality. In this setting, scribbles are a promising label type to achieve high quality segmentation results while requiring a much lower annotation effort than usual pixel-wise dense semantic segmentation annotations. The main limitation of scribbles as source for weak supervision is the lack of challenging datasets for scribble segmentation, which hinders the development of novel methods and conclusive evaluations. To overcome this limitation, Scribbles for All provides scribble labels for several popular segmentation datasets and provides an algorithm to automatically generate scribble labels for any dataset with dense annotations, paving the way for new insights and model advancements in the field of weakly supervised segmentation. In addition to providing datasets and algorithm, we evaluate state-of-the-art segmentation models on our datasets and show that models trained with our synthetic labels perform competitively with respect to models trained on manual labels. Thus, our datasets enable state-of-the-art research into methods for scribble-labeled semantic segmentation. The datasets, scribble generation algorithm, and baselines are publicly available at https://github.com/wbkit/Scribbles4All

8/23/2024

From Few to More: Scribble-based Medical Image Segmentation via Masked Context Modeling and Continuous Pseudo Labels

Zhisong Wang, Yiwen Ye, Ziyang Chen, Minglei Shu, Yong Xia

Scribble-based weakly supervised segmentation techniques offer comparable performance to fully supervised methods while significantly reducing annotation costs, making them an appealing alternative. Existing methods often rely on auxiliary tasks to enforce semantic consistency and use hard pseudo labels for supervision. However, these methods often overlook the unique requirements of models trained with sparse annotations. Since the model must predict pixel-wise segmentation maps with limited annotations, the ability to handle varying levels of annotation richness is critical. In this paper, we adopt the principle of `from few to more' and propose MaCo, a weakly supervised framework designed for medical image segmentation. MaCo employs masked context modeling (MCM) and continuous pseudo labels (CPL). MCM uses an attention-based masking strategy to disrupt the input image, compelling the model's predictions to remain consistent with those of the original image. CPL converts scribble annotations into continuous pixel-wise labels by applying an exponential decay function to distance maps, resulting in continuous maps that represent the confidence of each pixel belonging to a specific category, rather than using hard pseudo labels. We evaluate MaCo against other weakly supervised methods using three public datasets. The results indicate that MaCo outperforms competing methods across all datasets, setting a new record in weakly supervised medical image segmentation.

8/26/2024

ModelMix: A New Model-Mixup Strategy to Minimize Vicinal Risk across Tasks for Few-scribble based Cardiac Segmentation

Ke Zhang, Vishal M. Patel

Pixel-level dense labeling is both resource-intensive and time-consuming, whereas weak labels such as scribble present a more feasible alternative to full annotations. However, training segmentation networks with weak supervision from scribbles remains challenging. Inspired by the fact that different segmentation tasks can be correlated with each other, we introduce a new approach to few-scribble supervised segmentation based on model parameter interpolation, termed as ModelMix. Leveraging the prior knowledge that linearly interpolating convolution kernels and bias terms should result in linear interpolations of the corresponding feature vectors, ModelMix constructs virtual models using convex combinations of convolutional parameters from separate encoders. We then regularize the model set to minimize vicinal risk across tasks in both unsupervised and scribble-supervised way. Validated on three open datasets, i.e., ACDC, MSCMRseg, and MyoPS, our few-scribble guided ModelMix significantly surpasses the performance of the state-of-the-art scribble supervised methods.

6/21/2024