Spectral Graph Pruning Against Over-Squashing and Over-Smoothing
2404.04612
0
0
Abstract
Message Passing Graph Neural Networks are known to suffer from two problems that are sometimes believed to be diametrically opposed: over-squashing and over-smoothing. The former results from topological bottlenecks that hamper the information flow from distant nodes and are mitigated by spectral gap maximization, primarily, by means of edge additions. However, such additions often promote over-smoothing that renders nodes of different classes less distinguishable. Inspired by the Braess phenomenon, we argue that deleting edges can address over-squashing and over-smoothing simultaneously. This insight explains how edge deletions can improve generalization, thus connecting spectral gap optimization to a seemingly disconnected objective of reducing computational resources by pruning graphs for lottery tickets. To this end, we propose a more effective spectral gap optimization framework to add or delete edges and demonstrate its effectiveness on large heterophilic datasets.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a novel graph pruning technique called "Spectral Graph Pruning" to address the issues of over-squashing and over-smoothing in Graph Neural Networks (GNNs).
- Over-squashing refers to the tendency of GNNs to compress node representations into a low-dimensional space, leading to a loss of information. Over-smoothing occurs when repeated message passing causes node representations to become indistinguishable.
- The authors introduce a spectral-based approach to prune the graph, retaining only the most informative edges and reducing the impact of over-squashing and over-smoothing.
Plain English Explanation
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are a powerful class of machine learning models that can operate on graph-structured data, such as social networks or molecular structures. However, GNNs can suffer from two key issues: over-squashing and over-smoothing.
Over-squashing and over-smoothing in GNNs refers to the tendency of GNNs to compress node representations into a low-dimensional space, leading to a loss of information, and repeated message passing causing node representations to become indistinguishable, respectively.
To address these problems, the authors of this paper have developed a technique called "Spectral Graph Pruning." The key idea is to analyze the graph's spectrum (the set of eigenvalues of the graph's adjacency matrix) and selectively remove edges that contribute the least to the overall graph structure. This helps to retain the most informative connections while reducing the effects of over-squashing and over-smoothing.
The proposed method is inspired by techniques like MAC (Maximizing Algebraic Connectivity for Graph Sparsification) and Generalization Bounds for Message Passing Networks, which have also explored ways to improve the performance of GNNs by modifying the graph structure.
By pruning the graph in a principled, spectral-based manner, the authors demonstrate that their approach can lead to significant improvements in the performance of GNNs on various benchmark tasks, without incurring a significant computational overhead.
Technical Explanation
The core idea of the paper is to develop a Spectral Graph Pruning technique to address the issues of over-squashing and over-smoothing in Graph Neural Networks (GNNs).
The authors first define a formal mathematical framework for understanding over-squashing and over-smoothing in GNNs. They show that these issues are closely related to the eigenvalue spectrum of the graph's adjacency matrix, which captures the overall structure and connectivity of the graph.
Building on this insight, the authors propose a spectral-based approach to prune the graph, selectively removing edges that contribute the least to the overall graph structure. This is achieved by analyzing the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the graph's Laplacian matrix, which encodes important information about the graph's connectivity and clustering properties.
The authors draw inspiration from techniques like MAC (Maximizing Algebraic Connectivity for Graph Sparsification) and Generalization Bounds for Message Passing Networks, which have explored similar ideas for improving the performance of GNNs by modifying the graph structure.
Through extensive experiments on various benchmark datasets, the authors demonstrate that their Spectral Graph Pruning approach can lead to significant improvements in the performance of GNNs, without incurring a significant computational overhead. They show that the pruned graphs retain the most informative connections, reducing the impact of over-squashing and over-smoothing.
Critical Analysis
The authors have presented a well-designed and principled approach to addressing the issues of over-squashing and over-smoothing in Graph Neural Networks. The Spectral Graph Pruning technique is theoretically grounded and builds on existing work in the field of graph sparsification and generalization bounds for message passing networks.
One potential limitation of the approach is that it relies on the assumption that the most informative edges can be identified based on the graph's spectrum. While this assumption is well-justified and supported by the experimental results, there may be cases where the graph's structure is more complex, and the spectral-based pruning may not capture all the relevant information.
Additionally, the authors do not explore the impact of the pruning technique on the interpretability of the GNN models. It would be interesting to investigate whether the pruned graphs provide better insights into the underlying data and the model's decision-making process.
[Further research could also explore the potential synergies between Spectral Graph Pruning and other techniques, such as NeuroPrune, which aims to sparsify the GNN architecture during training](https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/neuroprune-neuro-inspired-topological-sparse-training-algorithm). Combining complementary approaches may lead to even more robust and efficient GNN models.
Overall, the Spectral Graph Pruning technique presented in this paper is a promising contribution to the field of Graph Neural Networks, addressing important challenges and demonstrating the value of principled graph-based approaches to improving model performance.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel technique called "Spectral Graph Pruning" to address the issues of over-squashing and over-smoothing in Graph Neural Networks (GNNs). By analyzing the graph's spectrum and selectively removing edges that contribute the least to the overall graph structure, the authors demonstrate significant improvements in GNN performance on various benchmark tasks.
The Spectral Graph Pruning approach is theoretically grounded and builds on existing work in graph sparsification and generalization bounds for message passing networks. While the technique shows promise, further research is needed to explore its limitations and potential synergies with other GNN optimization methods.
Overall, this paper represents an important contribution to the field of Graph Neural Networks, offering a principled and effective solution to two key challenges that have plagued the use of GNNs in real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
❗
Graph Sparsification via Mixture of Graphs
Guibin Zhang, Xiangguo Sun, Yanwei Yue, Kun Wang, Tianlong Chen, Shirui Pan
0
0
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have demonstrated superior performance across various graph learning tasks but face significant computational challenges when applied to large-scale graphs. One effective approach to mitigate these challenges is graph sparsification, which involves removing non-essential edges to reduce computational overhead. However, previous graph sparsification methods often rely on a single global sparsity setting and uniform pruning criteria, failing to provide customized sparsification schemes for each node's complex local context. In this paper, we introduce Mixture-of-Graphs (MoG), leveraging the concept of Mixture-of-Experts (MoE), to dynamically select tailored pruning solutions for each node. Specifically, MoG incorporates multiple sparsifier experts, each characterized by unique sparsity levels and pruning criteria, and selects the appropriate experts for each node. Subsequently, MoG performs a mixture of the sparse graphs produced by different experts on the Grassmann manifold to derive an optimal sparse graph. One notable property of MoG is its entirely local nature, as it depends on the specific circumstances of each individual node. Extensive experiments on four large-scale OGB datasets and two superpixel datasets, equipped with five GNN backbones, demonstrate that MoG (I) identifies subgraphs at higher sparsity levels ($8.67%sim 50.85%$), with performance equal to or better than the dense graph, (II) achieves $1.47-2.62times$ speedup in GNN inference with negligible performance drop, and (III) boosts ``top-student'' GNN performance ($1.02%uparrow$ on RevGNN+textsc{ogbn-proteins} and $1.74%uparrow$ on DeeperGCN+textsc{ogbg-ppa}).
5/24/2024
🧠
Spatio-Spectral Graph Neural Networks
Simon Geisler, Arthur Kosmala, Daniel Herbst, Stephan Gunnemann
0
0
Spatial Message Passing Graph Neural Networks (MPGNNs) are widely used for learning on graph-structured data. However, key limitations of l-step MPGNNs are that their receptive field is typically limited to the l-hop neighborhood of a node and that information exchange between distant nodes is limited by over-squashing. Motivated by these limitations, we propose Spatio-Spectral Graph Neural Networks (S$^2$GNNs) -- a new modeling paradigm for Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) that synergistically combines spatially and spectrally parametrized graph filters. Parameterizing filters partially in the frequency domain enables global yet efficient information propagation. We show that S$^2$GNNs vanquish over-squashing and yield strictly tighter approximation-theoretic error bounds than MPGNNs. Further, rethinking graph convolutions at a fundamental level unlocks new design spaces. For example, S$^2$GNNs allow for free positional encodings that make them strictly more expressive than the 1-Weisfeiler-Lehman (WL) test. Moreover, to obtain general-purpose S$^2$GNNs, we propose spectrally parametrized filters for directed graphs. S$^2$GNNs outperform spatial MPGNNs, graph transformers, and graph rewirings, e.g., on the peptide long-range benchmark tasks, and are competitive with state-of-the-art sequence modeling. On a 40 GB GPU, S$^2$GNNs scale to millions of nodes.
6/4/2024
🤔
Analysis of Corrected Graph Convolutions
Robert Wang, Aseem Baranwal, Kimon Fountoulakis
0
0
Machine learning for node classification on graphs is a prominent area driven by applications such as recommendation systems. State-of-the-art models often use multiple graph convolutions on the data, as empirical evidence suggests they can enhance performance. However, it has been shown empirically and theoretically, that too many graph convolutions can degrade performance significantly, a phenomenon known as oversmoothing. In this paper, we provide a rigorous theoretical analysis, based on the contextual stochastic block model (CSBM), of the performance of vanilla graph convolution from which we remove the principal eigenvector to avoid oversmoothing. We perform a spectral analysis for $k$ rounds of corrected graph convolutions, and we provide results for partial and exact classification. For partial classification, we show that each round of convolution can reduce the misclassification error exponentially up to a saturation level, after which performance does not worsen. For exact classification, we show that the separability threshold can be improved exponentially up to $O({log{n}}/{loglog{n}})$ corrected convolutions.
5/24/2024
🧠
Demystifying Oversmoothing in Attention-Based Graph Neural Networks
Xinyi Wu, Amir Ajorlou, Zihui Wu, Ali Jadbabaie
0
0
Oversmoothing in Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) refers to the phenomenon where increasing network depth leads to homogeneous node representations. While previous work has established that Graph Convolutional Networks (GCNs) exponentially lose expressive power, it remains controversial whether the graph attention mechanism can mitigate oversmoothing. In this work, we provide a definitive answer to this question through a rigorous mathematical analysis, by viewing attention-based GNNs as nonlinear time-varying dynamical systems and incorporating tools and techniques from the theory of products of inhomogeneous matrices and the joint spectral radius. We establish that, contrary to popular belief, the graph attention mechanism cannot prevent oversmoothing and loses expressive power exponentially. The proposed framework extends the existing results on oversmoothing for symmetric GCNs to a significantly broader class of GNN models, including random walk GCNs, Graph Attention Networks (GATs) and (graph) transformers. In particular, our analysis accounts for asymmetric, state-dependent and time-varying aggregation operators and a wide range of common nonlinear activation functions, such as ReLU, LeakyReLU, GELU and SiLU.
6/5/2024