STAR: A Benchmark for Situated Reasoning in Real-World Videos
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper introduces STAR, a new benchmark for evaluating the ability of AI systems to reason about real-world situations depicted in videos.
- STAR focuses on situated reasoning, which involves understanding the context and relationships between objects, characters, and actions in a given scenario.
- The benchmark includes a diverse dataset of real-world videos with associated questions that require complex, multi-step reasoning to answer correctly.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers have created a new tool called STAR to test how well AI systems can understand and reason about the real-world situations they see in videos. STAR is designed to go beyond simple video question answering tasks by requiring the AI to really grasp the context and connections between different elements in the scene.
The STAR dataset includes a wide variety of everyday videos, like people cooking, working on projects, or playing games. For each video, there are questions that test the AI's ability to piece together what's happening and why. Answering these questions correctly often requires making multiple logical inferences, not just identifying individual objects or actions.
By creating this challenging benchmark, the researchers aim to push the boundaries of current AI reasoning capabilities and spur progress towards systems that can understand the world in a more human-like way.
Technical Explanation
The STAR benchmark consists of a dataset of 3,000 real-world videos accompanied by over 15,000 situational reasoning questions. The videos cover a diverse range of everyday scenarios, such as cooking, home improvement, and leisure activities.
Each video is annotated with bounding boxes and segmentation masks for the key objects, characters, and interactions. The questions associated with each video require the AI system to reason about the relationships between these elements in order to infer the correct answer.
The question types span a variety of situated reasoning tasks, including:
- Identifying the purpose or goal of an observed activity
- Predicting the future state or outcome of an ongoing process
- Explaining the causal relationships between events
- Comparing the relative attributes or behaviors of different entities
To establish a strong reasoning as retrieval baseline, the authors also provide a large knowledge base of textual descriptions about the videos' contents and question-answer pairs.
Critical Analysis
The STAR benchmark represents an important step towards developing AI systems that can engage in more comprehensive and contextual reasoning about real-world situations. By focusing on videos of everyday activities, the benchmark aims to capture the complexity of how humans understand and make sense of the world around them.
One key strength of the STAR dataset is its diversity - the videos cover a wide range of scenarios and question types, which should help push the boundaries of current video understanding models. The inclusion of a knowledge base also provides a valuable resource for training and evaluating neural-symbolic reasoning approaches.
At the same time, the authors acknowledge some limitations of the dataset, such as potential biases in the video selection and question formulation. Additionally, the reliance on bounding boxes and segmentation masks means the benchmark may not fully capture the finer-grained perceptual challenges involved in situated reasoning.
Further research will be needed to explore how well STAR-trained models generalize to novel situations and to investigate the role of commonsense knowledge, causal reasoning, and other higher-level cognitive capabilities in this domain. Nonetheless, the STAR benchmark represents an important contribution to the ongoing effort to develop AI systems that can understand and reason about the complexity of the real world.
Conclusion
The STAR benchmark introduces a new challenge for AI systems - the ability to engage in situated reasoning about real-world videos. By creating a diverse dataset of everyday scenarios paired with multi-faceted questions, the researchers aim to push the boundaries of current video understanding capabilities and spur progress towards more human-like reasoning and comprehension.
While the benchmark has some limitations, it represents a valuable tool for the research community to explore the frontiers of AI reasoning. Advancements in this area could have far-reaching implications, from improving the contextual understanding of virtual assistants to enhancing the safety and robustness of autonomous systems operating in the real world.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
STAR: A Benchmark for Situated Reasoning in Real-World Videos
Bo Wu, Shoubin Yu, Zhenfang Chen, Joshua B Tenenbaum, Chuang Gan
Reasoning in the real world is not divorced from situations. How to capture the present knowledge from surrounding situations and perform reasoning accordingly is crucial and challenging for machine intelligence. This paper introduces a new benchmark that evaluates the situated reasoning ability via situation abstraction and logic-grounded question answering for real-world videos, called Situated Reasoning in Real-World Videos (STAR Benchmark). This benchmark is built upon the real-world videos associated with human actions or interactions, which are naturally dynamic, compositional, and logical. The dataset includes four types of questions, including interaction, sequence, prediction, and feasibility. We represent the situations in real-world videos by hyper-graphs connecting extracted atomic entities and relations (e.g., actions, persons, objects, and relationships). Besides visual perception, situated reasoning also requires structured situation comprehension and logical reasoning. Questions and answers are procedurally generated. The answering logic of each question is represented by a functional program based on a situation hyper-graph. We compare various existing video reasoning models and find that they all struggle on this challenging situated reasoning task. We further propose a diagnostic neuro-symbolic model that can disentangle visual perception, situation abstraction, language understanding, and functional reasoning to understand the challenges of this benchmark.
Read more5/17/2024
0
SOK-Bench: A Situated Video Reasoning Benchmark with Aligned Open-World Knowledge
Andong Wang, Bo Wu, Sunli Chen, Zhenfang Chen, Haotian Guan, Wei-Ning Lee, Li Erran Li, Chuang Gan
Learning commonsense reasoning from visual contexts and scenes in real-world is a crucial step toward advanced artificial intelligence. However, existing video reasoning benchmarks are still inadequate since they were mainly designed for factual or situated reasoning and rarely involve broader knowledge in the real world. Our work aims to delve deeper into reasoning evaluations, specifically within dynamic, open-world, and structured context knowledge. We propose a new benchmark (SOK-Bench), consisting of 44K questions and 10K situations with instance-level annotations depicted in the videos. The reasoning process is required to understand and apply situated knowledge and general knowledge for problem-solving. To create such a dataset, we propose an automatic and scalable generation method to generate question-answer pairs, knowledge graphs, and rationales by instructing the combinations of LLMs and MLLMs. Concretely, we first extract observable situated entities, relations, and processes from videos for situated knowledge and then extend to open-world knowledge beyond the visible content. The task generation is facilitated through multiple dialogues as iterations and subsequently corrected and refined by our designed self-promptings and demonstrations. With a corpus of both explicit situated facts and implicit commonsense, we generate associated question-answer pairs and reasoning processes, finally followed by manual reviews for quality assurance. We evaluated recent mainstream large vision-language models on the benchmark and found several insightful conclusions. For more information, please refer to our benchmark at www.bobbywu.com/SOKBench.
Read more5/20/2024
0
Reframing Spatial Reasoning Evaluation in Language Models: A Real-World Simulation Benchmark for Qualitative Reasoning
Fangjun Li, David C. Hogg, Anthony G. Cohn
Spatial reasoning plays a vital role in both human cognition and machine intelligence, prompting new research into language models' (LMs) capabilities in this regard. However, existing benchmarks reveal shortcomings in evaluating qualitative spatial reasoning (QSR). These benchmarks typically present oversimplified scenarios or unclear natural language descriptions, hindering effective evaluation. We present a novel benchmark for assessing QSR in LMs, which is grounded in realistic 3D simulation data, offering a series of diverse room layouts with various objects and their spatial relationships. This approach provides a more detailed and context-rich narrative for spatial reasoning evaluation, diverging from traditional, toy-task-oriented scenarios. Our benchmark encompasses a broad spectrum of qualitative spatial relationships, including topological, directional, and distance relations. These are presented with different viewing points, varied granularities, and density of relation constraints to mimic real-world complexities. A key contribution is our logic-based consistency-checking tool, which enables the assessment of multiple plausible solutions, aligning with real-world scenarios where spatial relationships are often open to interpretation. Our benchmark evaluation of advanced LMs reveals their strengths and limitations in spatial reasoning. They face difficulties with multi-hop spatial reasoning and interpreting a mix of different view descriptions, pointing to areas for future improvement.
Read more5/27/2024
0
Multi-modal Situated Reasoning in 3D Scenes
Xiongkun Linghu, Jiangyong Huang, Xuesong Niu, Xiaojian Ma, Baoxiong Jia, Siyuan Huang
Situation awareness is essential for understanding and reasoning about 3D scenes in embodied AI agents. However, existing datasets and benchmarks for situated understanding are limited in data modality, diversity, scale, and task scope. To address these limitations, we propose Multi-modal Situated Question Answering (MSQA), a large-scale multi-modal situated reasoning dataset, scalably collected leveraging 3D scene graphs and vision-language models (VLMs) across a diverse range of real-world 3D scenes. MSQA includes 251K situated question-answering pairs across 9 distinct question categories, covering complex scenarios within 3D scenes. We introduce a novel interleaved multi-modal input setting in our benchmark to provide text, image, and point cloud for situation and question description, resolving ambiguity in previous single-modality convention (e.g., text). Additionally, we devise the Multi-modal Situated Next-step Navigation (MSNN) benchmark to evaluate models' situated reasoning for navigation. Comprehensive evaluations on MSQA and MSNN highlight the limitations of existing vision-language models and underscore the importance of handling multi-modal interleaved inputs and situation modeling. Experiments on data scaling and cross-domain transfer further demonstrate the efficacy of leveraging MSQA as a pre-training dataset for developing more powerful situated reasoning models.
Read more9/5/2024