A Statistical-Modelling Approach to Feedforward Neural Network Model Selection

Overview

• Feedforward neural networks (FNNs) are a type of non-linear regression model where input variables are combined through weighted sums and non-linear functions
• While these models share similarities with statistical modeling approaches, neural network research has largely occurred outside the field of statistics
• This has led to a lack of statistically-based methodology, particularly around model parsimony and architecture selection

Plain English Explanation

Feedforward neural networks (FNNs) are a type of machine learning model that can be used for non-linear regression. In these models, the input variables (or "covariates") are combined in a specific way to produce the output.

The key steps are:

1. The input variables are multiplied by individual "weights"
2. These weighted inputs are summed together
3. The sum is then passed through a non-linear function, like a sigmoid or ReLU

This allows the model to capture complex, non-linear relationships in the data. While FNNs share some similarities with traditional statistical modeling approaches, much of the research in this area has happened outside the field of statistics.

As a result, there has been less focus on developing statistically-grounded methods for selecting the model architecture - that is, determining the number and configuration of the hidden layers. This is an important consideration, as the model architecture directly impacts its complexity and ability to fit the data.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a novel approach for selecting the input variables and hidden layer architecture of feedforward neural networks, using the Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) as the model selection objective.

Traditionally, neural network architecture selection has often been done by comparing out-of-sample performance across different model configurations. However, the authors argue that using an information-theoretic criterion like BIC can lead to the recovery of the "true" underlying model structure, while still achieving good out-of-sample performance.

The proposed method performs joint selection of both the input variables and the number of hidden nodes. This is analogous to variable selection and model complexity determination in statistical modeling.

The authors evaluate their approach through simulation studies and real-world applications, demonstrating its advantages over relying solely on out-of-sample performance for model selection.

Critical Analysis

The key innovation of this work is the use of the BIC as the model selection objective, rather than relying on out-of-sample performance comparisons. This provides a more statistically-grounded approach to neural network architecture search.

That said, the authors acknowledge that their method may be computationally expensive, especially for larger networks. Additionally, the BIC criterion makes certain assumptions, such as the existence of a "true" underlying model, which may not always hold in practice.

Further research could explore the performance of this approach on a wider range of datasets and task types, as well as comparisons to other model selection techniques like Bayesian neural networks or approximate Bayesian inference. Investigating the robustness of the BIC-based approach to violations of its underlying assumptions would also be a valuable area of study.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach for selecting the architecture of feedforward neural networks, using the Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) as the model selection objective. By incorporating statistical principles into the model selection process, the authors aim to recover the underlying model structure while still achieving good out-of-sample performance.

The proposed method represents a step towards bridging the gap between neural network research and the field of statistics, potentially leading to more interpretable and parsimonious neural network models. Further research is needed to fully understand the strengths and limitations of this approach, but it demonstrates the value of integrating statistical reasoning into the development of advanced machine learning techniques.