Stochastic Controlled Averaging for Federated Learning with Communication Compression
0
🔍
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the challenge of communication compression in Federated Learning (FL) and proposes new algorithms to address them.
- Federated Learning is a distributed machine learning approach that aims to train models without centrally collecting sensitive data.
- Communication compression is a technique to reduce the amount of data transmitted during the FL process, which can help alleviate communication overhead.
- However, communication compression introduces new challenges in FL due to the interplay between compression-induced information distortion and inherent characteristics of FL, such as partial participation and data heterogeneity.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a technique called communication compression, which is used in Federated Learning (FL) to reduce the amount of data that needs to be transmitted over the network. This is important because FL involves training machine learning models without centrally collecting all the data, which can be a communication-intensive process.
By compressing the data, the researchers aim to make the FL process more efficient and reduce the overall communication costs. However, they explain that communication compression also brings new challenges in FL due to the way it can distort the information being transmitted, and how this interacts with the inherent characteristics of FL, such as the fact that not all devices participate fully, and the data on different devices can be quite different.
The paper proposes two new compressed FL algorithms, called SCALLION and SCAFCOM, that are designed to address these challenges. The key ideas are to use a more efficient formulation of a previous method, and to support both unbiased and biased compression techniques. The researchers claim these new algorithms outperform existing compressed FL methods in terms of communication and computation complexity, while also being able to handle a wider range of data heterogeneity without making additional assumptions about the compression errors.
Technical Explanation
The paper starts by revisiting a seminal stochastic controlled averaging method and proposing an equivalent but more efficient and simplified formulation that reduces the uplink communication costs by half. This serves as the foundation for the two compressed FL algorithms they introduce:
-
SCALLION: This algorithm supports unbiased compression, where the compressed update preserves the expected value of the full-precision update. This helps maintain the unbiased nature of the FL training process.
-
SCAFCOM: This algorithm supports biased compression, where the compressed update may have a different expected value than the full-precision update. This can provide additional flexibility and potential performance benefits in certain scenarios.
Both SCALLION and SCAFCOM are designed to accommodate arbitrary data heterogeneity among the participating devices in the FL system, without requiring any additional assumptions about the compression errors. The researchers show through experiments that these new algorithms can match the performance of corresponding full-precision FL approaches while substantially reducing the uplink communication costs, and they also outperform recent compressed FL methods under the same communication budget.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a valuable contribution by addressing the important challenge of communication compression in Federated Learning. The proposed SCALLION and SCAFCOM algorithms appear to be effective in reducing communication costs while maintaining model performance, even in the presence of data heterogeneity and partial participation.
However, the paper does not discuss the potential impact of the compression techniques on the overall robustness and convergence properties of the FL training process. Robust Federated Learning in Wireless Networks has shown that communication errors can have significant effects on FL, so further analysis of the resilience of the proposed methods would be helpful.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the tradeoffs between the unbiased and biased compression approaches, or provide guidance on when one might be preferable over the other. Investigating the practical implications and use cases for these different compression strategies could be an area for future research.
Conclusion
This paper addresses an important challenge in Federated Learning by proposing new compressed FL algorithms called SCALLION and SCAFCOM. These methods aim to reduce communication costs while accommodating data heterogeneity and partial participation, two key characteristics of FL systems.
The proposed algorithms show promising results in terms of communication and computation efficiency, matching the performance of full-precision FL approaches. This work contributes to the ongoing efforts to conquer communication constraints and overcome the "vanishing variance" problem in fully decentralized learning systems. Further research on the robustness and practical trade-offs of these compression techniques could help advance the field of Federated Learning and enable its wider adoption.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔍
0
Stochastic Controlled Averaging for Federated Learning with Communication Compression
Xinmeng Huang, Ping Li, Xiaoyun Li
Communication compression, a technique aiming to reduce the information volume to be transmitted over the air, has gained great interests in Federated Learning (FL) for the potential of alleviating its communication overhead. However, communication compression brings forth new challenges in FL due to the interplay of compression-incurred information distortion and inherent characteristics of FL such as partial participation and data heterogeneity. Despite the recent development, the performance of compressed FL approaches has not been fully exploited. The existing approaches either cannot accommodate arbitrary data heterogeneity or partial participation, or require stringent conditions on compression. In this paper, we revisit the seminal stochastic controlled averaging method by proposing an equivalent but more efficient/simplified formulation with halved uplink communication costs. Building upon this implementation, we propose two compressed FL algorithms, SCALLION and SCAFCOM, to support unbiased and biased compression, respectively. Both the proposed methods outperform the existing compressed FL methods in terms of communication and computation complexities. Moreover, SCALLION and SCAFCOM accommodates arbitrary data heterogeneity and do not make any additional assumptions on compression errors. Experiments show that SCALLION and SCAFCOM can match the performance of corresponding full-precision FL approaches with substantially reduced uplink communication, and outperform recent compressed FL methods under the same communication budget.
Read more4/10/2024
0
Bandwidth-Aware and Overlap-Weighted Compression for Communication-Efficient Federated Learning
Zichen Tang, Junlin Huang, Rudan Yan, Yuxin Wang, Zhenheng Tang, Shaohuai Shi, Amelie Chi Zhou, Xiaowen Chu
Current data compression methods, such as sparsification in Federated Averaging (FedAvg), effectively enhance the communication efficiency of Federated Learning (FL). However, these methods encounter challenges such as the straggler problem and diminished model performance due to heterogeneous bandwidth and non-IID (Independently and Identically Distributed) data. To address these issues, we introduce a bandwidth-aware compression framework for FL, aimed at improving communication efficiency while mitigating the problems associated with non-IID data. First, our strategy dynamically adjusts compression ratios according to bandwidth, enabling clients to upload their models at a close pace, thus exploiting the otherwise wasted time to transmit more data. Second, we identify the non-overlapped pattern of retained parameters after compression, which results in diminished client update signals due to uniformly averaged weights. Based on this finding, we propose a parameter mask to adjust the client-averaging coefficients at the parameter level, thereby more closely approximating the original updates, and improving the training convergence under heterogeneous environments. Our evaluations reveal that our method significantly boosts model accuracy, with a maximum improvement of 13% over the uncompressed FedAvg. Moreover, it achieves a $3.37times$ speedup in reaching the target accuracy compared to FedAvg with a Top-K compressor, demonstrating its effectiveness in accelerating convergence with compression. The integration of common compression techniques into our framework further establishes its potential as a versatile foundation for future cross-device, communication-efficient FL research, addressing critical challenges in FL and advancing the field of distributed machine learning.
Read more8/28/2024
0
ACCESS-FL: Agile Communication and Computation for Efficient Secure Aggregation in Stable Federated Learning Networks
Niousha Nazemi, Omid Tavallaie, Shuaijun Chen, Anna Maria Mandalari, Kanchana Thilakarathna, Ralph Holz, Hamed Haddadi, Albert Y. Zomaya
Federated Learning (FL) is a promising distributed learning framework designed for privacy-aware applications. FL trains models on client devices without sharing the client's data and generates a global model on a server by aggregating model updates. Traditional FL approaches risk exposing sensitive client data when plain model updates are transmitted to the server, making them vulnerable to security threats such as model inversion attacks where the server can infer the client's original training data from monitoring the changes of the trained model in different rounds. Google's Secure Aggregation (SecAgg) protocol addresses this threat by employing a double-masking technique, secret sharing, and cryptography computations in honest-but-curious and adversarial scenarios with client dropouts. However, in scenarios without the presence of an active adversary, the computational and communication cost of SecAgg significantly increases by growing the number of clients. To address this issue, in this paper, we propose ACCESS-FL, a communication-and-computation-efficient secure aggregation method designed for honest-but-curious scenarios in stable FL networks with a limited rate of client dropout. ACCESS-FL reduces the computation/communication cost to a constant level (independent of the network size) by generating shared secrets between only two clients and eliminating the need for double masking, secret sharing, and cryptography computations. To evaluate the performance of ACCESS-FL, we conduct experiments using the MNIST, FMNIST, and CIFAR datasets to verify the performance of our proposed method. The evaluation results demonstrate that our proposed method significantly reduces computation and communication overhead compared to state-of-the-art methods, SecAgg and SecAgg+.
Read more9/6/2024
🤖
0
Adaptive Compression in Federated Learning via Side Information
Berivan Isik, Francesco Pase, Deniz Gunduz, Sanmi Koyejo, Tsachy Weissman, Michele Zorzi
The high communication cost of sending model updates from the clients to the server is a significant bottleneck for scalable federated learning (FL). Among existing approaches, state-of-the-art bitrate-accuracy tradeoffs have been achieved using stochastic compression methods -- in which the client $n$ sends a sample from a client-only probability distribution $q_{phi^{(n)}}$, and the server estimates the mean of the clients' distributions using these samples. However, such methods do not take full advantage of the FL setup where the server, throughout the training process, has side information in the form of a global distribution $p_{theta}$ that is close to the clients' distribution $q_{phi^{(n)}}$ in Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence. In this work, we exploit this closeness between the clients' distributions $q_{phi^{(n)}}$'s and the side information $p_{theta}$ at the server, and propose a framework that requires approximately $D_{KL}(q_{phi^{(n)}}|| p_{theta})$ bits of communication. We show that our method can be integrated into many existing stochastic compression frameworks to attain the same (and often higher) test accuracy with up to $82$ times smaller bitrate than the prior work -- corresponding to 2,650 times overall compression.
Read more4/23/2024