Structure in Deep Reinforcement Learning: A Survey and Open Problems
2306.16021
0
0
Abstract
Reinforcement Learning (RL), bolstered by the expressive capabilities of Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) for function approximation, has demonstrated considerable success in numerous applications. However, its practicality in addressing various real-world scenarios, characterized by diverse and unpredictable dynamics, noisy signals, and large state and action spaces, remains limited. This limitation stems from poor data efficiency, limited generalization capabilities, a lack of safety guarantees, and the absence of interpretability, among other factors. To overcome these challenges and improve performance across these crucial metrics, one promising avenue is to incorporate additional structural information about the problem into the RL learning process. Various sub-fields of RL have proposed methods for incorporating such inductive biases. We amalgamate these diverse methodologies under a unified framework, shedding light on the role of structure in the learning problem, and classify these methods into distinct patterns of incorporating structure. By leveraging this comprehensive framework, we provide valuable insights into the challenges of structured RL and lay the groundwork for a design pattern perspective on RL research. This novel perspective paves the way for future advancements and aids in developing more effective and efficient RL algorithms that can potentially handle real-world scenarios better.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper provides a comprehensive survey of the role of structure in reinforcement learning (RL) and highlights several open problems in this area.
- The authors examine how incorporating different forms of structural information can enhance RL algorithms and lead to more efficient and effective learning.
- Key topics covered include graph reinforcement learning, model-based RL, and imitation learning, among others.
Plain English Explanation
Reinforcement learning is a type of machine learning where an agent learns to make decisions by interacting with its environment and receiving rewards or penalties for those decisions. However, traditional RL approaches can be inefficient, especially when dealing with complex, structured environments.
This paper explores how incorporating structural information can improve the performance of RL algorithms. For example, Graph Reinforcement Learning: A Survey of Combinatorial Optimization discusses how RL can be used to solve complex optimization problems represented as graphs.
The paper also covers Model-Based Imitation Learning, which allows an agent to learn from demonstrations by building a model of the environment, and Robust Reinforcement Learning Objectives for Sequential Recommender Systems, which explores how to make RL more resilient to changes in the environment.
By incorporating structural information, RL algorithms can become more efficient, effective, and adaptable, leading to better performance in a wide range of real-world applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by providing an overview of the role of structure in reinforcement learning. The authors discuss how incorporating different forms of structural information, such as graph representations, models of the environment, and imitation learning, can enhance the performance of RL algorithms.
One key area explored is Graph Reinforcement Learning, which leverages the inherent structure of problems represented as graphs to solve complex combinatorial optimization tasks more efficiently.
The paper also covers Model-Based Imitation Learning, where the agent builds a model of the environment based on observed demonstrations and then uses this model to learn optimal policies.
Additionally, the authors discuss Robust Reinforcement Learning Objectives for sequential recommender systems, which aims to make RL more resilient to changes in the environment.
The paper also explores the use of Structural Information Principles to guide the design of RL algorithms and improve their sample efficiency and generalization capabilities.
Throughout the survey, the authors highlight several open problems and future research directions in this rapidly evolving field of RL.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive and insightful overview of the role of structure in reinforcement learning, highlighting numerous promising research directions. However, the authors acknowledge that the field is still relatively young, and there are several challenges that need to be addressed.
One potential limitation is the difficulty of effectively incorporating structural information into RL algorithms, particularly in complex, dynamic environments. The authors note that more research is needed to develop robust and scalable methods for leveraging different forms of structural information.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential biases or limitations of the various structural RL approaches discussed. For example, the use of model-based imitation learning could be susceptible to issues like distributional shift if the demonstration data is not representative of the true environment.
Future research should also explore the ethical implications of deploying structural RL systems in high-stakes domains, such as decision-making for autonomous systems or personalized recommendation engines. Ensuring the fairness, transparency, and accountability of these algorithms will be crucial.
Conclusion
This paper provides a valuable and comprehensive survey of the role of structure in reinforcement learning. By incorporating different forms of structural information, RL algorithms can become more efficient, effective, and adaptable, leading to significant improvements in a wide range of real-world applications.
The authors have highlighted several promising research directions, such as Graph Reinforcement Learning, Model-Based Imitation Learning, and Robust Reinforcement Learning Objectives, which have the potential to push the boundaries of what is possible with RL.
As the field of structural RL continues to evolve, it will be crucial to address the remaining challenges and ensure that these powerful techniques are developed and deployed responsibly, with a keen eye on their societal impact.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
On the Role of Information Structure in Reinforcement Learning for Partially-Observable Sequential Teams and Games
Awni Altabaa, Zhuoran Yang
0
0
In a sequential decision-making problem, the information structure is the description of how events in the system occurring at different points in time affect each other. Classical models of reinforcement learning (e.g., MDPs, POMDPs) assume a simple and highly regular information structure, while more general models like predictive state representations do not explicitly model the information structure. By contrast, real-world sequential decision-making problems typically involve a complex and time-varying interdependence of system variables, requiring a rich and flexible representation of information structure. In this paper, we formalize a novel reinforcement learning model which explicitly represents the information structure. We then use this model to carry out an information-structural analysis of the statistical hardness of general sequential decision-making problems, obtaining a characterization via a graph-theoretic quantity of the DAG representation of the information structure. We prove an upper bound on the sample complexity of learning a general sequential decision-making problem in terms of its information structure by exhibiting an algorithm achieving the upper bound. This recovers known tractability results and gives a novel perspective on reinforcement learning in general sequential decision-making problems, providing a systematic way of identifying new tractable classes of problems.
5/29/2024
🤷
Unsupervised Representation Learning in Deep Reinforcement Learning: A Review
Nicol`o Botteghi, Mannes Poel, Christoph Brune
0
0
This review addresses the problem of learning abstract representations of the measurement data in the context of Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL). While the data are often ambiguous, high-dimensional, and complex to interpret, many dynamical systems can be effectively described by a low-dimensional set of state variables. Discovering these state variables from the data is a crucial aspect for (i) improving the data efficiency, robustness, and generalization of DRL methods, (ii) tackling the curse of dimensionality, and (iii) bringing interpretability and insights into black-box DRL. This review provides a comprehensive and complete overview of unsupervised representation learning in DRL by describing the main Deep Learning tools used for learning representations of the world, providing a systematic view of the method and principles, summarizing applications, benchmarks and evaluation strategies, and discussing open challenges and future directions.
5/2/2024
Effective Reinforcement Learning Based on Structural Information Principles
Xianghua Zeng, Hao Peng, Dingli Su, Angsheng Li
0
0
Although Reinforcement Learning (RL) algorithms acquire sequential behavioral patterns through interactions with the environment, their effectiveness in noisy and high-dimensional scenarios typically relies on specific structural priors. In this paper, we propose a novel and general Structural Information principles-based framework for effective Decision-Making, namely SIDM, approached from an information-theoretic perspective. This paper presents a specific unsupervised partitioning method that forms vertex communities in the state and action spaces based on their feature similarities. An aggregation function, which utilizes structural entropy as the vertex weight, is devised within each community to obtain its embedding, thereby facilitating hierarchical state and action abstractions. By extracting abstract elements from historical trajectories, a directed, weighted, homogeneous transition graph is constructed. The minimization of this graph's high-dimensional entropy leads to the generation of an optimal encoding tree. An innovative two-layer skill-based learning mechanism is introduced to compute the common path entropy of each state transition as its identified probability, thereby obviating the requirement for expert knowledge. Moreover, SIDM can be flexibly incorporated into various single-agent and multi-agent RL algorithms, enhancing their performance. Finally, extensive evaluations on challenging benchmarks demonstrate that, compared with SOTA baselines, our framework significantly and consistently improves the policy's quality, stability, and efficiency up to 32.70%, 88.26%, and 64.86%, respectively.
4/16/2024
Zero-Sum Positional Differential Games as a Framework for Robust Reinforcement Learning: Deep Q-Learning Approach
Anton Plaksin, Vitaly Kalev
0
0
Robust Reinforcement Learning (RRL) is a promising Reinforcement Learning (RL) paradigm aimed at training robust to uncertainty or disturbances models, making them more efficient for real-world applications. Following this paradigm, uncertainty or disturbances are interpreted as actions of a second adversarial agent, and thus, the problem is reduced to seeking the agents' policies robust to any opponent's actions. This paper is the first to propose considering the RRL problems within the positional differential game theory, which helps us to obtain theoretically justified intuition to develop a centralized Q-learning approach. Namely, we prove that under Isaacs's condition (sufficiently general for real-world dynamical systems), the same Q-function can be utilized as an approximate solution of both minimax and maximin Bellman equations. Based on these results, we present the Isaacs Deep Q-Network algorithms and demonstrate their superiority compared to other baseline RRL and Multi-Agent RL algorithms in various environments.
5/6/2024