A Survey of Meta-features Used for Automated Selection of Algorithms for Black-box Single-objective Continuous Optimization
2406.06629
0
0
Abstract
The selection of the most appropriate algorithm to solve a given problem instance, known as algorithm selection, is driven by the potential to capitalize on the complementary performance of different algorithms across sets of problem instances. However, determining the optimal algorithm for an unseen problem instance has been shown to be a challenging task, which has garnered significant attention from researchers in recent years. In this survey, we conduct an overview of the key contributions to algorithm selection in the field of single-objective continuous black-box optimization. We present ongoing work in representation learning of meta-features for optimization problem instances, algorithm instances, and their interactions. We also study machine learning models for automated algorithm selection, configuration, and performance prediction. Through this analysis, we identify gaps in the state of the art, based on which we present ideas for further development of meta-feature representations.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper provides a comprehensive survey of meta-features used for automated selection of algorithms for black-box single-objective continuous optimization.
- Meta-features are characteristics of optimization problems that can be used to intelligently select the most appropriate optimization algorithm for a given problem.
- The survey examines a wide range of meta-features, including problem properties, algorithm performance measures, and other characteristics that can inform algorithm selection.
- By understanding which meta-features are most useful for this task, researchers can develop more effective algorithm selection systems to solve complex optimization problems.
Plain English Explanation
When faced with a challenging optimization problem, such as finding the optimal configuration for a machine learning model, it can be difficult to know which optimization algorithm will work best. Different algorithms have their own strengths and weaknesses, and the performance of an algorithm can depend heavily on the specific characteristics of the problem at hand.
This paper aims to address this challenge by surveying the various meta-features that have been used to help automate the selection of optimization algorithms. Meta-features are essentially characteristics or properties of an optimization problem that can provide clues about which algorithm might work best.
For example, some problems may have a lot of constraints or multiple objectives, while others may have a highly irregular or discontinuous objective function. By understanding these problem-specific characteristics, researchers can develop intelligent systems that can automatically select the most appropriate optimization algorithm for a given problem, without the user having to manually try different approaches.
The survey examines a wide range of meta-features, including properties of the problem itself, measures of algorithm performance, and other characteristics that can inform the algorithm selection process. By understanding which meta-features are most useful, the researchers hope to pave the way for more effective and efficient algorithm selection in the future.
Technical Explanation
The paper provides a comprehensive survey of the meta-features that have been used for automated selection of algorithms for black-box single-objective continuous optimization problems. Meta-features are characteristics of optimization problems that can be used to intelligently select the most appropriate optimization algorithm for a given problem.
The survey examines a wide range of meta-features, including:
- Problem properties, such as the dimensionality, constraints, and characteristics of the objective function
- Algorithm performance measures, such as convergence rate, solution quality, and computational cost
- Other characteristics, such as the problem's landscape, structure, and difficulty
By understanding which meta-features are most useful for this task, the researchers aim to help develop more effective algorithm selection systems that can solve complex optimization problems more efficiently.
The paper reviews a large number of existing studies that have explored the use of meta-features for algorithm selection. It categorizes and analyzes the different types of meta-features, their computational complexity, and their effectiveness in predicting algorithm performance.
The authors also discuss the challenges and limitations of current meta-feature-based algorithm selection approaches, such as the difficulty of accurately characterizing complex optimization problems and the need for robust performance models. They suggest potential areas for future research, such as the development of more sophisticated meta-feature extraction techniques and the integration of machine learning methods for algorithm selection.
Critical Analysis
The survey provides a comprehensive and well-structured overview of the meta-features used for automated algorithm selection in black-box single-objective continuous optimization. The authors have clearly put a significant effort into reviewing and synthesizing the existing literature on this topic.
One potential limitation of the survey is that it primarily focuses on single-objective optimization problems, while many real-world optimization tasks involve multiple objectives. The authors acknowledge this limitation and suggest that future research should also examine meta-features for multi-objective optimization.
Additionally, the survey does not delve deeply into the specific methods and algorithms used for meta-feature extraction and algorithm selection. While the authors provide a high-level overview of these techniques, a more detailed discussion of their strengths, weaknesses, and comparative performance could have been valuable.
Nevertheless, the survey serves as an important reference for researchers and practitioners working in the field of optimization algorithm selection. By highlighting the key meta-features and their practical applications, the paper provides a solid foundation for the development of more intelligent and effective algorithm selection systems.
Conclusion
This survey paper offers a comprehensive overview of the meta-features used for automated selection of algorithms in black-box single-objective continuous optimization. By examining a wide range of problem characteristics, algorithm performance measures, and other relevant features, the authors have laid the groundwork for the development of more effective and efficient algorithm selection systems.
The insights provided in this paper can have significant implications for a variety of optimization-related applications, from hyperparameter tuning in machine learning to the design of complex engineering systems. By leveraging meta-features to intelligently select the most appropriate optimization algorithms, researchers and practitioners can save time, reduce computational costs, and ultimately achieve better-optimized solutions to their problems.
As the field of optimization continues to evolve, this survey provides a valuable resource for understanding the current state of the art in meta-feature-based algorithm selection, as well as promising directions for future research in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
Multi-Objective Hyperparameter Optimization in Machine Learning -- An Overview
Florian Karl, Tobias Pielok, Julia Moosbauer, Florian Pfisterer, Stefan Coors, Martin Binder, Lennart Schneider, Janek Thomas, Jakob Richter, Michel Lang, Eduardo C. Garrido-Merch'an, Juergen Branke, Bernd Bischl
0
0
Hyperparameter optimization constitutes a large part of typical modern machine learning workflows. This arises from the fact that machine learning methods and corresponding preprocessing steps often only yield optimal performance when hyperparameters are properly tuned. But in many applications, we are not only interested in optimizing ML pipelines solely for predictive accuracy; additional metrics or constraints must be considered when determining an optimal configuration, resulting in a multi-objective optimization problem. This is often neglected in practice, due to a lack of knowledge and readily available software implementations for multi-objective hyperparameter optimization. In this work, we introduce the reader to the basics of multi-objective hyperparameter optimization and motivate its usefulness in applied ML. Furthermore, we provide an extensive survey of existing optimization strategies, both from the domain of evolutionary algorithms and Bayesian optimization. We illustrate the utility of MOO in several specific ML applications, considering objectives such as operating conditions, prediction time, sparseness, fairness, interpretability and robustness.
6/7/2024
Unlock the Power of Algorithm Features: A Generalization Analysis for Algorithm Selection
Xingyu Wu, Yan Zhong, Jibin Wu, Yuxiao Huang, Sheng-hao Wu, Kay Chen Tan
0
0
In the algorithm selection research, the discussion surrounding algorithm features has been significantly overshadowed by the emphasis on problem features. Although a few empirical studies have yielded evidence regarding the effectiveness of algorithm features, the potential benefits of incorporating algorithm features into algorithm selection models and their suitability for different scenarios remain unclear. In this paper, we address this gap by proposing the first provable guarantee for algorithm selection based on algorithm features, taking a generalization perspective. We analyze the benefits and costs associated with algorithm features and investigate how the generalization error is affected by different factors. Specifically, we examine adaptive and predefined algorithm features under transductive and inductive learning paradigms, respectively, and derive upper bounds for the generalization error based on their model's Rademacher complexity. Our theoretical findings not only provide tight upper bounds, but also offer analytical insights into the impact of various factors, such as the training scale of problem instances and candidate algorithms, model parameters, feature values, and distributional differences between the training and test data. Notably, we demonstrate how models will benefit from algorithm features in complex scenarios involving many algorithms, and proves the positive correlation between generalization error bound and $chi^2$-divergence of distributions.
6/4/2024
Frugal Algorithm Selection
Erdem Kuc{s}, Ozgur Akgun, Nguyen Dang, Ian Miguel
0
0
When solving decision and optimisation problems, many competing algorithms (model and solver choices) have complementary strengths. Typically, there is no single algorithm that works well for all instances of a problem. Automated algorithm selection has been shown to work very well for choosing a suitable algorithm for a given instance. However, the cost of training can be prohibitively large due to running candidate algorithms on a representative set of training instances. In this work, we explore reducing this cost by choosing a subset of the training instances on which to train. We approach this problem in three ways: using active learning to decide based on prediction uncertainty, augmenting the algorithm predictors with a timeout predictor, and collecting training data using a progressively increasing timeout. We evaluate combinations of these approaches on six datasets from ASLib and present the reduction in labelling cost achieved by each option.
5/21/2024
💬
Large Language Model-Enhanced Algorithm Selection: Towards Comprehensive Algorithm Representation
Xingyu Wu, Yan Zhong, Jibin Wu, Bingbing Jiang, Kay Chen Tan
0
0
Algorithm selection, a critical process of automated machine learning, aims to identify the most suitable algorithm for solving a specific problem prior to execution. Mainstream algorithm selection techniques heavily rely on problem features, while the role of algorithm features remains largely unexplored. Due to the intrinsic complexity of algorithms, effective methods for universally extracting algorithm information are lacking. This paper takes a significant step towards bridging this gap by introducing Large Language Models (LLMs) into algorithm selection for the first time. By comprehending the code text, LLM not only captures the structural and semantic aspects of the algorithm, but also demonstrates contextual awareness and library function understanding. The high-dimensional algorithm representation extracted by LLM, after undergoing a feature selection module, is combined with the problem representation and passed to the similarity calculation module. The selected algorithm is determined by the matching degree between a given problem and different algorithms. Extensive experiments validate the performance superiority of the proposed model and the efficacy of each key module. Furthermore, we present a theoretical upper bound on model complexity, showcasing the influence of algorithm representation and feature selection modules. This provides valuable theoretical guidance for the practical implementation of our method.
5/17/2024