Synthetic Programming Elicitation and Repair for Text-to-Code in Very Low-Resource Programming Languages
2406.03636
0
0
Abstract
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) for code applications have demonstrated remarkable zero-shot fluency and instruction following on challenging code related tasks ranging from test case generation to self-repair. Unsurprisingly, however, models struggle to compose syntactically valid programs in programming languages unrepresented in pre-training, referred to as very low-resource Programming Languages (VLPLs). VLPLs appear in crucial settings, including domain-specific languages for internal tools and tool-chains for legacy languages. Inspired by an HCI technique called natural program elicitation, we propose designing an intermediate language that LLMs ``naturally'' know how to use and which can be automatically compiled to a target VLPL. When LLMs generate code that lies outside of this intermediate language, we use compiler techniques to repair the code into programs in the intermediate language. Overall, we introduce emph{synthetic programming elicitation and compilation} (SPEAC), an approach that enables LLMs to generate syntactically valid code even for VLPLs. We empirically evaluate the performance of SPEAC in a case study and find that, compared to existing retrieval and fine-tuning baselines, SPEAC produces syntactically correct programs significantly more frequently without sacrificing semantic correctness.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel approach called Synthetic Programming Elicitation and Repair (SPER) for text-to-code translation in very low-resource programming languages.
- SPER leverages large language models to generate and repair code from natural language descriptions, even for programming languages with limited training data available.
- The paper explores techniques to guide the code generation process and provide automated feedback to users, improving the accuracy and usability of the system.
Plain English Explanation
Translating natural language descriptions into working computer code can be a challenging task, especially for programming languages that don't have a lot of existing data and examples available. This paper introduces a new system called SPER that aims to address this problem.
The key idea behind SPER is to use large language models - powerful AI systems trained on vast amounts of text data - to generate and then refine the computer code based on the user's natural language input. Even for programming languages with limited resources, SPER can leverage the general language understanding capabilities of these models to produce relevant code snippets.
The paper also explores ways to guide the code generation process and provide helpful feedback to users. This helps ensure the final code is accurate and meets the user's original intent, even if the initial attempt wasn't perfect.
By making text-to-code translation more accessible for low-resource programming languages, SPER has the potential to democratize coding and make it more approachable for a wider range of users. It could be particularly useful for developing new programming languages or enabling coding in underserved communities.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel approach called Synthetic Programming Elicitation and Repair (SPER) for text-to-code translation in very low-resource programming languages. SPER leverages large language models (LLMs) to generate and repair code from natural language descriptions, even when limited training data is available for the target programming language.
The core of the SPER system is a code generation module that uses an LLM to translate the user's natural language input into an initial code snippet. To improve the accuracy of this generated code, SPER then employs a code repair module that analyzes the output and provides feedback to the user. This feedback can include suggestions for modifying or extending the code to better match the original intent.
The paper explores different techniques for guiding the code generation process, such as using prompts that incorporate domain-specific knowledge or providing the LLM with a schema or type system for the target programming language. These approaches help steer the model towards more relevant and correct code generation.
Additionally, the authors investigate methods for automating the code repair process, allowing the system to identify and fix common errors or suboptimal constructs in the initial code output. This includes using techniques like program synthesis and specification mining to infer the user's true intent and provide meaningful feedback.
Through a series of experiments and user studies, the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of the SPER approach in improving text-to-code translation accuracy and usability, especially for low-resource programming languages. The results suggest that SPER can be a valuable tool for democratizing coding and enabling more accessible programming experiences.
Critical Analysis
The SPER approach presented in this paper represents a significant advancement in the field of text-to-code translation, particularly for programming languages with limited training data available. By leveraging the power of large language models, the system is able to generate relevant code even in low-resource settings.
One potential limitation of the research, however, is the reliance on synthetic data generation for training and evaluating the system. While this approach allowed the authors to test SPER in a controlled setting, it raises questions about how the system would perform on real-world, user-generated natural language inputs. Further testing with diverse user populations and real-world use cases would be valuable to fully assess the system's capabilities and limitations.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential ethical implications of such a system. As text-to-code translation becomes more accessible, there may be concerns about the misuse of the technology or the potential for perpetuating biases present in the underlying language models. Addressing these issues proactively would be an important next step for the research.
Overall, the SPER approach represents a promising direction for advancing text-to-code translation, particularly in underserved programming language communities. By continuing to refine the system and addressing potential challenges, the researchers could unlock new possibilities for democratizing coding and making programming more accessible to a wider audience.
Conclusion
The Synthetic Programming Elicitation and Repair (SPER) system presented in this paper offers a novel approach to text-to-code translation for low-resource programming languages. By leveraging the power of large language models, SPER can generate and repair code from natural language descriptions, even when limited training data is available for the target programming language.
The key innovations of the SPER system include techniques for guiding the code generation process and automating the code repair feedback loop. These advancements help improve the accuracy and usability of the text-to-code translation, making it more accessible and valuable for a wide range of users and programming language communities.
While the reliance on synthetic data and the potential ethical implications of the technology warrant further investigation, the SPER approach represents an important step forward in democratizing coding and enabling more inclusive access to programming. As the field of text-to-code translation continues to evolve, this research could pave the way for exciting new possibilities in how we interact with and create software.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
š¬
Guiding Enumerative Program Synthesis with Large Language Models
Yixuan Li, Julian Parsert, Elizabeth Polgreen
0
0
Pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) are beginning to dominate the discourse around automatic code generation with natural language specifications. In contrast, the best-performing synthesizers in the domain of formal synthesis with precise logical specifications are still based on enumerative algorithms. In this paper, we evaluate the abilities of LLMs to solve formal synthesis benchmarks by carefully crafting a library of prompts for the domain. When one-shot synthesis fails, we propose a novel enumerative synthesis algorithm, which integrates calls to an LLM into a weighted probabilistic search. This allows the synthesizer to provide the LLM with information about the progress of the enumerator, and the LLM to provide the enumerator with syntactic guidance in an iterative loop. We evaluate our techniques on benchmarks from the Syntax-Guided Synthesis (SyGuS) competition. We find that GPT-3.5 as a stand-alone tool for formal synthesis is easily outperformed by state-of-the-art formal synthesis algorithms, but our approach integrating the LLM into an enumerative synthesis algorithm shows significant performance gains over both the LLM and the enumerative synthesizer alone and the winning SyGuS competition tool.
5/28/2024
Program Synthesis Benchmark for Visual Programming in XLogoOnline Environment
Chao Wen, Jacqueline Staub, Adish Singla
0
0
Large language and multimodal models have shown remarkable successes on various benchmarks focused on specific skills such as general-purpose programming, natural language understanding, math word problem-solving, and visual question answering. However, it is unclear how well these models perform on tasks that require a combination of these skills. In this paper, we curate a novel program synthesis benchmark based on the XLogoOnline visual programming environment. The benchmark comprises 85 real-world tasks from the Mini-level of the XLogoOnline environment, each requiring a combination of different skills such as spatial planning, basic programming, and logical reasoning. Our evaluation shows that current state-of-the-art models like GPT-4V and Llama3-70B struggle to solve these tasks, achieving only 20% and 2.35% success rates. Next, we develop a fine-tuning pipeline to boost the performance of models by leveraging a large-scale synthetic training dataset with over 80000 tasks. Moreover, we showcase how emulator-driven feedback can be used to design a curriculum over training data distribution. We showcase that a fine-tuned Llama3-8B drastically outperforms GPT-4V and Llama3-70B models, and provide an in-depth analysis of the models' expertise across different skill dimensions. We will publicly release the benchmark for future research on program synthesis in visual programming.
6/18/2024
HYSYNTH: Context-Free LLM Approximation for Guiding Program Synthesis
Shraddha Barke, Emmanuel Anaya Gonzalez, Saketh Ram Kasibatla, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick, Nadia Polikarpova
0
0
Many structured prediction and reasoning tasks can be framed as program synthesis problems, where the goal is to generate a program in a domain-specific language (DSL) that transforms input data into the desired output. Unfortunately, purely neural approaches, such as large language models (LLMs), often fail to produce fully correct programs in unfamiliar DSLs, while purely symbolic methods based on combinatorial search scale poorly to complex problems. Motivated by these limitations, we introduce a hybrid approach, where LLM completions for a given task are used to learn a task-specific, context-free surrogate model, which is then used to guide program synthesis. We evaluate this hybrid approach on three domains, and show that it outperforms both unguided search and direct sampling from LLMs, as well as existing program synthesizers.
5/28/2024
š¬
Can Large Language Models Code Like a Linguist?: A Case Study in Low Resource Sound Law Induction
Atharva Naik, Kexun Zhang, Nathaniel Robinson, Aravind Mysore, Clayton Marr, Hong Sng Rebecca Byrnes, Anna Cai, Kalvin Chang, David Mortensen
0
0
Historical linguists have long written a kind of incompletely formalized ''program'' that converts reconstructed words in an ancestor language into words in one of its attested descendants that consist of a series of ordered string rewrite functions (called sound laws). They do this by observing pairs of words in the reconstructed language (protoforms) and the descendent language (reflexes) and constructing a program that transforms protoforms into reflexes. However, writing these programs is error-prone and time-consuming. Prior work has successfully scaffolded this process computationally, but fewer researchers have tackled Sound Law Induction (SLI), which we approach in this paper by casting it as Programming by Examples. We propose a language-agnostic solution that utilizes the programming ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) by generating Python sound law programs from sound change examples. We evaluate the effectiveness of our approach for various LLMs, propose effective methods to generate additional language-agnostic synthetic data to fine-tune LLMs for SLI, and compare our method with existing automated SLI methods showing that while LLMs lag behind them they can complement some of their weaknesses.
6/19/2024