System-level Safety Guard: Safe Tracking Control through Uncertain Neural Network Dynamics Models
2312.06810
0
0
Abstract
The Neural Network (NN), as a black-box function approximator, has been considered in many control and robotics applications. However, difficulties in verifying the overall system safety in the presence of uncertainties hinder the deployment of NN modules in safety-critical systems. In this paper, we leverage the NNs as predictive models for trajectory tracking of unknown dynamical systems. We consider controller design in the presence of both intrinsic uncertainty and uncertainties from other system modules. In this setting, we formulate the constrained trajectory tracking problem and show that it can be solved using Mixed-integer Linear Programming (MILP). The proposed MILP-based approach is empirically demonstrated in robot navigation and obstacle avoidance through simulations. The demonstration videos are available at https://xiaolisean.github.io/publication/2023-11-01-L4DC2024.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Presents a "system-level safety guard" approach for safe tracking control in systems with uncertain neural network dynamics models
- Aims to provide safety guarantees while accounting for errors and uncertainties in the neural network model
- Combines model predictive control with a safety-aware backup controller to ensure safe operation
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a method for controlling complex systems, like robots or autonomous vehicles, in a safe and reliable way, even when the mathematical model of the system's behavior (its "dynamics") is uncertain or imperfect. This is a common challenge when using machine learning techniques, like neural networks, to model the dynamics.
The key idea is to use a combination of model predictive control and a backup "safety guard" controller. The model predictive control component uses the neural network dynamics model to plan the best control actions to follow a desired trajectory. However, since the neural network model may have errors, the safety guard component monitors the system and can take over control if it detects that the system is getting too close to an unsafe state like a collision or instability - see related work on providing safety assurances.
By combining these two controllers, the approach aims to achieve safe and robust control, even with an imperfect neural network dynamics model. This could enable the use of more expressive neural network models like the neural network based approach to hybrid systems while still providing safety guarantees, potentially leading to more capable and reliable autonomous systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the problem of safe tracking control for systems with uncertain neural network dynamics models. They introduce a "system-level safety guard" approach that combines model predictive control with a safety-aware backup controller.
The model predictive control component uses the neural network dynamics model to plan optimal control actions to follow a desired trajectory. However, to account for errors and uncertainties in the neural network model, the safety guard component monitors the system state and can override the model predictive control if it detects the system is approaching an unsafe region of the state space.
The authors derive theoretical guarantees for the safety and stability of the overall control system, and demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through simulations of a quadrotor aircraft example.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for addressing the challenge of safe control with uncertain dynamics models, a common issue when using neural networks. The combination of model predictive control and a safety-aware backup controller seems like a reasonable way to leverage the flexibility of neural network models while maintaining robust safety guarantees.
That said, the authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for future work. For example, the theoretical guarantees rely on the ability to accurately estimate the bounded region of uncertainty for the neural network model, which may be difficult in practice. Additionally, the approach may be computationally intensive, especially for real-time control of high-dimensional systems.
Further research could explore ways to improve the computational efficiency of the method, perhaps through more efficient optimization techniques or approximations. Validating the approach on physical systems and comparing it to other safe control methods would also be valuable next steps.
Overall, this paper presents an interesting and promising direction for safe control of complex systems with uncertain dynamics, but there are still some challenges to address before the approach could be widely deployed in real-world applications.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a "system-level safety guard" approach for safe tracking control in systems with uncertain neural network dynamics models. By combining model predictive control with a safety-aware backup controller, the method aims to leverage the expressive power of neural networks while still providing robust safety guarantees.
The key insights are the theoretical analysis showing the safety and stability of the overall control system, and the demonstration of the approach on a quadrotor aircraft example. While there are still some practical limitations to address, this work represents an important step towards enabling the use of more advanced machine learning techniques in safety-critical control applications.
As autonomous systems become more prevalent in our lives, techniques like this that can provide strong safety assurances will be crucial for building public trust and ensuring the reliable and responsible deployment of these technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Efficient model predictive control for nonlinear systems modelled by deep neural networks
Jianglin Lan
0
0
This paper presents a model predictive control (MPC) for dynamic systems whose nonlinearity and uncertainty are modelled by deep neural networks (NNs), under input and state constraints. Since the NN output contains a high-order complex nonlinearity of the system state and control input, the MPC problem is nonlinear and challenging to solve for real-time control. This paper proposes two types of methods for solving the MPC problem: the mixed integer programming (MIP) method which produces an exact solution to the nonlinear MPC, and linear relaxation (LR) methods which generally give suboptimal solutions but are much computationally cheaper. Extensive numerical simulation for an inverted pendulum system modelled by ReLU NNs of various sizes is used to demonstrate and compare performance of the MIP and LR methods.
5/20/2024
Providing Safety Assurances for Systems with Unknown Dynamics
Hao Wang, Javier Borquez, Somil Bansal
0
0
As autonomous systems become more complex and integral in our society, the need to accurately model and safely control these systems has increased significantly. In the past decade, there has been tremendous success in using deep learning techniques to model and control systems that are difficult to model using first principles. However, providing safety assurances for such systems remains difficult, partially due to the uncertainty in the learned model. In this work, we aim to provide safety assurances for systems whose dynamics are not readily derived from first principles and, hence, are more advantageous to be learned using deep learning techniques. Given the system of interest and safety constraints, we learn an ensemble model of the system dynamics from data. Leveraging ensemble uncertainty as a measure of uncertainty in the learned dynamics model, we compute a maximal robust control invariant set, starting from which the system is guaranteed to satisfy the safety constraints under the condition that realized model uncertainties are contained in the predefined set of admissible model uncertainty. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our method using a simulated case study with an inverted pendulum and a hardware experiment with a TurtleBot. The experiments show that our method robustifies the control actions of the system against model uncertainty and generates safe behaviors without being overly restrictive. The codes and accompanying videos can be found on the project website.
5/7/2024
🧠
Provably Safe Neural Network Controllers via Differential Dynamic Logic
Samuel Teuber, Stefan Mitsch, Andr'e Platzer
0
0
While neural networks (NNs) have potential as autonomous controllers for Cyber-Physical Systems, verifying the safety of NN based control systems (NNCSs) poses significant challenges for the practical use of NNs, especially when safety is needed for unbounded time horizons. One reason is the intractability of analyzing NNs, ODEs and hybrid systems. To this end, we introduce VerSAILLE (Verifiably Safe AI via Logically Linked Envelopes): The first general approach that allows reusing control theory results for NNCS verification. By joining forces, we exploit the efficiency of NN verification tools while retaining the rigor of differential dynamic logic (dL). Based on provably safe control envelopes in dL, we derive specifications for the NN which is proven via NN verification. We show that a proof of the NN adhering to the specification is mirrored by a dL proof on the infinite-time safety of the NNCS. The NN verification properties resulting from hybrid systems typically contain nonlinear arithmetic and arbitrary logical structures while efficient NN verification merely supports linear constraints. To overcome this divide, we present Mosaic: An efficient, sound and complete verification approach for polynomial real arithmetic properties on piece-wise linear NNs. Mosaic partitions complex verification queries into simple queries and lifts off-the-shelf linear constraint tools to the nonlinear setting in a completeness-preserving manner by combining approximation with exact reasoning for counterexample regions. Our evaluation demonstrates the versatility of VerSAILLE and Mosaic: We prove infinite-time safety on the classical Vertical Airborne Collision Avoidance NNCS verification benchmark for two scenarios while (exhaustively) enumerating counterexample regions in unsafe scenarios. We also show that our approach significantly outperforms State-of-the-Art tools in closed-loop NNV.
6/17/2024
🏅
Verified Safe Reinforcement Learning for Neural Network Dynamic Models
Junlin Wu, Huan Zhang, Yevgeniy Vorobeychik
0
0
Learning reliably safe autonomous control is one of the core problems in trustworthy autonomy. However, training a controller that can be formally verified to be safe remains a major challenge. We introduce a novel approach for learning verified safe control policies in nonlinear neural dynamical systems while maximizing overall performance. Our approach aims to achieve safety in the sense of finite-horizon reachability proofs, and is comprised of three key parts. The first is a novel curriculum learning scheme that iteratively increases the verified safe horizon. The second leverages the iterative nature of gradient-based learning to leverage incremental verification, reusing information from prior verification runs. Finally, we learn multiple verified initial-state-dependent controllers, an idea that is especially valuable for more complex domains where learning a single universal verified safe controller is extremely challenging. Our experiments on five safe control problems demonstrate that our trained controllers can achieve verified safety over horizons that are as much as an order of magnitude longer than state-of-the-art baselines, while maintaining high reward, as well as a perfect safety record over entire episodes.
5/28/2024