TAME: Task Agnostic Continual Learning using Multiple Experts
2210.03869
0
0
👁️
Abstract
The goal of lifelong learning is to continuously learn from non-stationary distributions, where the non-stationarity is typically imposed by a sequence of distinct tasks. Prior works have mostly considered idealistic settings, where the identity of tasks is known at least at training. In this paper we focus on a fundamentally harder, so-called task-agnostic setting where the task identities are not known and the learning machine needs to infer them from the observations. Our algorithm, which we call TAME (Task-Agnostic continual learning using Multiple Experts), automatically detects the shift in data distributions and switches between task expert networks in an online manner. At training, the strategy for switching between tasks hinges on an extremely simple observation that for each new coming task there occurs a statistically-significant deviation in the value of the loss function that marks the onset of this new task. At inference, the switching between experts is governed by the selector network that forwards the test sample to its relevant expert network. The selector network is trained on a small subset of data drawn uniformly at random. We control the growth of the task expert networks as well as selector network by employing online pruning. Our experimental results show the efficacy of our approach on benchmark continual learning data sets, outperforming the previous task-agnostic methods and even the techniques that admit task identities at both training and testing, while at the same time using a comparable model size.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper focuses on a challenging problem in continual learning called the "task-agnostic" setting, where the learning algorithm must infer the task identity from the observations alone, without being explicitly told the task identity.
- The proposed algorithm, TAME (Task-Agnostic continual learning using Multiple Experts), automatically detects shifts in data distributions and switches between task-specific expert networks in an online manner.
- TAME leverages a simple observation that the onset of a new task is marked by a statistically significant deviation in the loss function value.
- The selector network, trained on a small subset of data, is responsible for forwarding test samples to the relevant expert network.
- TAME controls the growth of the task expert networks and the selector network through online pruning.
Plain English Explanation
Continual learning is the ability to continuously learn from non-stationary distributions, where the data changes over time, often due to a sequence of distinct tasks. Previous work has often assumed that the identity of the tasks is known during training. However, in many real-world scenarios, the task identity is not known, and the learning algorithm must infer it from the data. This is known as the "task-agnostic" setting, and it is the focus of this paper.
The researchers propose an algorithm called TAME (Task-Agnostic continual learning using Multiple Experts) that can automatically detect when the data distribution shifts, indicating a new task, and switch between task-specific expert networks accordingly. The key insight is that the onset of a new task is marked by a statistically significant change in the value of the loss function. The algorithm uses a selector network, trained on a small subset of data, to route new inputs to the appropriate expert network.
To prevent the model from growing indefinitely, TAME employs online pruning to control the size of the task expert networks and the selector network. This allows the model to adapt to new tasks without becoming too large and unwieldy.
Technical Explanation
The paper addresses the task-agnostic continual learning problem, where the learning agent must infer the task identity from the observations alone, without being explicitly told the task labels. This is a fundamentally harder problem than the typical continual learning setting, where the task identity is known during training.
The proposed TAME algorithm consists of three key components:
-
Task Expert Networks: These are specialized neural networks, each trained to solve a particular task. TAME automatically detects when the data distribution shifts, indicating a new task, and switches to the appropriate expert network.
-
Selector Network: This network is responsible for routing new inputs to the relevant expert network. It is trained on a small subset of data drawn uniformly at random.
-
Online Pruning: TAME employs a strategy to control the growth of the task expert networks and the selector network, preventing the model from becoming too large and unwieldy.
The core insight behind TAME is that the onset of a new task is marked by a statistically significant deviation in the value of the loss function. This observation is used to trigger the switching between task expert networks during training.
At inference, the selector network forwards the test sample to the relevant expert network. The selector network is trained on a small subset of data, which helps it generalize to new tasks.
The experimental results show that TAME outperforms previous task-agnostic methods and even techniques that have access to task identities at both training and testing, while using a comparable model size. This is achieved through the effective learning of alternative ways of performing the task and the efficient management of the model complexity.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to the task-agnostic continual learning problem, which is a challenging and important problem in the field. The key strength of TAME is its ability to automatically detect task shifts and switch between experts without requiring explicit task labels, making it a practical solution for real-world scenarios.
However, the paper does not address certain limitations and potential issues with the proposed approach:
-
Sensitivity to Hyperparameters: The performance of TAME may be sensitive to the choice of hyperparameters, such as the threshold for detecting a statistically significant change in the loss function. This could make it difficult to apply the algorithm in a wide range of settings without extensive tuning.
-
Generalization to Diverse Task Distributions: The paper primarily evaluates TAME on benchmark continual learning datasets, which may not capture the full complexity of real-world task distributions. Further research is needed to understand how TAME would perform in more diverse and challenging task scenarios.
-
Computational Efficiency: While TAME employs online pruning to control model size, the overall computational overhead of maintaining multiple expert networks and the selector network may still be a concern, especially for resource-constrained applications.
-
Interpretability: The paper does not discuss the interpretability of the TAME algorithm, which could be an important consideration for certain applications where the reasoning behind the task switching needs to be explainable.
Despite these potential limitations, the TAME algorithm represents an important step forward in the field of task-agnostic continual learning, and the insights it provides could inspire further research and development in this area.
Conclusion
The paper introduces TAME, a novel approach to task-agnostic continual learning that can automatically detect shifts in data distributions and switch between task-specific expert networks. TAME's key innovation is the use of a simple observation that the onset of a new task is marked by a statistically significant change in the loss function value, which allows it to infer task identity without being explicitly told.
The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of TAME, as it outperforms previous task-agnostic methods and even techniques that have access to task identities during both training and testing. This suggests that TAME could be a valuable tool for real-world applications that involve continuously learning from non-stationary data.
While the paper identifies some potential limitations, such as sensitivity to hyperparameters and computational efficiency, the TAME algorithm represents an important step forward in the field of continual learning and could inspire further research and development in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
✨
Continual Learning of Numerous Tasks from Long-tail Distributions
Liwei Kang, Wee Sun Lee
0
0
Continual learning, an important aspect of artificial intelligence and machine learning research, focuses on developing models that learn and adapt to new tasks while retaining previously acquired knowledge. Existing continual learning algorithms usually involve a small number of tasks with uniform sizes and may not accurately represent real-world learning scenarios. In this paper, we investigate the performance of continual learning algorithms with a large number of tasks drawn from a task distribution that is long-tail in terms of task sizes. We design one synthetic dataset and two real-world continual learning datasets to evaluate the performance of existing algorithms in such a setting. Moreover, we study an overlooked factor in continual learning, the optimizer states, e.g. first and second moments in the Adam optimizer, and investigate how it can be used to improve continual learning performance. We propose a method that reuses the optimizer states in Adam by maintaining a weighted average of the second moments from previous tasks. We demonstrate that our method, compatible with most existing continual learning algorithms, effectively reduces forgetting with only a small amount of additional computational or memory costs, and provides further improvements on existing continual learning algorithms, particularly in a long-tail task sequence.
4/4/2024
🤷
U-TELL: Unsupervised Task Expert Lifelong Learning
Indu Solomon, Aye Phyu Phyu Aung, Uttam Kumar, Senthilnath Jayavelu
0
0
Continual learning (CL) models are designed to learn new tasks arriving sequentially without re-training the network. However, real-world ML applications have very limited label information and these models suffer from catastrophic forgetting. To address these issues, we propose an unsupervised CL model with task experts called Unsupervised Task Expert Lifelong Learning (U-TELL) to continually learn the data arriving in a sequence addressing catastrophic forgetting. During training of U-TELL, we introduce a new expert on arrival of a new task. Our proposed architecture has task experts, a structured data generator and a task assigner. Each task expert is composed of 3 blocks; i) a variational autoencoder to capture the task distribution and perform data abstraction, ii) a k-means clustering module, and iii) a structure extractor to preserve latent task data signature. During testing, task assigner selects a suitable expert to perform clustering. U-TELL does not store or replay task samples, instead, we use generated structured samples to train the task assigner. We compared U-TELL with five SOTA unsupervised CL methods. U-TELL outperformed all baselines on seven benchmarks and one industry dataset for various CL scenarios with a training time over 6 times faster than the best performing baseline.
6/11/2024
Theory on Mixture-of-Experts in Continual Learning
Hongbo Li, Sen Lin, Lingjie Duan, Yingbin Liang, Ness B. Shroff
0
0
Continual learning (CL) has garnered significant attention because of its ability to adapt to new tasks that arrive over time. Catastrophic forgetting (of old tasks) has been identified as a major issue in CL, as the model adapts to new tasks. The Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) model has recently been shown to effectively mitigate catastrophic forgetting in CL, by employing a gating network to sparsify and distribute diverse tasks among multiple experts. However, there is a lack of theoretical analysis of MoE and its impact on the learning performance in CL. This paper provides the first theoretical results to characterize the impact of MoE in CL via the lens of overparameterized linear regression tasks. We establish the benefit of MoE over a single expert by proving that the MoE model can diversify its experts to specialize in different tasks, while its router learns to select the right expert for each task and balance the loads across all experts. Our study further suggests an intriguing fact that the MoE in CL needs to terminate the update of the gating network after sufficient training rounds to attain system convergence, which is not needed in the existing MoE studies that do not consider the continual task arrival. Furthermore, we provide explicit expressions for the expected forgetting and overall generalization error to characterize the benefit of MoE in the learning performance in CL. Interestingly, adding more experts requires additional rounds before convergence, which may not enhance the learning performance. Finally, we conduct experiments on both synthetic and real datasets to extend these insights from linear models to deep neural networks (DNNs), which also shed light on the practical algorithm design for MoE in CL.
6/26/2024
Low-Rank Mixture-of-Experts for Continual Medical Image Segmentation
Qian Chen, Lei Zhu, Hangzhou He, Xinliang Zhang, Shuang Zeng, Qiushi Ren, Yanye Lu
0
0
The primary goal of continual learning (CL) task in medical image segmentation field is to solve the catastrophic forgetting problem, where the model totally forgets previously learned features when it is extended to new categories (class-level) or tasks (task-level). Due to the privacy protection, the historical data labels are inaccessible. Prevalent continual learning methods primarily focus on generating pseudo-labels for old datasets to force the model to memorize the learned features. However, the incorrect pseudo-labels may corrupt the learned feature and lead to a new problem that the better the model is trained on the old task, the poorer the model performs on the new tasks. To avoid this problem, we propose a network by introducing the data-specific Mixture of Experts (MoE) structure to handle the new tasks or categories, ensuring that the network parameters of previous tasks are unaffected or only minimally impacted. To further overcome the tremendous memory costs caused by introducing additional structures, we propose a Low-Rank strategy which significantly reduces memory cost. We validate our method on both class-level and task-level continual learning challenges. Extensive experiments on multiple datasets show our model outperforms all other methods.
6/21/2024