Task-level Distributionally Robust Optimization for Large Language Model-based Dense Retrieval
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a task-level distributionally robust optimization (DRO) approach to train large language model-based dense retrieval models.
- The goal is to improve the robustness and generalization of dense retrieval models to different query distributions at test time.
- The authors show that their DRO approach outperforms standard training methods on several benchmark datasets.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on dense retrieval models, which are a type of information retrieval system that uses large language models to efficiently find the most relevant documents for a given query.
The key challenge with dense retrieval models is that they can sometimes perform poorly when the distribution of queries at test time is different from the distribution used during training. To address this, the authors propose a distributionally robust optimization (DRO) approach, which trains the model to be more robust to variations in the query distribution.
The intuition behind DRO is that instead of optimizing the model to perform well on the average query, it optimizes the model to perform well on the "worst-case" query distribution within a certain uncertainty set. This encourages the model to learn features that are more generalizable and robust to distribution shifts.
The authors show that their DRO approach leads to significant performance improvements on several benchmark dense retrieval tasks, compared to standard training methods. This suggests that DRO can be a useful technique for improving the robustness and flexibility of large language model-based retrieval systems, especially when the target application domain may differ from the training data.
Technical Explanation
The key aspects of the paper's technical approach are:
-
Task-level DRO: The authors propose a task-level DRO formulation, where the uncertainty set is defined over the distribution of queries for a given task, rather than the overall data distribution. This allows the model to be optimized for robustness to query distribution shifts within a specific task.
-
Optimization Procedure: The authors use a min-max optimization procedure to solve the DRO problem, alternating between updating the model parameters to minimize the loss on the "worst-case" query distribution, and updating the worst-case distribution to maximize the loss.
-
Experiments: The authors evaluate their DRO approach on several dense retrieval benchmarks, including MS MARCO, TREC-DL, and BEIR. They compare the performance of their DRO-trained models to those trained using standard methods, and show significant improvements in robustness and generalization.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough empirical evaluation of the proposed DRO approach for dense retrieval. The authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for future work, such as:
- The need for more theoretical analysis to better understand the properties and convergence of the DRO optimization procedure.
- The potential for the DRO approach to be extended to other types of retrieval tasks beyond dense retrieval.
- The potential impact of different ways of defining the uncertainty set on the DRO model's performance.
One potential concern is the computational overhead of the DRO optimization procedure, which may be more expensive than standard training methods. The authors do not provide a detailed analysis of the training time or efficiency of their approach.
Overall, the paper presents a promising and well-executed approach to improving the robustness and generalization of large language model-based dense retrieval systems, which is an important problem in the field of information retrieval.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a task-level distributionally robust optimization (DRO) approach for training large language model-based dense retrieval models. The key idea is to optimize the model to perform well on the "worst-case" query distribution within a certain uncertainty set, rather than just optimizing for the average query performance.
The authors show that their DRO-trained models outperform standard training methods on several benchmark dense retrieval tasks, demonstrating improved robustness and generalization to different query distributions. This suggests that DRO can be a valuable technique for building more flexible and reliable large language model-based information retrieval systems, with potential applications in a wide range of domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Task-level Distributionally Robust Optimization for Large Language Model-based Dense Retrieval
Guangyuan Ma, Yongliang Ma, Xing Wu, Zhenpeng Su, Ming Zhou, Songlin Hu
Large Language Model-based Dense Retrieval (LLM-DR) optimizes over numerous heterogeneous fine-tuning collections from different domains. However, the discussion about its training data distribution is still minimal. Previous studies rely on empirically assigned dataset choices or sampling ratios, which inevitably leads to sub-optimal retrieval performances. In this paper, we propose a new task-level Distributionally Robust Optimization (tDRO) algorithm for LLM-DR fine-tuning, targeted at improving the universal domain generalization ability by end-to-end reweighting the data distribution of each task. The tDRO parameterizes the domain weights and updates them with scaled domain gradients. The optimized weights are then transferred to the LLM-DR fine-tuning to train more robust retrievers. Experiments show optimal improvements in large-scale retrieval benchmarks and reduce up to 30% dataset usage after applying our optimization algorithm with a series of different-sized LLM-DR models.
Read more8/21/2024
💬
0
Towards Robust Alignment of Language Models: Distributionally Robustifying Direct Preference Optimization
Junkang Wu, Yuexiang Xie, Zhengyi Yang, Jiancan Wu, Jiawei Chen, Jinyang Gao, Bolin Ding, Xiang Wang, Xiangnan He
This study addresses the challenge of noise in training datasets for Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), a method for aligning Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences. We categorize noise into pointwise noise, which includes low-quality data points, and pairwise noise, which encompasses erroneous data pair associations that affect preference rankings. Utilizing Distributionally Robust Optimization (DRO), we enhance DPO's resilience to these types of noise. Our theoretical insights reveal that DPO inherently embeds DRO principles, conferring robustness to pointwise noise, with the regularization coefficient $beta$ playing a critical role in its noise resistance. Extending this framework, we introduce Distributionally Robustifying DPO (Dr. DPO), which integrates pairwise robustness by optimizing against worst-case pairwise scenarios. The novel hyperparameter $beta'$ in Dr. DPO allows for fine-tuned control over data pair reliability, providing a strategic balance between exploration and exploitation in noisy training environments. Empirical evaluations demonstrate that Dr. DPO substantially improves the quality of generated text and response accuracy in preference datasets, showcasing enhanced performance in both noisy and noise-free settings. The code is available at https://github.com/junkangwu/Dr_DPO.
Read more7/11/2024
🤷
0
Leveraging LLMs for Unsupervised Dense Retriever Ranking
Ekaterina Khramtsova, Shengyao Zhuang, Mahsa Baktashmotlagh, Guido Zuccon
In this paper we present Large Language Model Assisted Retrieval Model Ranking (LARMOR), an effective unsupervised approach that leverages LLMs for selecting which dense retriever to use on a test corpus (target). Dense retriever selection is crucial for many IR applications that rely on using dense retrievers trained on public corpora to encode or search a new, private target corpus. This is because when confronted with domain shift, where the downstream corpora, domains, or tasks of the target corpus differ from the domain/task the dense retriever was trained on, its performance often drops. Furthermore, when the target corpus is unlabeled, e.g., in a zero-shot scenario, the direct evaluation of the model on the target corpus becomes unfeasible. Unsupervised selection of the most effective pre-trained dense retriever becomes then a crucial challenge. Current methods for dense retriever selection are insufficient in handling scenarios with domain shift. Our proposed solution leverages LLMs to generate pseudo-relevant queries, labels and reference lists based on a set of documents sampled from the target corpus. Dense retrievers are then ranked based on their effectiveness on these generated pseudo-relevant signals. Notably, our method is the first approach that relies solely on the target corpus, eliminating the need for both training corpora and test labels. To evaluate the effectiveness of our method, we construct a large pool of state-of-the-art dense retrievers. The proposed approach outperforms existing baselines with respect to both dense retriever selection and ranking. We make our code and results publicly available at https://github.com/ielab/larmor/.
Read more5/24/2024
0
Generalizing Few Data to Unseen Domains Flexibly Based on Label Smoothing Integrated with Distributionally Robust Optimization
Yangdi Wang, Zhi-Hai Zhang, Su Xiu Xu, Wenming Guo
Overfitting commonly occurs when applying deep neural networks (DNNs) on small-scale datasets, where DNNs do not generalize well from existing data to unseen data. The main reason resulting in overfitting is that small-scale datasets cannot reflect the situations of the real world. Label smoothing (LS) is an effective regularization method to prevent overfitting, avoiding it by mixing one-hot labels with uniform label vectors. However, LS only focuses on labels while ignoring the distribution of existing data. In this paper, we introduce the distributionally robust optimization (DRO) to LS, achieving shift the existing data distribution flexibly to unseen domains when training DNNs. Specifically, we prove that the regularization of LS can be extended to a regularization term for the DNNs parameters when integrating DRO. The regularization term can be utilized to shift existing data to unseen domains and generate new data. Furthermore, we propose an approximate gradient-iteration label smoothing algorithm (GI-LS) to achieve the findings and train DNNs. We prove that the shift for the existing data does not influence the convergence of GI-LS. Since GI-LS incorporates a series of hyperparameters, we further consider using Bayesian optimization (BO) to find the relatively optimal combinations of these hyperparameters. Taking small-scale anomaly classification tasks as a case, we evaluate GI-LS, and the results clearly demonstrate its superior performance.
Read more8/12/2024