Leveraging LLMs for Unsupervised Dense Retriever Ranking

Overview

• Presents a new method called LARMOR (Large Language Model Assisted Retrieval Model Ranking) for selecting effective pre-trained dense retrieval models
• LARMOR leverages large language models (LLMs) to generate pseudo-relevant queries, labels, and reference lists from a target corpus
• Allows selecting the most effective pre-trained dense retriever for the target corpus, even in zero-shot scenarios with domain shift

Plain English Explanation

Information retrieval (IR) systems often rely on "dense retrievers" - machine learning models trained to encode documents in a way that similar documents are close together. These dense retrievers are usually trained on large, public datasets. However, when using these dense retrievers on a new, private target corpus, their performance can drop significantly if the target corpus is in a different domain or covers different topics than the training data (a phenomenon known as "domain shift").

LARMOR aims to solve this problem by using large language models (LLMs) to generate pseudo-relevant signals (queries, labels, and reference lists) based on a sample of documents from the target corpus. These signals are then used to evaluate and rank a pool of pre-trained dense retrievers, allowing the selection of the most effective one for the target corpus, even in zero-shot scenarios where no labeled data is available.

The key innovation is that LARMOR requires no labeled data from the target corpus or training corpora - it relies solely on the target corpus itself to choose the best dense retriever. This makes it a powerful tool for deploying IR systems in new domains where labeled data may be scarce or unavailable.

Technical Explanation

The LARMOR approach works as follows:

1. A set of documents is sampled from the target corpus.
2. The LLM is used to generate pseudo-relevant queries, labels, and reference lists based on the sampled documents.
3. A pool of state-of-the-art pre-trained dense retrievers is then evaluated and ranked based on their performance on the generated pseudo-relevant signals.
4. The highest-ranked dense retriever is selected to be used on the full target corpus.

The authors construct a large pool of dense retrievers, including models from leading techniques like DocT5Query, Passage Retrieval with LLMs, and Personalization of LLMs. They show that LARMOR outperforms existing baselines for dense retriever selection and ranking, without requiring any labeled data from the target corpus or training corpora.

Critical Analysis

The LARMOR approach addresses an important challenge in information retrieval - how to effectively use dense retrievers on new, unlabeled target corpora that may differ from the data the retrievers were trained on. The authors' use of LLMs to generate pseudo-relevant signals is a clever solution to this problem.

However, the paper does not discuss potential limitations or caveats of the approach. For example, the quality and relevance of the pseudo-signals generated by the LLM could impact the accuracy of the dense retriever rankings. Additionally, the approach assumes that a sample of the target corpus is available, which may not always be the case in real-world scenarios.

Further research could explore ways to address these potential issues, such as techniques for improving the pseudo-signal generation or methods for dense retriever selection without any access to the target corpus. Additionally, it would be valuable to see the LARMOR approach evaluated on a wider range of target corpora and IR tasks to understand its broader applicability and limitations.

Conclusion

The LARMOR method presented in this paper offers a novel and effective solution for selecting the most appropriate pre-trained dense retrieval model when working with a new, unlabeled target corpus. By leveraging large language models to generate pseudo-relevant signals, LARMOR can effectively rank dense retrievers without requiring any labeled data from the target corpus or training corpora.

This capability could be transformative for many information retrieval applications, enabling the deployment of high-performing IR systems in new domains where labeled data is scarce or unavailable. As research in LLM-augmented retrieval and structured database retrieval continues to advance, LARMOR represents an important step forward in bridging the gap between pre-trained models and domain-specific IR needs.