Temporal True and Surrogate Fitness Landscape Analysis for Expensive Bi-Objective Optimisation
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the use of surrogate models to analyze the fitness landscape of expensive bi-objective optimization problems.
- It proposes a method for "temporal true and surrogate fitness landscape analysis" to understand how the fitness landscape changes over time during the optimization process.
- The authors evaluate their approach on a set of benchmark problems and demonstrate its potential to provide insights that can guide the selection of appropriate optimization algorithms.
Plain English Explanation
Optimizing complex systems often involves balancing multiple, sometimes conflicting, objectives. This can be a challenging task, especially when evaluating the performance of a system is computationally expensive or time-consuming.
The authors of this paper introduce a technique to help understand the underlying "fitness landscape" of these types of optimization problems. The fitness landscape is a way of visualizing the relationship between the different objectives, showing where the optimal solutions lie. However, for complex, expensive-to-evaluate problems, it can be difficult to fully explore the fitness landscape.
To address this, the researchers developed a method that uses "surrogate models" - simplified mathematical models that can approximate the true fitness landscape much more efficiently. By analyzing how the surrogate model's representation of the landscape changes over the course of the optimization process, the researchers were able to gain insights that could help guide the choice of optimization algorithm.
For example, the analysis might reveal that the landscape is highly complex and rugged, suggesting that a genetic algorithm would be a more suitable optimization approach than a gradient-based method. Or it could show that the landscape changes dramatically over time, indicating that the optimization strategy should be adjusted as the process progresses.
Overall, this work provides a valuable tool for understanding and navigating the challenges of expensive, multi-objective optimization problems, which have important applications in fields like engineering, finance, and scientific research.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a method called "Temporal True and Surrogate Fitness Landscape Analysis" (TTSFL) to study the fitness landscape of expensive bi-objective optimization problems. The key idea is to use surrogate models to approximate the true fitness landscape in a computationally efficient way, and then analyze how this surrogate landscape changes over the course of the optimization process.
The authors first construct a series of surrogate models at different stages of the optimization. These surrogate models are trained on a small set of true fitness evaluations, and are designed to provide a fast approximation of the full fitness landscape. The researchers then analyze the properties of these surrogate landscapes, such as their level of multimodality, ruggedness, and correlation between the objectives.
By comparing the characteristics of the surrogate landscapes over time, the authors are able to gain insights into how the true fitness landscape is evolving. For example, they may observe that the landscape becomes more complex and disconnected as the optimization progresses, suggesting that a different algorithm may be more suitable in the later stages.
The authors evaluate their TTSFL approach on a set of benchmark bi-objective optimization problems, including the ZDT test suite and the DTLZ test suite. They demonstrate that the temporal analysis of the surrogate landscapes can provide valuable information to guide the selection of appropriate optimization algorithms and parameters.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge several limitations of their approach. First, the accuracy of the TTSFL analysis is dependent on the quality of the surrogate models, which may struggle to capture the full complexity of the true fitness landscape, especially in the early stages of the optimization.
Additionally, the paper focuses only on bi-objective problems, and it's unclear how well the method would scale to problems with a larger number of objectives. The authors also note that the computational overhead of constructing and analyzing the surrogate models may be non-trivial, potentially reducing the overall efficiency of the optimization process.
Further research could explore ways to improve the sample-efficiency of the surrogate models, or investigate methods for automatically selecting the most appropriate optimization algorithm based on the TTSFL analysis. It would also be interesting to see applications of this approach to real-world, expensive multi-objective optimization problems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach for analyzing the fitness landscape of expensive bi-objective optimization problems using surrogate models. By studying how the surrogate landscape changes over the course of the optimization process, the researchers were able to gain insights that can guide the selection of appropriate optimization algorithms and parameters.
While the method has some limitations, it represents an important step forward in understanding the challenges of algorithmic fairness and enhancing the performance of multi-objective optimization in computationally expensive domains. Further development and application of this approach could have significant implications for a wide range of important optimization problems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Temporal True and Surrogate Fitness Landscape Analysis for Expensive Bi-Objective Optimisation
C. J. Rodriguez, S. L. Thomson, T. Alderliesten, P. A. N. Bosman
Many real-world problems have expensive-to-compute fitness functions and are multi-objective in nature. Surrogate-assisted evolutionary algorithms are often used to tackle such problems. Despite this, literature about analysing the fitness landscapes induced by surrogate models is limited, and even non-existent for multi-objective problems. This study addresses this critical gap by comparing landscapes of the true fitness function with those of surrogate models for multi-objective functions. Moreover, it does so temporally by examining landscape features at different points in time during optimisation, in the vicinity of the population at that point in time. We consider the BBOB bi-objective benchmark functions in our experiments. The results of the fitness landscape analysis reveals significant differences between true and surrogate features at different time points during optimisation. Despite these differences, the true and surrogate landscape features still show high correlations between each other. Furthermore, this study identifies which landscape features are related to search and demonstrates that both surrogate and true landscape features are capable of predicting algorithm performance. These findings indicate that temporal analysis of the landscape features may help to facilitate the design of surrogate switching approaches to improve performance in multi-objective optimisation.
Read more4/11/2024
0
Neural Exploratory Landscape Analysis
Zeyuan Ma, Jiacheng Chen, Hongshu Guo, Yue-Jiao Gong
Recent research in Meta-Black-Box Optimization (MetaBBO) have shown that meta-trained neural networks can effectively guide the design of black-box optimizers, significantly reducing the need for expert tuning and delivering robust performance across complex problem distributions. Despite their success, a paradox remains: MetaBBO still rely on human-crafted Exploratory Landscape Analysis features to inform the meta-level agent about the low-level optimization progress. To address the gap, this paper proposes Neural Exploratory Landscape Analysis (NeurELA), a novel framework that dynamically profiles landscape features through a two-stage, attention-based neural network, executed in an entirely end-to-end fashion. NeurELA is pre-trained over a variety of MetaBBO algorithms using a multi-task neuroevolution strategy. Extensive experiments show that NeurELA achieves consistently superior performance when integrated into different and even unseen MetaBBO tasks and can be efficiently fine-tuned for further performance boost. This advancement marks a pivotal step in making MetaBBO algorithms more autonomous and broadly applicable.
Read more8/21/2024
0
On the Hyperparameter Loss Landscapes of Machine Learning Models: An Exploratory Study
Mingyu Huang, Ke Li
Previous efforts on hyperparameter optimization (HPO) of machine learning (ML) models predominately focus on algorithmic advances, yet little is known about the topography of the underlying hyperparameter (HP) loss landscape, which plays a fundamental role in governing the search process of HPO. While several works have conducted fitness landscape analysis (FLA) on various ML systems, they are limited to properties of isolated landscape without interrogating the potential structural similarities among them. The exploration of such similarities can provide a novel perspective for understanding the mechanism behind modern HPO methods, but has been missing, possibly due to the expensive cost of large-scale landscape construction, and the lack of effective analysis methods. In this paper, we mapped 1,500 HP loss landscapes of 6 representative ML models on 63 datasets across different fidelity levels, with 11M+ configurations. By conducting exploratory analysis on these landscapes with fine-grained visualizations and dedicated FLA metrics, we observed a similar landscape topography across a wide range of models, datasets, and fidelities, and shed light on several central topics in HPO.
Read more5/27/2024
🐍
0
Efficient Learning of Accurate Surrogates for Simulations of Complex Systems
A. Diaw, M. McKerns, I. Sagert, L. G. Stanton, M. S. Murillo
Machine learning methods are increasingly used to build computationally inexpensive surrogates for complex physical models. The predictive capability of these surrogates suffers when data are noisy, sparse, or time-dependent. As we are interested in finding a surrogate that provides valid predictions of any potential future model evaluations, we introduce an online learning method empowered by optimizer-driven sampling. The method has two advantages over current approaches. First, it ensures that all turning points on the model response surface are included in the training data. Second, after any new model evaluations, surrogates are tested and retrained (updated) if the score drops below a validity threshold. Tests on benchmark functions reveal that optimizer-directed sampling generally outperforms traditional sampling methods in terms of accuracy around local extrema, even when the scoring metric favors overall accuracy. We apply our method to simulations of nuclear matter to demonstrate that highly accurate surrogates for the nuclear equation of state can be reliably auto-generated from expensive calculations using a few model evaluations.
Read more5/20/2024