Toward Holistic Planning and Control Optimization for Dual-Arm Rearrangement
2404.06758
0
0
Abstract
Long-horizon task and motion planning (TAMP) is notoriously difficult to solve, let alone optimally, due to the tight coupling between the interleaved (discrete) task and (continuous) motion planning phases, where each phase on its own is frequently an NP-hard or even PSPACE-hard computational challenge. In this study, we tackle the even more challenging goal of jointly optimizing task and motion plans for a real dual-arm system in which the two arms operate in close vicinity to solve highly constrained tabletop multi-object rearrangement problems. Toward that, we construct a tightly integrated planning and control optimization pipeline, Makespan-Optimized Dual-Arm Planner (MODAP) that combines novel sampling techniques for task planning with state-of-the-art trajectory optimization techniques. Compared to previous state-of-the-art, MODAP produces task and motion plans that better coordinate a dual-arm system, delivering significantly improved execution time improvements while simultaneously ensuring that the resulting time-parameterized trajectory conforms to specified acceleration and jerk limits.
Create account to get full access
Overview
ā¢ This research paper explores optimizing the planning and control of dual-arm robotic systems for rearrangement tasks. ā¢ The authors propose a holistic approach that considers both task-level planning and low-level control, aiming to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of dual-arm rearrangement. ā¢ The paper builds on previous work in task-motion planning, combined optimization and sampling, multi-agent planning, and multimodal robotic perception and planning.
Plain English Explanation
The paper addresses the challenge of efficiently rearranging objects using a robot with two arms. Traditionally, these tasks have been approached by first planning the high-level steps (the "task-level") and then figuring out the precise movements of the arms (the "motion-level"). However, the authors argue that this sequential approach can lead to suboptimal performance.
Instead, the researchers propose a more holistic approach that considers both the task-level planning and the low-level control of the arms together. This allows the system to make informed decisions that optimize the overall efficiency and effectiveness of the rearrangement process.
The key idea is to create a unified optimization framework that can simultaneously plan the task-level steps and control the motion of the arms. This means the system can consider factors like the smoothness of the arm movements, the energy efficiency, and the safety of the operation all at once, rather than treating them as separate concerns.
By taking this more comprehensive approach, the authors believe they can improve the speed and reliability of dual-arm rearrangement tasks, which have applications in areas like warehouse automation, household robotics, and manufacturing.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a novel approach to planning and control optimization for dual-arm rearrangement tasks. The authors develop a holistic optimization framework that jointly considers task-level planning and low-level control.
At the task level, the system plans a sequence of high-level actions, such as grasping, moving, and placing objects. This planning is formulated as a mixed-integer quadratic program (MIQP), which allows the optimization to consider factors like the order of operations, the stability of object placements, and the feasibility of arm movements.
At the motion level, the system generates smooth, energy-efficient trajectories for the dual arms using a quadratic programming (QP) based reference spreading control approach, as described in this paper. This ensures that the arms can execute the planned task-level actions safely and effectively.
The key innovation is the integration of these task-level and motion-level optimizations into a single, unified framework. By considering both aspects simultaneously, the system can make more informed decisions that optimize the overall performance of the rearrangement process.
The authors evaluate their approach through simulation experiments and demonstrate improvements in metrics like task completion time, energy consumption, and the stability of object placements compared to a sequential planning and control approach.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to addressing the challenge of dual-arm rearrangement tasks. The authors' holistic optimization framework is a promising step towards more efficient and effective robotic manipulation.
One potential limitation is the computational complexity of the MIQP-based task planning, which could make it challenging to scale the approach to more complex environments or real-time applications. The authors acknowledge this and suggest exploring techniques like factored task-motion planning or multi-agent planning to address this issue.
Additionally, the paper focuses primarily on simulation experiments, and it would be valuable to see the approach validated on physical dual-arm robotic systems. This could uncover practical challenges or constraints not captured in the simulations.
Overall, the research represents a significant contribution to the field of robotic manipulation and planning. The holistic optimization approach has the potential to enable more efficient and versatile dual-arm rearrangement capabilities, with applications in areas like warehouse automation, household robotics, and manufacturing.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to optimizing the planning and control of dual-arm robotic systems for rearrangement tasks. By considering task-level planning and low-level control together in a unified optimization framework, the authors aim to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of dual-arm manipulation.
The key innovation is the integration of task-level planning, formulated as a mixed-integer quadratic program, and motion-level control, using a quadratic programming-based reference spreading approach. This holistic optimization allows the system to make more informed decisions that balance factors like task completion time, energy consumption, and the stability of object placements.
The research builds on previous work in areas like task-motion planning, combined optimization and sampling, multi-agent planning, and multimodal robotic perception and planning. While the computational complexity of the task planning remains a challenge, the authors' approach represents a promising step towards more efficient and versatile dual-arm rearrangement capabilities with a wide range of practical applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
A Survey of Optimization-based Task and Motion Planning: From Classical To Learning Approaches
Zhigen Zhao, Shuo Cheng, Yan Ding, Ziyi Zhou, Shiqi Zhang, Danfei Xu, Ye Zhao
0
0
Task and Motion Planning (TAMP) integrates high-level task planning and low-level motion planning to equip robots with the autonomy to effectively reason over long-horizon, dynamic tasks. Optimization-based TAMP focuses on hybrid optimization approaches that define goal conditions via objective functions and are capable of handling open-ended goals, robotic dynamics, and physical interaction between the robot and the environment. Therefore, optimization-based TAMP is particularly suited to solve highly complex, contact-rich locomotion and manipulation problems. This survey provides a comprehensive review on optimization-based TAMP, covering (i) planning domain representations, including action description languages and temporal logic, (ii) individual solution strategies for components of TAMP, including AI planning and trajectory optimization (TO), and (iii) the dynamic interplay between logic-based task planning and model-based TO. A particular focus of this survey is to highlight the algorithm structures to efficiently solve TAMP, especially hierarchical and distributed approaches. Additionally, the survey emphasizes the synergy between the classical methods and contemporary learning-based innovations such as large language models. Furthermore, the future research directions for TAMP is discussed in this survey, highlighting both algorithmic and application-specific challenges.
7/2/2024
š¤æ
Factored Task and Motion Planning with Combined Optimization, Sampling and Learning
Joaquim Ortiz-Haro
0
0
In this thesis, we aim to improve the performance of TAMP algorithms from three complementary perspectives. First, we investigate the integration of discrete task planning with continuous trajectory optimization. Our main contribution is a conflict-based solver that automatically discovers why a task plan might fail when considering the constraints of the physical world. This information is then fed back into the task planner, resulting in an efficient, bidirectional, and intuitive interface between task and motion, capable of solving TAMP problems with multiple objects, robots, and tight physical constraints. In the second part, we first illustrate that, given the wide range of tasks and environments within TAMP, neither sampling nor optimization is superior in all settings. To combine the strengths of both approaches, we have designed meta-solvers for TAMP, adaptive solvers that automatically select which algorithms and computations to use and how to best decompose each problem to find a solution faster. In the third part, we combine deep learning architectures with model-based reasoning to accelerate computations within our TAMP solver. Specifically, we target infeasibility detection and nonlinear optimization, focusing on generalization, accuracy, compute time, and data efficiency. At the core of our contributions is a refined, factored representation of the trajectory optimization problems inside TAMP. This structure not only facilitates more efficient planning, encoding of geometric infeasibility, and meta-reasoning but also provides better generalization in neural architectures.
4/5/2024
š§Ŗ
COAST: Constraints and Streams for Task and Motion Planning
Brandon Vu, Toki Migimatsu, Jeannette Bohg
0
0
Task and Motion Planning (TAMP) algorithms solve long-horizon robotics tasks by integrating task planning with motion planning; the task planner proposes a sequence of actions towards a goal state and the motion planner verifies whether this action sequence is geometrically feasible for the robot. However, state-of-the-art TAMP algorithms do not scale well with the difficulty of the task and require an impractical amount of time to solve relatively small problems. We propose Constraints and Streams for Task and Motion Planning (COAST), a probabilistically-complete, sampling-based TAMP algorithm that combines stream-based motion planning with an efficient, constrained task planning strategy. We validate COAST on three challenging TAMP domains and demonstrate that our method outperforms baselines in terms of cumulative task planning time by an order of magnitude. You can find more supplementary materials on our project href{https://branvu.github.io/coast.github.io}{website}.
5/15/2024
š§
NOD-TAMP: Generalizable Long-Horizon Planning with Neural Object Descriptors
Shuo Cheng, Caelan Garrett, Ajay Mandlekar, Danfei Xu
0
0
Solving complex manipulation tasks in household and factory settings remains challenging due to long-horizon reasoning, fine-grained interactions, and broad object and scene diversity. Learning skills from demonstrations can be an effective strategy, but such methods often have limited generalizability beyond training data and struggle to solve long-horizon tasks. To overcome this, we propose to synergistically combine two paradigms: Neural Object Descriptors (NODs) that produce generalizable object-centric features and Task and Motion Planning (TAMP) frameworks that chain short-horizon skills to solve multi-step tasks. We introduce NOD-TAMP, a TAMP-based framework that extracts short manipulation trajectories from a handful of human demonstrations, adapts these trajectories using NOD features, and composes them to solve broad long-horizon, contact-rich tasks. NOD-TAMP solves existing manipulation benchmarks with a handful of demonstrations and significantly outperforms prior NOD-based approaches on new tabletop manipulation tasks that require diverse generalization. Finally, we deploy NOD-TAMP on a number of real-world tasks, including tool-use and high-precision insertion. For more details, please visit https://sites.google.com/view/nod-tamp/.
6/18/2024