Towards Clinician-Preferred Segmentation: Leveraging Human-in-the-Loop for Test Time Adaptation in Medical Image Segmentation

Read original: arXiv:2405.08270 - Published 5/15/2024 by Shishuai Hu, Zehui Liao, Zeyou Liu, Yong Xia

🖼️

Overview

Deep learning models for medical image segmentation often struggle when deployed across different healthcare facilities, due to differences in the distribution of the data.
Test Time Adaptation (TTA) methods have been used to help these models adapt to new data distributions, but existing TTA approaches have limitations.
This paper introduces a novel TTA framework called Human-in-the-loop TTA (HiTTA) that addresses these limitations.

Plain English Explanation

Deep learning models trained to analyze medical images, like X-rays or MRIs, can be very effective. However, these models often have trouble performing well when used at different healthcare facilities. This is because the data the models were trained on may look quite different from the data they encounter in the real world.

HiTTA aims to solve this problem by allowing the model to adapt to the new data it sees during deployment. The key insights of HiTTA are:

Incorporate Human Feedback: HiTTA taps into the knowledge of medical experts by incorporating their corrections to the model's predictions. This helps steer the model towards making predictions that align better with clinical expectations.
Reduce Prediction Divergence: HiTTA includes a special "divergence loss" that helps minimize the differences between the model's predictions and the actual data distribution. This allows the model to better fit the new data it encounters.

By combining these two approaches, HiTTA enables deep learning models to perform well across a variety of medical settings, even when the data looks quite different from what the model was originally trained on. This can make these powerful AI tools more useful and reliable in real-world clinical applications.

Technical Explanation

HiTTA builds upon existing Test Time Adaptation (TTA) methods, which aim to adapt pre-trained models to work well on new, different data distributions. However, previous TTA approaches have limitations, primarily focusing on manipulating Batch Normalization (BN) layers or using prompts and adversarial learning.

To address these limitations, HiTTA introduces two key innovations:

Leveraging Clinician Feedback: HiTTA incorporates corrections made by medical experts to the model's predictions. This human-in-the-loop approach helps steer the model towards making predictions that better align with clinical expectations, beyond just adapting to the new data distribution.
Divergence Loss: HiTTA introduces a novel "divergence loss" that is designed to minimize the discrepancy between the model's predictions and the actual data distribution. This targeted loss function helps the model better adapt to the specific differences in the new data it encounters.

The authors evaluate HiTTA on a public medical imaging dataset, and show that it outperforms existing TTA methods. This demonstrates the advantages of integrating human feedback and the divergence loss to enhance a model's performance and adaptability across diverse medical centers.

Critical Analysis

The HiTTA framework presented in this paper addresses an important challenge in the deployment of deep learning models for medical image segmentation. The authors' approach of incorporating clinician feedback and introducing a divergence loss are novel and promising ideas.

However, the paper does not provide a comprehensive analysis of the limitations or potential drawbacks of the HiTTA approach. For example, the reliance on human feedback may introduce new challenges, such as the availability and consistency of clinician annotations, or potential biases in their preferences.

Additionally, the paper could have delved deeper into the theoretical underpinnings of the divergence loss and how it compares to other domain adaptation techniques, such as entropy-based TTA or active TTA.

Further research could also explore the scalability of HiTTA, particularly in scenarios where large-scale clinician feedback may be difficult to obtain, or when dealing with highly diverse medical data distributions across multiple healthcare centers.

Conclusion

The HiTTA framework presented in this paper offers a novel approach to addressing the challenge of performance degradation in deep learning-based medical image segmentation models when deployed across different healthcare facilities.

By integrating clinician feedback and introducing a divergence loss, HiTTA demonstrates the ability to adapt pre-trained models to new data distributions while also ensuring that the model's predictions align more closely with clinical expectations. This dual-faceted capability can significantly enhance the relevance and real-world applicability of these powerful AI tools in medical settings.

The insights and innovations presented in this paper pave the way for further research and development in the field of domain adaptation for medical image analysis, ultimately contributing to the goal of making AI-powered healthcare solutions more robust and trustworthy across diverse clinical environments.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🖼️

Towards Clinician-Preferred Segmentation: Leveraging Human-in-the-Loop for Test Time Adaptation in Medical Image Segmentation

Shishuai Hu, Zehui Liao, Zeyou Liu, Yong Xia

Deep learning-based medical image segmentation models often face performance degradation when deployed across various medical centers, largely due to the discrepancies in data distribution. Test Time Adaptation (TTA) methods, which adapt pre-trained models to test data, have been employed to mitigate such discrepancies. However, existing TTA methods primarily focus on manipulating Batch Normalization (BN) layers or employing prompt and adversarial learning, which may not effectively rectify the inconsistencies arising from divergent data distributions. In this paper, we propose a novel Human-in-the-loop TTA (HiTTA) framework that stands out in two significant ways. First, it capitalizes on the largely overlooked potential of clinician-corrected predictions, integrating these corrections into the TTA process to steer the model towards predictions that coincide more closely with clinical annotation preferences. Second, our framework conceives a divergence loss, designed specifically to diminish the prediction divergence instigated by domain disparities, through the careful calibration of BN parameters. Our HiTTA is distinguished by its dual-faceted capability to acclimatize to the distribution of test data whilst ensuring the model's predictions align with clinical expectations, thereby enhancing its relevance in a medical context. Extensive experiments on a public dataset underscore the superiority of our HiTTA over existing TTA methods, emphasizing the advantages of integrating human feedback and our divergence loss in enhancing the model's performance and adaptability across diverse medical centers.

5/15/2024

Exploring Human-in-the-Loop Test-Time Adaptation by Synergizing Active Learning and Model Selection

Yushu Li, Yongyi Su, Xulei Yang, Kui Jia, Xun Xu

Existing test-time adaptation (TTA) approaches often adapt models with the unlabeled testing data stream. A recent attempt relaxed the assumption by introducing limited human annotation, referred to as Human-In-the-Loop Test-Time Adaptation (HILTTA) in this study. The focus of existing HILTTA studies lies in selecting the most informative samples to label, a.k.a. active learning. In this work, we are motivated by a pitfall of TTA, i.e. sensitivity to hyper-parameters, and propose to approach HILTTA by synergizing active learning and model selection. Specifically, we first select samples for human annotation (active learning) and then use the labeled data to select optimal hyper-parameters (model selection). To prevent the model selection process from overfitting to local distributions, multiple regularization techniques are employed to complement the validation objective. A sample selection strategy is further tailored by considering the balance between active learning and model selection purposes. We demonstrate on 5 TTA datasets that the proposed HILTTA approach is compatible with off-the-shelf TTA methods and such combinations substantially outperform the state-of-the-art HILTTA methods. Importantly, our proposed method can always prevent choosing the worst hyper-parameters on all off-the-shelf TTA methods. The source code will be released upon publication.

8/28/2024

Gradient Alignment Improves Test-Time Adaptation for Medical Image Segmentation

Ziyang Chen, Yiwen Ye, Yongsheng Pan, Yong Xia

Although recent years have witnessed significant advancements in medical image segmentation, the pervasive issue of domain shift among medical images from diverse centres hinders the effective deployment of pre-trained models. Many Test-time Adaptation (TTA) methods have been proposed to address this issue by fine-tuning pre-trained models with test data during inference. These methods, however, often suffer from less-satisfactory optimization due to suboptimal optimization direction (dictated by the gradient) and fixed step-size (predicated on the learning rate). In this paper, we propose the Gradient alignment-based Test-time adaptation (GraTa) method to improve both the gradient direction and learning rate in the optimization procedure. Unlike conventional TTA methods, which primarily optimize the pseudo gradient derived from a self-supervised objective, our method incorporates an auxiliary gradient with the pseudo one to facilitate gradient alignment. Such gradient alignment enables the model to excavate the similarities between different gradients and correct the gradient direction to approximate the empirical gradient related to the current segmentation task. Additionally, we design a dynamic learning rate based on the cosine similarity between the pseudo and auxiliary gradients, thereby empowering the adaptive fine-tuning of pre-trained models on diverse test data. Extensive experiments establish the effectiveness of the proposed gradient alignment and dynamic learning rate and substantiate the superiority of our GraTa method over other state-of-the-art TTA methods on a benchmark medical image segmentation task. The code and weights of pre-trained source models will be available.

8/19/2024

Single Image Test-Time Adaptation for Segmentation

Klara Janouskova, Tamir Shor, Chaim Baskin, Jiri Matas

Test-Time Adaptation (TTA) methods improve the robustness of deep neural networks to domain shift on a variety of tasks such as image classification or segmentation. This work explores adapting segmentation models to a single unlabelled image with no other data available at test-time. In particular, this work focuses on adaptation by optimizing self-supervised losses at test-time. Multiple baselines based on different principles are evaluated under diverse conditions and a novel adversarial training is introduced for adaptation with mask refinement. Our additions to the baselines result in a 3.51 and 3.28 % increase over non-adapted baselines, without these improvements, the increase would be 1.7 and 2.16 % only.

7/4/2024