Towards Counterfactual Fairness-aware Domain Generalization in Changing Environments
2309.13005
0
0
📉
Abstract
Recognizing the prevalence of domain shift as a common challenge in machine learning, various domain generalization (DG) techniques have been developed to enhance the performance of machine learning systems when dealing with out-of-distribution (OOD) data. Furthermore, in real-world scenarios, data distributions can gradually change across a sequence of sequential domains. While current methodologies primarily focus on improving model effectiveness within these new domains, they often overlook fairness issues throughout the learning process. In response, we introduce an innovative framework called Counterfactual Fairness-Aware Domain Generalization with Sequential Autoencoder (CDSAE). This approach effectively separates environmental information and sensitive attributes from the embedded representation of classification features. This concurrent separation not only greatly improves model generalization across diverse and unfamiliar domains but also effectively addresses challenges related to unfair classification. Our strategy is rooted in the principles of causal inference to tackle these dual issues. To examine the intricate relationship between semantic information, sensitive attributes, and environmental cues, we systematically categorize exogenous uncertainty factors into four latent variables: 1) semantic information influenced by sensitive attributes, 2) semantic information unaffected by sensitive attributes, 3) environmental cues influenced by sensitive attributes, and 4) environmental cues unaffected by sensitive attributes. By incorporating fairness regularization, we exclusively employ semantic information for classification purposes. Empirical validation on synthetic and real-world datasets substantiates the effectiveness of our approach, demonstrating improved accuracy levels while ensuring the preservation of fairness in the evolving landscape of continuous domains.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Introduces a new framework called Counterfactual Fairness-Aware Domain Generalization with Sequential Autoencoder (CDSAE) to address challenges in machine learning related to domain shift and fairness.
- CDSAE aims to improve model generalization across diverse domains while also ensuring fair classification.
- Rooted in causal inference, the approach systematically categorizes environmental uncertainty factors to separate sensitive attributes and environmental cues from classification features.
Plain English Explanation
Machine learning systems can struggle when faced with data that is different from what they were trained on, a problem known as domain shift. To address this, researchers have developed domain generalization (DG) techniques to help models perform better on out-of-distribution data.
In real-world scenarios, data distributions can gradually change over time across a sequence of domains. While current methods focus on improving model effectiveness in these new domains, they often overlook fairness issues that can arise during the learning process.
The new CDSAE framework introduced in this paper aims to address both domain generalization and fairness concerns. It does this by effectively separating environmental information and sensitive attributes (like race or gender) from the key features used for classification.
This separation not only improves the model's ability to generalize to diverse, unfamiliar domains, but also helps ensure the classifications are fair and unbiased. The approach is based on the principles of causal inference, systematically categorizing different types of environmental uncertainty factors.
By focusing classification exclusively on the semantic information unaffected by sensitive attributes, the CDSAE framework is able to achieve improved accuracy while preserving fairness as data distributions evolve across a sequence of domains.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces the Counterfactual Fairness-Aware Domain Generalization with Sequential Autoencoder (CDSAE) framework to address the dual challenges of domain shift and fairness in machine learning.
The key elements of the approach are:
-
Systematic categorization of exogenous uncertainty factors into four latent variables:
- Semantic information influenced by sensitive attributes
- Semantic information unaffected by sensitive attributes
- Environmental cues influenced by sensitive attributes
- Environmental cues unaffected by sensitive attributes
-
Separation of these factors through a sequential autoencoder architecture to isolate the semantic information unaffected by sensitive attributes for classification purposes.
-
Incorporation of fairness regularization to ensure the model's predictions are fair and unbiased, even as data distributions change across a sequence of domains.
The authors validate the effectiveness of CDSAE through empirical evaluation on both synthetic and real-world datasets. The results demonstrate improved accuracy levels while preserving fairness as the data landscape evolves.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a comprehensive and well-designed approach to address the important challenges of domain shift and fairness in machine learning. The systematic categorization of exogenous uncertainty factors and the use of causal inference principles are particularly noteworthy.
However, the paper could benefit from a more in-depth discussion of potential limitations and areas for further research. For example, the performance of CDSAE on larger, more complex real-world datasets, or its scalability to high-dimensional input spaces, could be explored further.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into potential computational or memory overhead introduced by the sequential autoencoder architecture, which could be a consideration for practical deployment.
Nevertheless, the CDSAE framework represents a significant advancement in the field of domain generalization, with a strong focus on maintaining fairness throughout the learning process. The paper encourages readers to think critically about the importance of addressing these dual concerns in machine learning systems as they become increasingly deployed in the real world.
Conclusion
The Counterfactual Fairness-Aware Domain Generalization with Sequential Autoencoder (CDSAE) framework introduced in this paper offers a novel and effective solution to the challenges of domain shift and fairness in machine learning. By systematically separating environmental information and sensitive attributes from classification features, CDSAE is able to improve model generalization across diverse domains while ensuring fair and unbiased predictions, even as data distributions evolve over time.
The rigorous theoretical foundations and empirical validation of this approach suggest that it could have significant implications for the development of more robust and equitable machine learning systems. As the field continues to grapple with the complexities of real-world data, the insights and techniques presented in this paper will likely become increasingly valuable.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Algorithmic Fairness Generalization under Covariate and Dependence Shifts Simultaneously
Chen Zhao, Kai Jiang, Xintao Wu, Haoliang Wang, Latifur Khan, Christan Grant, Feng Chen
0
0
The endeavor to preserve the generalization of a fair and invariant classifier across domains, especially in the presence of distribution shifts, becomes a significant and intricate challenge in machine learning. In response to this challenge, numerous effective algorithms have been developed with a focus on addressing the problem of fairness-aware domain generalization. These algorithms are designed to navigate various types of distribution shifts, with a particular emphasis on covariate and dependence shifts. In this context, covariate shift pertains to changes in the marginal distribution of input features, while dependence shift involves alterations in the joint distribution of the label variable and sensitive attributes. In this paper, we introduce a simple but effective approach that aims to learn a fair and invariant classifier by simultaneously addressing both covariate and dependence shifts across domains. We assert the existence of an underlying transformation model can transform data from one domain to another, while preserving the semantics related to non-sensitive attributes and classes. By augmenting various synthetic data domains through the model, we learn a fair and invariant classifier in source domains. This classifier can then be generalized to unknown target domains, maintaining both model prediction and fairness concerns. Extensive empirical studies on four benchmark datasets demonstrate that our approach surpasses state-of-the-art methods.
5/22/2024
Path-Specific Causal Reasoning for Fairness-aware Cognitive Diagnosis
Dacao Zhang, Kun Zhang, Le Wu, Mi Tian, Richang Hong, Meng Wang
0
0
Cognitive Diagnosis~(CD), which leverages students and exercise data to predict students' proficiency levels on different knowledge concepts, is one of fundamental components in Intelligent Education. Due to the scarcity of student-exercise interaction data, most existing methods focus on making the best use of available data, such as exercise content and student information~(e.g., educational context). Despite the great progress, the abuse of student sensitive information has not been paid enough attention. Due to the important position of CD in Intelligent Education, employing sensitive information when making diagnosis predictions will cause serious social issues. Moreover, data-driven neural networks are easily misled by the shortcut between input data and output prediction, exacerbating this problem. Therefore, it is crucial to eliminate the negative impact of sensitive information in CD models. In response, we argue that sensitive attributes of students can also provide useful information, and only the shortcuts directly related to the sensitive information should be eliminated from the diagnosis process. Thus, we employ causal reasoning and design a novel Path-Specific Causal Reasoning Framework (PSCRF) to achieve this goal. Specifically, we first leverage an encoder to extract features and generate embeddings for general information and sensitive information of students. Then, we design a novel attribute-oriented predictor to decouple the sensitive attributes, in which fairness-related sensitive features will be eliminated and other useful information will be retained. Finally, we designed a multi-factor constraint to ensure the performance of fairness and diagnosis performance simultaneously. Extensive experiments over real-world datasets (e.g., PISA dataset) demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed PSCRF.
6/6/2024
Causality-inspired Latent Feature Augmentation for Single Domain Generalization
Jian Xu, Chaojie Ji, Yankai Cao, Ye Li, Ruxin Wang
0
0
Single domain generalization (Single-DG) intends to develop a generalizable model with only one single training domain to perform well on other unknown target domains. Under the domain-hungry configuration, how to expand the coverage of source domain and find intrinsic causal features across different distributions is the key to enhancing the models' generalization ability. Existing methods mainly depend on the meticulous design of finite image-level transformation techniques and learning invariant features across domains based on statistical correlation between samples and labels in source domain. This makes it difficult to capture stable semantics between source and target domains, which hinders the improvement of the model's generalization performance. In this paper, we propose a novel causality-inspired latent feature augmentation method for Single-DG by learning the meta-knowledge of feature-level transformation based on causal learning and interventions. Instead of strongly relying on the finite image-level transformation, with the learned meta-knowledge, we can generate diverse implicit feature-level transformations in latent space based on the consistency of causal features and diversity of non-causal features, which can better compensate for the domain-hungry defect and reduce the strong reliance on initial finite image-level transformations and capture more stable domain-invariant causal features for generalization. Extensive experiments on several open-access benchmarks demonstrate the outstanding performance of our model over other state-of-the-art single domain generalization and also multi-source domain generalization methods.
6/11/2024
🌿
Modeling the Data-Generating Process is Necessary for Out-of-Distribution Generalization
Jivat Neet Kaur, Emre Kiciman, Amit Sharma
0
0
Recent empirical studies on domain generalization (DG) have shown that DG algorithms that perform well on some distribution shifts fail on others, and no state-of-the-art DG algorithm performs consistently well on all shifts. Moreover, real-world data often has multiple distribution shifts over different attributes; hence we introduce multi-attribute distribution shift datasets and find that the accuracy of existing DG algorithms falls even further. To explain these results, we provide a formal characterization of generalization under multi-attribute shifts using a canonical causal graph. Based on the relationship between spurious attributes and the classification label, we obtain realizations of the canonical causal graph that characterize common distribution shifts and show that each shift entails different independence constraints over observed variables. As a result, we prove that any algorithm based on a single, fixed constraint cannot work well across all shifts, providing theoretical evidence for mixed empirical results on DG algorithms. Based on this insight, we develop Causally Adaptive Constraint Minimization (CACM), an algorithm that uses knowledge about the data-generating process to adaptively identify and apply the correct independence constraints for regularization. Results on fully synthetic, MNIST, small NORB, and Waterbirds datasets, covering binary and multi-valued attributes and labels, show that adaptive dataset-dependent constraints lead to the highest accuracy on unseen domains whereas incorrect constraints fail to do so. Our results demonstrate the importance of modeling the causal relationships inherent in the data-generating process.
5/21/2024