Towards Geometry-Aware Pareto Set Learning for Neural Multi-Objective Combinatorial Optimization
2405.08604
0
0
🧠
Abstract
Multi-objective combinatorial optimization (MOCO) problems are prevalent in various real-world applications. Most existing neural MOCO methods rely on problem decomposition to transform an MOCO problem into a series of singe-objective combinatorial optimization (SOCO) problems. However, these methods often approximate partial regions of the Pareto front and spend excessive time on diversity enhancement because of ambiguous decomposition and time-consuming precise hypervolume calculation. To address these limitations, we design a Geometry-Aware Pareto set Learning algorithm named GAPL, which provides a novel geometric perspective for neural MOCO via a Pareto attention model based on hypervolume expectation maximization. In addition, we propose a hypervolume residual update strategy to enable the Pareto attention model to capture both local and non-local information of the Pareto set/front. We also design a novel inference approach to further improve quality of the solution set and speed up hypervolume calculation. Experimental results on three classic MOCO problems demonstrate that our GAPL outperforms several state-of-the-art baselines via superior decomposition and efficient diversity enhancement.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Multi-objective combinatorial optimization (MOCO) problems are common in real-world applications
- Existing neural methods for MOCO rely on decomposition and precise hypervolume to enhance diversity
- These methods often approximate limited regions of the Pareto front and spend excessive time on diversity enhancement
Plain English Explanation
Many real-world problems involve making the best decisions with multiple, sometimes conflicting goals. Existing AI methods for solving these multi-objective optimization problems often rely on breaking the problem into smaller pieces and precisely measuring how well the solutions cover the full range of possible tradeoffs. However, these methods tend to only find solutions that are good for certain goals, and the process of finding diverse solutions can take a long time.
To address these limitations, the researchers designed a new algorithm called GAPL (Geometry-Aware Pareto set Learning). GAPL takes a novel geometric approach, using a type of attention model to learn the shape of the Pareto set (the set of optimal tradeoff solutions). This allows GAPL to capture both local and global information about the Pareto set, leading to better solutions that cover a wider range of tradeoffs. GAPL also uses an improved method for measuring solution quality and diversity that is faster than previous approaches.
Technical Explanation
The key innovations in GAPL are:
-
Pareto Attention Model: GAPL uses a novel "Pareto attention" mechanism that learns the geometric structure of the Pareto set, rather than just decomposing the problem. This allows the model to capture both local and non-local information about the Pareto front.
-
Hypervolume Residual Update: GAPL proposes a hypervolume residual update strategy to efficiently update the Pareto attention model, avoiding the high computational cost of precise hypervolume calculation.
-
Efficient Inference: GAPL introduces a novel inference approach that improves the quality of the final solution set and speeds up hypervolume calculation and local subset selection.
Experiments on three classic MOCO problems show that GAPL outperforms state-of-the-art neural methods in terms of solution quality and diversity, thanks to its superior decomposition and efficient diversity enhancement.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a novel geometric perspective for neural MOCO, which addresses some key limitations of existing methods. However, the authors acknowledge that GAPL may struggle with problems with complex constraints or hierarchical objectives. Additionally, the paper does not explore fairness considerations in the multi-objective setting.
Further research could investigate ways to extend GAPL to handle a wider range of MOCO problem types and incorporate fairness constraints into the optimization process.
Conclusion
The GAPL algorithm offers a promising new approach to solving multi-objective combinatorial optimization problems, which are ubiquitous in real-world applications. By learning the geometric structure of the Pareto set, GAPL is able to find a diverse set of high-quality solutions more efficiently than previous methods. While the current version of GAPL has some limitations, the underlying ideas represent an important step forward in the field of multi-objective optimization.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Towards Efficient Pareto Set Approximation via Mixture of Experts Based Model Fusion
Anke Tang, Li Shen, Yong Luo, Shiwei Liu, Han Hu, Bo Du
0
0
Solving multi-objective optimization problems for large deep neural networks is a challenging task due to the complexity of the loss landscape and the expensive computational cost of training and evaluating models. Efficient Pareto front approximation of large models enables multi-objective optimization for various tasks such as multi-task learning and trade-off analysis. Existing algorithms for learning Pareto set, including (1) evolutionary, hypernetworks, and hypervolume-maximization methods, are computationally expensive and have restricted scalability to large models; (2) Scalarization algorithms, where a separate model is trained for each objective ray, which is inefficient for learning the entire Pareto set and fails to capture the objective trade-offs effectively. Inspired by the recent success of model merging, we propose a practical and scalable approach to Pareto set learning problem via mixture of experts (MoE) based model fusion. By ensembling the weights of specialized single-task models, the MoE module can effectively capture the trade-offs between multiple objectives and closely approximate the entire Pareto set of large neural networks. Once the routers are learned and a preference vector is set, the MoE module can be unloaded, thus no additional computational cost is introduced during inference. We conduct extensive experiments on vision and language tasks using large-scale models such as CLIP-ViT and GPT-2. The experimental results demonstrate that our method efficiently approximates the entire Pareto front of large models. Using only hundreds of trainable parameters of the MoE routers, our method even has lower memory usage compared to linear scalarization and algorithms that learn a single Pareto optimal solution, and are scalable to both the number of objectives and the size of the model.
6/17/2024
Collaborative Pareto Set Learning in Multiple Multi-Objective Optimization Problems
Chikai Shang, Rongguang Ye, Jiaqi Jiang, Fangqing Gu
0
0
Pareto Set Learning (PSL) is an emerging research area in multi-objective optimization, focusing on training neural networks to learn the mapping from preference vectors to Pareto optimal solutions. However, existing PSL methods are limited to addressing a single Multi-objective Optimization Problem (MOP) at a time. When faced with multiple MOPs, this limitation results in significant inefficiencies and hinders the ability to exploit potential synergies across varying MOPs. In this paper, we propose a Collaborative Pareto Set Learning (CoPSL) framework, which learns the Pareto sets of multiple MOPs simultaneously in a collaborative manner. CoPSL particularly employs an architecture consisting of shared and MOP-specific layers. The shared layers are designed to capture commonalities among MOPs collaboratively, while the MOP-specific layers tailor these general insights to generate solution sets for individual MOPs. This collaborative approach enables CoPSL to efficiently learn the Pareto sets of multiple MOPs in a single execution while leveraging the potential relationships among various MOPs. To further understand these relationships, we experimentally demonstrate that shareable representations exist among MOPs. Leveraging these shared representations effectively improves the capability to approximate Pareto sets. Extensive experiments underscore the superior efficiency and robustness of CoPSL in approximating Pareto sets compared to state-of-the-art approaches on a variety of synthetic and real-world MOPs. Code is available at https://github.com/ckshang/CoPSL.
4/30/2024
Multi-objective Neural Architecture Search by Learning Search Space Partitions
Yiyang Zhao, Linnan Wang, Tian Guo
0
0
Deploying deep learning models requires taking into consideration neural network metrics such as model size, inference latency, and #FLOPs, aside from inference accuracy. This results in deep learning model designers leveraging multi-objective optimization to design effective deep neural networks in multiple criteria. However, applying multi-objective optimizations to neural architecture search (NAS) is nontrivial because NAS tasks usually have a huge search space, along with a non-negligible searching cost. This requires effective multi-objective search algorithms to alleviate the GPU costs. In this work, we implement a novel multi-objectives optimizer based on a recently proposed meta-algorithm called LaMOO on NAS tasks. In a nutshell, LaMOO speedups the search process by learning a model from observed samples to partition the search space and then focusing on promising regions likely to contain a subset of the Pareto frontier. Using LaMOO, we observe an improvement of more than 200% sample efficiency compared to Bayesian optimization and evolutionary-based multi-objective optimizers on different NAS datasets. For example, when combined with LaMOO, qEHVI achieves a 225% improvement in sample efficiency compared to using qEHVI alone in NasBench201. For real-world tasks, LaMOO achieves 97.36% accuracy with only 1.62M #Params on CIFAR10 in only 600 search samples. On ImageNet, our large model reaches 80.4% top-1 accuracy with only 522M #FLOPs.
6/4/2024
Analyzing and Overcoming Local Optima in Complex Multi-Objective Optimization by Decomposition-Based Evolutionary Algorithms
Ting Dong, Haoxin Wang, Hengxi Zhang, Wenbo Ding
0
0
When addressing the challenge of complex multi-objective optimization problems, particularly those with non-convex and non-uniform Pareto fronts, Decomposition-based Multi-Objective Evolutionary Algorithms (MOEADs) often converge to local optima, thereby limiting solution diversity. Despite its significance, this issue has received limited theoretical exploration. Through a comprehensive geometric analysis, we identify that the traditional method of Reference Point (RP) selection fundamentally contributes to this challenge. In response, we introduce an innovative RP selection strategy, the Weight Vector-Guided and Gaussian-Hybrid method, designed to overcome the local optima issue. This approach employs a novel RP type that aligns with weight vector directions and integrates a Gaussian distribution to combine three distinct RP categories. Our research comprises two main experimental components: an ablation study involving 14 algorithms within the MOEADs framework, spanning from 2014 to 2022, to validate our theoretical framework, and a series of empirical tests to evaluate the effectiveness of our proposed method against both traditional and cutting-edge alternatives. Results demonstrate that our method achieves remarkable improvements in both population diversity and convergence.
4/15/2024