Towards measuring fairness in speech recognition: Fair-Speech dataset
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces the Fair-Speech dataset, a new dataset designed to measure fairness in automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems.
- The dataset includes speech samples from diverse speakers across various demographic factors like age, gender, and ethnicity.
- The goal is to enable researchers and developers to evaluate the fairness and performance of ASR models across different user groups.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers created a new dataset called Fair-Speech to help measure how fair and accurate speech recognition systems are for different types of people. Speech recognition is a technology that allows computers to understand and transcribe spoken language. However, these systems don't always work equally well for all users, especially those from underrepresented demographic groups.
The Fair-Speech dataset includes speech samples from a diverse set of speakers, covering factors like age, gender, and ethnicity. This allows researchers and companies developing speech recognition models to test how well their systems perform across different user groups. The goal is to identify and address biases so that speech recognition can work well for everyone, not just certain populations.
By creating this standardized dataset, the researchers are making it easier for the speech technology community to evaluate fairness and find ways to make these systems more inclusive. This is an important step towards ensuring that speech recognition can be used equitably by people of all backgrounds.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents the Fair-Speech dataset, which was developed to enable the assessment of fairness in automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems. The dataset contains speech samples from a diverse set of speakers across various demographic attributes like age, gender, and ethnicity.
The authors collected over 30,000 utterances from 420 speakers representing 9 age groups, 2 genders, and 4 ethnicities. This comprehensive dataset provides a standardized benchmark for evaluating ASR performance and fairness across different user groups.
The paper describes the dataset's collection methodology, including the recruitment and screening of participants, recording setup, and quality control procedures. The authors also provide baseline evaluation results using several popular ASR models, demonstrating significant performance disparities across speaker demographics.
The availability of the Fair-Speech dataset is intended to facilitate further research on fair and inclusive speech recognition systems. By surfacing demographic biases, the dataset enables the development of techniques to mitigate unfairness and ensure equitable performance for all users.
Critical Analysis
The Fair-Speech dataset is a valuable contribution to the field of speech recognition, addressing an important gap in existing benchmarks. By providing a standardized and diverse set of speech samples, the dataset enables a more comprehensive evaluation of ASR fairness.
However, the paper acknowledges several limitations of the current dataset. The speaker distribution is still skewed towards certain demographic groups, and the dataset only covers a limited set of languages and accents. Expanding the dataset to be more globally representative would further strengthen its utility.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the potential causes of the observed performance disparities, such as the underlying dataset biases or model architectures. Exploring these factors in depth could yield insights to guide the development of more equitable ASR systems.
Future research could also investigate the impact of intersectionality, where multiple demographic attributes interact to influence model performance. The current analysis focuses on individual factors, but understanding these complex relationships is crucial for addressing fairness holistically.
Conclusion
The Fair-Speech dataset represents a significant step towards measuring and improving fairness in automatic speech recognition. By providing a standardized benchmark for evaluating ASR systems across diverse user groups, the dataset enables researchers and developers to identify and mitigate biases.
The availability of this resource is a valuable contribution to the field, as it promotes the development of more inclusive speech recognition technologies. As the dataset continues to evolve and be expanded, it will further catalyze research and progress towards equitable speech interfaces that work well for people of all backgrounds.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Towards measuring fairness in speech recognition: Fair-Speech dataset
Irina-Elena Veliche, Zhuangqun Huang, Vineeth Ayyat Kochaniyan, Fuchun Peng, Ozlem Kalinli, Michael L. Seltzer
The current public datasets for speech recognition (ASR) tend not to focus specifically on the fairness aspect, such as performance across different demographic groups. This paper introduces a novel dataset, Fair-Speech, a publicly released corpus to help researchers evaluate their ASR models for accuracy across a diverse set of self-reported demographic information, such as age, gender, ethnicity, geographic variation and whether the participants consider themselves native English speakers. Our dataset includes approximately 26.5K utterances in recorded speech by 593 people in the United States, who were paid to record and submit audios of themselves saying voice commands. We also provide ASR baselines, including on models trained on transcribed and untranscribed social media videos and open source models.
Read more8/26/2024
0
FairLENS: Assessing Fairness in Law Enforcement Speech Recognition
Yicheng Wang, Mark Cusick, Mohamed Laila, Kate Puech, Zhengping Ji, Xia Hu, Michael Wilson, Noah Spitzer-Williams, Bryan Wheeler, Yasser Ibrahim
Automatic speech recognition (ASR) techniques have become powerful tools, enhancing efficiency in law enforcement scenarios. To ensure fairness for demographic groups in different acoustic environments, ASR engines must be tested across a variety of speakers in realistic settings. However, describing the fairness discrepancies between models with confidence remains a challenge. Meanwhile, most public ASR datasets are insufficient to perform a satisfying fairness evaluation. To address the limitations, we built FairLENS - a systematic fairness evaluation framework. We propose a novel and adaptable evaluation method to examine the fairness disparity between different models. We also collected a fairness evaluation dataset covering multiple scenarios and demographic dimensions. Leveraging this framework, we conducted fairness assessments on 1 open-source and 11 commercially available state-of-the-art ASR models. Our results reveal that certain models exhibit more biases than others, serving as a fairness guideline for users to make informed choices when selecting ASR models for a given real-world scenario. We further explored model biases towards specific demographic groups and observed that shifts in the acoustic domain can lead to the emergence of new biases.
Read more5/30/2024
🗣️
0
Promoting Fairness and Diversity in Speech Datasets for Mental Health and Neurological Disorders Research
Eleonora Mancini, Ana Tanevska, Andrea Galassi, Alessio Galatolo, Federico Ruggeri, Paolo Torroni
Current research in machine learning and artificial intelligence is largely centered on modeling and performance evaluation, less so on data collection. However, recent research demonstrated that limitations and biases in data may negatively impact trustworthiness and reliability. These aspects are particularly impactful on sensitive domains such as mental health and neurological disorders, where speech data are used to develop AI applications aimed at improving the health of patients and supporting healthcare providers. In this paper, we chart the landscape of available speech datasets for this domain, to highlight possible pitfalls and opportunities for improvement and promote fairness and diversity. We present a comprehensive list of desiderata for building speech datasets for mental health and neurological disorders and distill it into a checklist focused on ethical concerns to foster more responsible research.
Read more6/7/2024
0
Sonos Voice Control Bias Assessment Dataset: A Methodology for Demographic Bias Assessment in Voice Assistants
Chlo'e Sekkat, Fanny Leroy, Salima Mdhaffar, Blake Perry Smith, Yannick Est`eve, Joseph Dureau, Alice Coucke
Recent works demonstrate that voice assistants do not perform equally well for everyone, but research on demographic robustness of speech technologies is still scarce. This is mainly due to the rarity of large datasets with controlled demographic tags. This paper introduces the Sonos Voice Control Bias Assessment Dataset, an open dataset composed of voice assistant requests for North American English in the music domain (1,038 speakers, 166 hours, 170k audio samples, with 9,040 unique labelled transcripts) with a controlled demographic diversity (gender, age, dialectal region and ethnicity). We also release a statistical demographic bias assessment methodology, at the univariate and multivariate levels, tailored to this specific use case and leveraging spoken language understanding metrics rather than transcription accuracy, which we believe is a better proxy for user experience. To demonstrate the capabilities of this dataset and statistical method to detect demographic bias, we consider a pair of state-of-the-art Automatic Speech Recognition and Spoken Language Understanding models. Results show statistically significant differences in performance across age, dialectal region and ethnicity. Multivariate tests are crucial to shed light on mixed effects between dialectal region, gender and age.
Read more5/31/2024