Towards Principled, Practical Policy Gradient for Bandits and Tabular MDPs
2405.13136
0
0
🏅
Abstract
We consider (stochastic) softmax policy gradient (PG) methods for bandits and tabular Markov decision processes (MDPs). While the PG objective is non-concave, recent research has used the objective's smoothness and gradient domination properties to achieve convergence to an optimal policy. However, these theoretical results require setting the algorithm parameters according to unknown problem-dependent quantities (e.g. the optimal action or the true reward vector in a bandit problem). To address this issue, we borrow ideas from the optimization literature to design practical, principled PG methods in both the exact and stochastic settings. In the exact setting, we employ an Armijo line-search to set the step-size for softmax PG and empirically demonstrate a linear convergence rate. In the stochastic setting, we utilize exponentially decreasing step-sizes, and characterize the convergence rate of the resulting algorithm. We show that the proposed algorithm offers similar theoretical guarantees as the state-of-the art results, but does not require the knowledge of oracle-like quantities. For the multi-armed bandit setting, our techniques result in a theoretically-principled PG algorithm that does not require explicit exploration, the knowledge of the reward gap, the reward distributions, or the noise. Finally, we empirically compare the proposed methods to PG approaches that require oracle knowledge, and demonstrate competitive performance.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper considers policy gradient (PG) methods for solving bandits and tabular Markov decision processes (MDPs)
- PG methods aim to find an optimal policy by directly optimizing the policy parameters using gradient information
- While the PG objective is non-concave, recent research has shown it can be optimized using its smoothness and gradient domination properties
- However, these theoretical results require setting the algorithm parameters based on unknown problem-specific quantities
- This paper proposes practical, principled PG methods that do not require this oracle knowledge
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at a family of algorithms called policy gradient (PG) methods for solving two types of decision-making problems: bandits and tabular Markov decision processes (MDPs).
PG methods work by directly optimizing the parameters of the decision-making policy, using the gradients of the policy's performance. While the objective function for this optimization is not concave, recent research has shown it can still be optimized effectively using its smoothness and gradient domination properties.
The challenge is that the theoretical results for PG methods require knowing certain problem-specific quantities, like the optimal action or the true reward vector in a bandit problem. This paper proposes new PG methods that do not require this kind of "oracle" knowledge, making them more practical to use in real-world applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper considers softmax PG methods for bandits and tabular MDPs. While the PG objective is non-concave, the authors leverage the objective's smoothness and gradient domination properties to provably converge to an optimal policy.
However, the theoretical results in prior work require setting the algorithm parameters based on unknown problem-dependent quantities, like the optimal action or true reward vector in a bandit. To address this, the authors borrow ideas from optimization literature to design practical, principled PG methods that do not require this oracle knowledge.
In the exact setting, the authors employ an Armijo line-search to set the step-size for softmax PG, and empirically demonstrate a linear convergence rate. In the stochastic setting, they utilize exponentially decreasing step-sizes, and characterize the convergence rate of the resulting algorithm.
The authors show that their proposed algorithms offer similar theoretical guarantees as prior state-of-the-art results, but without needing to know the oracle-like quantities. For the multi-armed bandit setting specifically, their techniques result in a PG algorithm that does not require explicit exploration, knowledge of the reward gap, reward distributions, or noise levels.
Finally, the authors empirically compare their methods to PG approaches that do require oracle knowledge, and demonstrate competitive performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents an interesting and principled approach to designing PG methods that do not rely on problem-specific knowledge. This is an important contribution, as the need for such oracle information has been a significant limitation in applying PG methods to real-world problems.
That said, the paper does not address potential challenges that may arise in practice, such as the sensitivity of the Armijo line-search to hyperparameters, or the difficulty of setting appropriate decreasing step-sizes in the stochastic setting. Additionally, the theoretical analysis focuses on tabular MDPs, which may limit the scalability of the proposed methods.
Further research could explore extensions to function approximation settings, as well as more robust step-size adaptation techniques that do not require detailed tuning. It would also be valuable to see a more thorough empirical evaluation, including comparisons to other state-of-the-art PG methods beyond just those requiring oracle knowledge.
Conclusion
This paper presents practical, principled PG algorithms for bandits and tabular MDPs that do not require knowing problem-specific quantities, unlike prior theoretical results. By borrowing ideas from optimization literature, the authors develop both exact and stochastic PG methods with strong theoretical guarantees.
While there are some potential limitations to address, this work represents an important step towards making PG methods more usable in real-world applications, where the necessary oracle information is often unavailable. The techniques proposed in this paper could help expand the reach and applicability of PG-based reinforcement learning approaches.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🧪
Learning Optimal Deterministic Policies with Stochastic Policy Gradients
Alessandro Montenegro, Marco Mussi, Alberto Maria Metelli, Matteo Papini
0
0
Policy gradient (PG) methods are successful approaches to deal with continuous reinforcement learning (RL) problems. They learn stochastic parametric (hyper)policies by either exploring in the space of actions or in the space of parameters. Stochastic controllers, however, are often undesirable from a practical perspective because of their lack of robustness, safety, and traceability. In common practice, stochastic (hyper)policies are learned only to deploy their deterministic version. In this paper, we make a step towards the theoretical understanding of this practice. After introducing a novel framework for modeling this scenario, we study the global convergence to the best deterministic policy, under (weak) gradient domination assumptions. Then, we illustrate how to tune the exploration level used for learning to optimize the trade-off between the sample complexity and the performance of the deployed deterministic policy. Finally, we quantitatively compare action-based and parameter-based exploration, giving a formal guise to intuitive results.
5/31/2024
🖼️
Elementary Analysis of Policy Gradient Methods
Jiacai Liu, Wenye Li, Ke Wei
0
0
Projected policy gradient under the simplex parameterization, policy gradient and natural policy gradient under the softmax parameterization, are fundamental algorithms in reinforcement learning. There have been a flurry of recent activities in studying these algorithms from the theoretical aspect. Despite this, their convergence behavior is still not fully understood, even given the access to exact policy evaluations. In this paper, we focus on the discounted MDP setting and conduct a systematic study of the aforementioned policy optimization methods. Several novel results are presented, including 1) global linear convergence of projected policy gradient for any constant step size, 2) sublinear convergence of softmax policy gradient for any constant step size, 3) global linear convergence of softmax natural policy gradient for any constant step size, 4) global linear convergence of entropy regularized softmax policy gradient for a wider range of constant step sizes than existing result, 5) tight local linear convergence rate of entropy regularized natural policy gradient, and 6) a new and concise local quadratic convergence rate of soft policy iteration without the assumption on the stationary distribution under the optimal policy. New and elementary analysis techniques have been developed to establish these results.
4/12/2024
➖
Beyond Stationarity: Convergence Analysis of Stochastic Softmax Policy Gradient Methods
Sara Klein, Simon Weissmann, Leif Doring
0
0
Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) are a formal framework for modeling and solving sequential decision-making problems. In finite-time horizons such problems are relevant for instance for optimal stopping or specific supply chain problems, but also in the training of large language models. In contrast to infinite horizon MDPs optimal policies are not stationary, policies must be learned for every single epoch. In practice all parameters are often trained simultaneously, ignoring the inherent structure suggested by dynamic programming. This paper introduces a combination of dynamic programming and policy gradient called dynamic policy gradient, where the parameters are trained backwards in time. For the tabular softmax parametrisation we carry out the convergence analysis for simultaneous and dynamic policy gradient towards global optima, both in the exact and sampled gradient settings without regularisation. It turns out that the use of dynamic policy gradient training much better exploits the structure of finite- time problems which is reflected in improved convergence bounds.
5/7/2024
🔍
New!A Policy Gradient Primal-Dual Algorithm for Constrained MDPs with Uniform PAC Guarantees
Toshinori Kitamura, Tadashi Kozuno, Masahiro Kato, Yuki Ichihara, Soichiro Nishimori, Akiyoshi Sannai, Sho Sonoda, Wataru Kumagai, Yutaka Matsuo
0
0
We study a primal-dual (PD) reinforcement learning (RL) algorithm for online constrained Markov decision processes (CMDPs). Despite its widespread practical use, the existing theoretical literature on PD-RL algorithms for this problem only provides sublinear regret guarantees and fails to ensure convergence to optimal policies. In this paper, we introduce a novel policy gradient PD algorithm with uniform probably approximate correctness (Uniform-PAC) guarantees, simultaneously ensuring convergence to optimal policies, sublinear regret, and polynomial sample complexity for any target accuracy. Notably, this represents the first Uniform-PAC algorithm for the online CMDP problem. In addition to the theoretical guarantees, we empirically demonstrate in a simple CMDP that our algorithm converges to optimal policies, while baseline algorithms exhibit oscillatory performance and constraint violation.
7/2/2024