Learning Optimal Deterministic Policies with Stochastic Policy Gradients

Overview

• Policy gradient (PG) methods are successful for continuous reinforcement learning (RL) problems.
• They learn stochastic parametric (hyper)policies by exploring in the action or parameter space.
• Stochastic controllers can be impractical due to lack of robustness, safety, and traceability.
• In practice, stochastic (hyper)policies are often learned to deploy their deterministic versions.

Plain English Explanation

Policy gradient (PG) methods are a successful approach to solving continuous reinforcement learning (RL) problems. These methods learn stochastic, or random, policies by exploring either the space of possible actions or the space of policy parameters. This means the agent doesn't always take the same actions, but instead selects actions based on a probability distribution.

While stochastic policies can be effective during the learning process, they can be problematic in practical applications. Stochastic controllers tend to lack robustness, safety, and the ability to trace or understand their decision-making. As a result, in real-world use cases, the stochastic policies learned during training are often converted to deterministic versions that always take the same actions.

This paper aims to provide a theoretical understanding of this common practice of converting stochastic policies to deterministic ones. The researchers introduce a framework for modeling this scenario and study when the learned deterministic policy will converge to the best possible deterministic policy. They also explore how to balance the exploration level used during training to optimize the tradeoff between sample complexity (how much data is needed) and the performance of the final deterministic policy.

Additionally, the paper compares two different exploration approaches - exploring in the action space versus exploring in the parameter space of the policy. This provides a formal analysis of some intuitive results about the differences between these two exploration methods.

Technical Explanation

This paper introduces a novel framework for modeling the scenario where stochastic parametric (hyper)policies are learned, but only their deterministic versions are deployed in practice. Under gradient domination assumptions, the researchers study the global convergence to the best deterministic policy.

The paper then illustrates how to tune the exploration level used for learning in order to optimize the tradeoff between sample complexity and the performance of the deployed deterministic policy. This builds on prior work in extremum seeking and stochastic online optimization.

Finally, the authors provide a formal comparison of action-based and parameter-based exploration, giving a rigorous treatment to some intuitive results about the differences between these two exploration approaches used in trajectory-oriented policy optimization for sparse reward settings.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a valuable contribution by providing a theoretical framework for understanding the common practice of learning stochastic policies but deploying deterministic ones. The analysis of the convergence properties and the exploration-exploitation tradeoff offers useful insights.

However, the paper does rely on some strong assumptions, such as gradient domination, which may not hold in all practical scenarios. Additionally, the formal comparison of action-based and parameter-based exploration, while interesting, may have limited real-world applicability, as the choice of exploration method often depends heavily on the specific problem and domain.

Further research could explore relaxing some of the assumptions, considering alternative exploration strategies, or investigating the implications of this framework in various RL application domains. It would also be helpful to see empirical validation of the theoretical results presented here.

Conclusion

This paper takes an important step towards a deeper theoretical understanding of a common practice in reinforcement learning - learning stochastic policies but deploying deterministic ones. By introducing a novel framework, analyzing convergence properties, and comparing exploration approaches, the authors provide useful insights that can inform the design of more robust and effective RL systems. While the results rely on some strong assumptions, this work lays the groundwork for further advancements in this area of research.