Towards Realistic Long-tailed Semi-supervised Learning in an Open World

Overview

• The paper introduces a new setting called Realistic Open-world Long-tailed Semi-supervised Learning (ROLSSL), which is more realistic than existing open-world long-tailed semi-supervised learning approaches.
• ROLSSL removes the assumption that the distribution of known and novel categories is nearly identical, and also considers the case where the number of labeled samples is much smaller than the number of unlabeled samples.
• The paper proposes a simple yet effective solution called dual-stage post-hoc logit adjustments to address the challenges in the ROLSSL setting.

Plain English Explanation

In machine learning, there is a growing interest in open-world long-tailed semi-supervised learning, where models need to learn from a large amount of unlabeled data, including both known and novel categories. However, existing approaches often assume that the distribution of known and novel categories is similar, which may not always be the case in the real world.

The paper introduces a more realistic open-world long-tailed semi-supervised learning (ROLSSL) setting, where there is no such assumption. Moreover, the researchers also consider the scenario where the number of labeled samples is significantly smaller than the number of unlabeled samples, as obtaining accurate annotations can be expensive in practice.

To address the challenges in the ROLSSL setting, the researchers propose a dual-stage post-hoc logit adjustments approach. This method revisits the logit adjustment strategy, which adjusts the model's output probabilities based on factors like the frequency of samples and the total number of categories. The proposed approach estimates the distribution of unlabeled data for both known and novel categories, and then dynamically readjusts the predictive probabilities to mitigate category bias during the learning of known and novel classes.

The researchers conducted extensive experiments on datasets like CIFAR100 and ImageNet100, and their proposed method demonstrated performance improvements of up to 50.1%, establishing a strong baseline for this task.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a new setting called Realistic Open-world Long-tailed Semi-supervised Learning (ROLSSL), which relaxes the assumption made by existing open-world long-tailed semi-supervised learning algorithms that the distributions between known and novel categories are nearly identical.

In the proposed ROLSSL setting, there is no premise on the distribution relationships between known and novel categories. Additionally, the number of labeled samples is significantly smaller than the number of unlabeled samples, as obtaining valid annotations can be prohibitively costly in the real world.

To address the challenges in the ROLSSL setting, the researchers propose a dual-stage post-hoc logit adjustments approach. The first stage revisits the logit adjustment strategy by considering the relationships among the frequency of samples, the total number of categories, and the overall size of data. The second stage estimates the distribution of unlabeled data for both known and novel categories to dynamically readjust the corresponding predictive probabilities, effectively mitigating category bias during the learning of known and novel classes with more selective utilization of imbalanced unlabeled data.

The researchers conducted extensive experiments on datasets such as CIFAR100 and ImageNet100, and their proposed method demonstrated performance improvements of up to 50.1%, validating the superiority of the approach and establishing a strong baseline for this task.

Critical Analysis

The paper addresses an important and realistic problem in machine learning, namely the open-world long-tailed semi-supervised learning setting, where the distribution of known and novel categories may differ, and the number of labeled samples is much smaller than the number of unlabeled samples.

The proposed ROLSSL setting and the dual-stage post-hoc logit adjustments approach are promising solutions to this problem. The authors have provided a thorough evaluation of their method on standard datasets, demonstrating significant performance improvements.

However, the paper could have benefited from a more detailed discussion of the limitations and potential issues with the proposed approach. For example, the researchers could have explored the sensitivity of the method to the quality of the unlabeled data distribution estimation, or the impact of the chosen hyperparameters on the final performance.

Additionally, the researchers could have compared their approach to other relevant semi-supervised learning techniques, such as self-supervised learning or reinforcement learning-guided semi-supervised learning, to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of their proposed solution.

Conclusion

The paper introduces a Realistic Open-world Long-tailed Semi-supervised Learning (ROLSSL) setting, which is more aligned with real-world scenarios than existing open-world long-tailed semi-supervised learning approaches. The researchers propose a dual-stage post-hoc logit adjustments method to address the challenges in the ROLSSL setting, and their experiments demonstrate significant performance improvements.

The work establishes a strong baseline for this task and highlights the importance of considering realistic assumptions in the design of machine learning systems. The proposed solution could have important implications for a wide range of real-world applications, such as adapting multi-modal large language models or prompt-based pseudo-labeling strategies, where the distribution of known and novel categories may be highly skewed, and the availability of labeled data is limited.