Towards Robust Model-Based Reinforcement Learning Against Adversarial Corruption

Read original: arXiv:2402.08991 - Published 7/23/2024 by Chenlu Ye, Jiafan He, Quanquan Gu, Tong Zhang

🏅

Overview

This study focuses on addressing the challenges of adversarial corruption in model-based reinforcement learning (RL)
Existing work on corruption-robust RL mainly focuses on model-free RL, using robust least-square regression for value function estimation
This paper targets the model-based RL setting, using maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) to learn the transition model
The work covers both online and offline settings, with algorithms that provide regret guarantees against adversarial corruption

Plain English Explanation

In model-based reinforcement learning, an agent learns a model of the environment's dynamics, which it then uses to plan and make decisions. However, this model can be corrupted by an adversary, causing the agent to make poor choices.

Previous research on corruption-robust RL has focused on the model-free setting, where the agent learns a value function directly from data, using robust regression techniques. But these methods don't directly apply to the model-based case.

This paper proposes new algorithms for learning transition models in a way that is robust to adversarial corruption. In the online setting, the "corruption-robust optimistic MLE" (CR-OMLE) algorithm uses total variation-based weights to account for uncertainty in the model. It is shown to achieve near-optimal regret, with an additive term that scales with the total corruption level.

For the offline setting, the authors introduce "corruption-robust pessimistic MLE" (CR-PMLE), which also uses a weighting scheme to handle corruption. Under a uniform coverage condition, CR-PMLE is shown to have suboptimality that scales linearly with the corruption level.

These are the first model-based RL algorithms with provable guarantees against adversarial corruption, which is an important step towards building reliable RL systems.

Technical Explanation

The core technical contribution of this paper is the development of two algorithms for learning transition models in model-based RL that are robust to adversarial corruption:

Corruption-Robust Optimistic MLE (CR-OMLE): This algorithm is designed for the online setting, where the agent interacts with the environment sequentially. CR-OMLE uses total variation (TV)-based information ratios as uncertainty weights in the maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) of the transition model. The authors prove that CR-OMLE achieves a regret bound of $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}(\sqrt{T} + C)$, where $T$ is the number of episodes and $C$ is the cumulative corruption level. They also establish a lower bound to show this additive dependence on $C$ is optimal.
Corruption-Robust Pessimistic MLE (CR-PMLE): This algorithm is designed for the offline setting, where the agent learns from a fixed dataset. CR-PMLE also employs a weighting scheme in the MLE, but in a "pessimistic" manner. Under a uniform coverage condition, the authors show that CR-PMLE's suboptimality scales as $\mathcal{O}(C/n)$, where $n$ is the dataset size, nearly matching the lower bound.

The key technical insights are:

Leveraging TV-based information ratios to quantify uncertainty in the online setting
Developing a pessimistic weighting scheme for the offline setting to handle corruption

To the best of the authors' knowledge, this is the first work on corruption-robust model-based RL algorithms with provable guarantees.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a strong theoretical foundation for corruption-robust model-based RL, addressing an important practical challenge. The regret and suboptimality bounds derived for the proposed algorithms are near-optimal, highlighting the effectiveness of the approaches.

However, the paper does not discuss the practical implementation of these algorithms or their empirical performance. It would be valuable to see how well they perform on real-world tasks compared to existing methods. Additionally, the uniform coverage condition required for the offline setting may be restrictive in practice, and further research could explore relaxing this assumption.

Another potential limitation is the focus on additive corruption, which may not capture all real-world adversarial scenarios. Future work could consider other corruption models, such as adaptive or targeted corruption, to further strengthen the robustness of the methods.

Overall, this paper makes a significant contribution to the field of robust RL, paving the way for more reliable and trustworthy model-based reinforcement learning systems. Researchers and practitioners in the field should carefully consider the implications of this work and build upon it to address the remaining challenges.

Conclusion

This study presents the first model-based reinforcement learning algorithms with provable guarantees against adversarial corruption. The proposed approaches, CR-OMLE and CR-PMLE, leverage novel weighting schemes to learn transition models that are robust to corruption, in both online and offline settings.

The theoretical analysis demonstrates the near-optimality of these algorithms, making an important step towards building reliable RL systems that can operate in adversarial environments. While further empirical validation and extensions to more complex corruption models are needed, this work lays a solid foundation for the critical problem of corruption-robust model-based reinforcement learning.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🏅

Towards Robust Model-Based Reinforcement Learning Against Adversarial Corruption

Chenlu Ye, Jiafan He, Quanquan Gu, Tong Zhang

This study tackles the challenges of adversarial corruption in model-based reinforcement learning (RL), where the transition dynamics can be corrupted by an adversary. Existing studies on corruption-robust RL mostly focus on the setting of model-free RL, where robust least-square regression is often employed for value function estimation. However, these techniques cannot be directly applied to model-based RL. In this paper, we focus on model-based RL and take the maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) approach to learn transition model. Our work encompasses both online and offline settings. In the online setting, we introduce an algorithm called corruption-robust optimistic MLE (CR-OMLE), which leverages total-variation (TV)-based information ratios as uncertainty weights for MLE. We prove that CR-OMLE achieves a regret of $tilde{mathcal{O}}(sqrt{T} + C)$, where $C$ denotes the cumulative corruption level after $T$ episodes. We also prove a lower bound to show that the additive dependence on $C$ is optimal. We extend our weighting technique to the offline setting, and propose an algorithm named corruption-robust pessimistic MLE (CR-PMLE). Under a uniform coverage condition, CR-PMLE exhibits suboptimality worsened by $mathcal{O}(C/n)$, nearly matching the lower bound. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work on corruption-robust model-based RL algorithms with provable guarantees.

7/23/2024

Robust Model-Based Reinforcement Learning with an Adversarial Auxiliary Model

Siemen Herremans, Ali Anwar, Siegfried Mercelis

Reinforcement learning has demonstrated impressive performance in various challenging problems such as robotics, board games, and classical arcade games. However, its real-world applications can be hindered by the absence of robustness and safety in the learned policies. More specifically, an RL agent that trains in a certain Markov decision process (MDP) often struggles to perform well in nearly identical MDPs. To address this issue, we employ the framework of Robust MDPs (RMDPs) in a model-based setting and introduce a novel learned transition model. Our method specifically incorporates an auxiliary pessimistic model, updated adversarially, to estimate the worst-case MDP within a Kullback-Leibler uncertainty set. In comparison to several existing works, our work does not impose any additional conditions on the training environment, such as the need for a parametric simulator. To test the effectiveness of the proposed pessimistic model in enhancing policy robustness, we integrate it into a practical RL algorithm, called Robust Model-Based Policy Optimization (RMBPO). Our experimental results indicate a notable improvement in policy robustness on high-dimensional MuJoCo control tasks, with the auxiliary model enhancing the performance of the learned policy in distorted MDPs. We further explore the learned deviation between the proposed auxiliary world model and the nominal model, to examine how pessimism is achieved. By learning a pessimistic world model and demonstrating its role in improving policy robustness, our research contributes towards making (model-based) RL more robust.

7/2/2024

🎯

Robust Q-Learning under Corrupted Rewards

Sreejeet Maity, Aritra Mitra

Recently, there has been a surge of interest in analyzing the non-asymptotic behavior of model-free reinforcement learning algorithms. However, the performance of such algorithms in non-ideal environments, such as in the presence of corrupted rewards, is poorly understood. Motivated by this gap, we investigate the robustness of the celebrated Q-learning algorithm to a strong-contamination attack model, where an adversary can arbitrarily perturb a small fraction of the observed rewards. We start by proving that such an attack can cause the vanilla Q-learning algorithm to incur arbitrarily large errors. We then develop a novel robust synchronous Q-learning algorithm that uses historical reward data to construct robust empirical Bellman operators at each time step. Finally, we prove a finite-time convergence rate for our algorithm that matches known state-of-the-art bounds (in the absence of attacks) up to a small inevitable $O(varepsilon)$ error term that scales with the adversarial corruption fraction $varepsilon$. Notably, our results continue to hold even when the true reward distributions have infinite support, provided they admit bounded second moments.

9/6/2024

Robust Decision Transformer: Tackling Data Corruption in Offline RL via Sequence Modeling

Jiawei Xu, Rui Yang, Feng Luo, Meng Fang, Baoxiang Wang, Lei Han

Learning policies from offline datasets through offline reinforcement learning (RL) holds promise for scaling data-driven decision-making and avoiding unsafe and costly online interactions. However, real-world data collected from sensors or humans often contains noise and errors, posing a significant challenge for existing offline RL methods. Our study indicates that traditional offline RL methods based on temporal difference learning tend to underperform Decision Transformer (DT) under data corruption, especially when the amount of data is limited. This suggests the potential of sequential modeling for tackling data corruption in offline RL. To further unleash the potential of sequence modeling methods, we propose Robust Decision Transformer (RDT) by incorporating several robust techniques. Specifically, we introduce Gaussian weighted learning and iterative data correction to reduce the effect of corrupted data. Additionally, we leverage embedding dropout to enhance the model's resistance to erroneous inputs. Extensive experiments on MoJoCo, KitChen, and Adroit tasks demonstrate RDT's superior performance under diverse data corruption compared to previous methods. Moreover, RDT exhibits remarkable robustness in a challenging setting that combines training-time data corruption with testing-time observation perturbations. These results highlight the potential of robust sequence modeling for learning from noisy or corrupted offline datasets, thereby promoting the reliable application of offline RL in real-world tasks.

7/8/2024