Towards a unifying framework for data-driven predictive control with quadratic regularization
2404.02721
0
0
🎲
Abstract
Data-driven predictive control (DPC) has recently gained popularity as an alternative to model predictive control (MPC). Amidst the surge in proposed DPC frameworks, upon closer inspection, many of these frameworks are more closely related (or perhaps even equivalent) to each other than it may first appear. We argue for a more formal characterization of these relationships so that results can be freely transferred from one framework to another, rather than being uniquely attributed to a particular framework. We demonstrate this idea by examining the connection between $gamma$-DDPC and the original DeePC formulation.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a unifying framework for data-driven predictive control (DPC) with quadratic regularization.
- It aims to reconcile different DPC approaches and provide a common theoretical foundation.
- The framework incorporates various regularization techniques to address practical challenges in DPC.
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a way to unify different approaches to data-driven predictive control (DPC), a technique used to control complex systems like factories or transportation networks. DPC uses observed data about a system's behavior to make predictions and decide on the best actions to take, without relying on a detailed mathematical model of the system.
The authors argue that existing DPC methods have some limitations, such as being sensitive to noise in the data or not accounting for uncertainty in the system's behavior. Their new framework offers a more comprehensive way to address these challenges by incorporating different types of regularization, which helps the DPC algorithm find the best control strategy without overfitting to the training data.
The framework is designed to be flexible, allowing researchers and engineers to combine various regularization techniques depending on the specific requirements of the system they are trying to control. This could lead to more reliable and robust DPC systems that can be applied to a wider range of real-world problems.
Technical Explanation
The paper first provides an overview of the fundamentals of DPC, including the key assumptions and mathematical formulations underlying the DeePC algorithm, a prominent DPC method. It then introduces a unifying DPC framework that generalizes DeePC by incorporating different types of quadratic regularization.
The framework casts DPC as an optimization problem, where the goal is to find the best control inputs that minimize a cost function. This cost function includes terms for tracking a desired output trajectory, as well as regularization terms that penalize undesirable properties of the control inputs, such as large magnitudes or rapid changes.
The authors explore several regularization approaches, including ridge regression, total variation, and nuclear norm regularization. These techniques help the DPC algorithm find control strategies that are more robust to noise, changes in the system dynamics, and other practical challenges.
The paper also discusses how the framework can be extended to handle constraints on the control inputs and states, as well as to incorporate dual decomposition methods for distributed optimization.
Critical Analysis
The proposed framework represents a meaningful step towards a more unified understanding of DPC methods. By offering a common theoretical foundation, it could help researchers and practitioners better compare and combine different DPC approaches to suit their specific needs.
However, the paper does not provide a comprehensive empirical evaluation of the framework's performance across a wide range of benchmark problems or real-world applications. While the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on a few illustrative examples, more extensive testing would be needed to fully assess the framework's practical utility and its advantages over existing DPC methods.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the computational complexity and scalability of the proposed optimization problem, which could be an important consideration for deploying DPC in large-scale or time-critical applications. Further analysis of the trade-offs between different regularization techniques and their impact on computational efficiency would be valuable.
Conclusion
The unifying DPC framework presented in this paper offers a promising approach to addressing some of the key practical challenges in data-driven predictive control. By providing a flexible and theoretically grounded way to incorporate various regularization techniques, the framework could pave the way for more robust and reliable DPC systems that can be tailored to a wide range of real-world control problems. While further empirical validation and analysis would be beneficial, this work represents an important contribution to the ongoing efforts to bridge the gap between theory and practice in the field of data-driven control.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🐍
Extending direct data-driven predictive control towards systems with finite control sets
Manuel Kladtke, Moritz Schulze Darup, Daniel E. Quevedo
0
0
Although classical model predictive control with finite control sets (FCS-MPC) is quite a popular control method, particularly in the realm of power electronics systems, its direct data-driven predictive control (FCS-DPC) counterpart has received relatively limited attention. In this paper, we introduce a novel reformulation of a commonly used DPC scheme that allows for the application of a modified sphere decoding algorithm, known for its efficiency and prominence in FCS-MPC applications. We test the reformulation on a popular electrical drive example and compare the computation times of sphere decoding FCS-DPC with an enumeration-based and a MIQP method.
4/4/2024
Model Predictive Control and Reinforcement Learning: A Unified Framework Based on Dynamic Programming
Dimitri P. Bertsekas
0
0
In this paper we describe a new conceptual framework that connects approximate Dynamic Programming (DP), Model Predictive Control (MPC), and Reinforcement Learning (RL). This framework centers around two algorithms, which are designed largely independently of each other and operate in synergy through the powerful mechanism of Newton's method. We call them the off-line training and the on-line play algorithms. The names are borrowed from some of the major successes of RL involving games; primary examples are the recent (2017) AlphaZero program (which plays chess, [SHS17], [SSS17]), and the similarly structured and earlier (1990s) TD-Gammon program (which plays backgammon, [Tes94], [Tes95], [TeG96]). In these game contexts, the off-line training algorithm is the method used to teach the program how to evaluate positions and to generate good moves at any given position, while the on-line play algorithm is the method used to play in real time against human or computer opponents. Significantly, the synergy between off-line training and on-line play also underlies MPC (as well as other major classes of sequential decision problems), and indeed the MPC design architecture is very similar to the one of AlphaZero and TD-Gammon. This conceptual insight provides a vehicle for bridging the cultural gap between RL and MPC, and sheds new light on some fundamental issues in MPC. These include the enhancement of stability properties through rollout, the treatment of uncertainty through the use of certainty equivalence, the resilience of MPC in adaptive control settings that involve changing system parameters, and the insights provided by the superlinear performance bounds implied by Newton's method.
6/12/2024
Differentiable Predictive Control for Large-Scale Urban Road Networks
Renukanandan Tumu, Wenceslao Shaw Cortez, J'an Drgov{n}a, Draguna L. Vrabie, Sonja Glavaski
0
0
Transportation is a major contributor to CO2 emissions, making it essential to optimize traffic networks to reduce energy-related emissions. This paper presents a novel approach to traffic network control using Differentiable Predictive Control (DPC), a physics-informed machine learning methodology. We base our model on the Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram (MFD) and the Networked Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram (NMFD), offering a simplified representation of citywide traffic networks. Our approach ensures compliance with system constraints by construction. In empirical comparisons with existing state-of-the-art Model Predictive Control (MPC) methods, our approach demonstrates a 4 order of magnitude reduction in computation time and an up to 37% improvement in traffic performance. Furthermore, we assess the robustness of our controller to scenario shifts and find that it adapts well to changes in traffic patterns. This work proposes more efficient traffic control methods, particularly in large-scale urban networks, and aims to mitigate emissions and alleviate congestion in the future.
6/18/2024
🏅
MPC-Inspired Reinforcement Learning for Verifiable Model-Free Control
Yiwen Lu, Zishuo Li, Yihan Zhou, Na Li, Yilin Mo
0
0
In this paper, we introduce a new class of parameterized controllers, drawing inspiration from Model Predictive Control (MPC). The controller resembles a Quadratic Programming (QP) solver of a linear MPC problem, with the parameters of the controller being trained via Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) rather than derived from system models. This approach addresses the limitations of common controllers with Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) or other general neural network architecture used in DRL, in terms of verifiability and performance guarantees, and the learned controllers possess verifiable properties like persistent feasibility and asymptotic stability akin to MPC. On the other hand, numerical examples illustrate that the proposed controller empirically matches MPC and MLP controllers in terms of control performance and has superior robustness against modeling uncertainty and noises. Furthermore, the proposed controller is significantly more computationally efficient compared to MPC and requires fewer parameters to learn than MLP controllers. Real-world experiments on vehicle drift maneuvering task demonstrate the potential of these controllers for robotics and other demanding control tasks.
4/10/2024