Towards Video Codec Performance Evaluation: A Rate-Energy-Distortion Perspective
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores a new approach to evaluating video codec performance from a rate-energy-distortion perspective.
- It examines the relationship between the bitrate, energy consumption, and video quality for different video codecs.
- The goal is to provide a comprehensive framework for assessing video codec efficiency beyond just rate-distortion metrics.
Plain English Explanation
Video codecs are software algorithms that compress and decompress digital video files to enable efficient storage and transmission. Traditionally, the performance of video codecs has been evaluated primarily based on rate-distortion models, which focus on the trade-off between the bitrate (file size) and video quality (distortion).
However, the authors of this paper argue that this approach is incomplete, as it fails to consider the energy consumption of the codec, which is becoming increasingly important in battery-powered devices and environmentally-conscious applications. They propose a new framework that incorporates the rate-energy-distortion perspective, allowing for a more comprehensive evaluation of video codec performance.
By considering the energy efficiency of different codecs in addition to the traditional rate-distortion metrics, the researchers aim to provide a more holistic understanding of the trade-offs involved in video codec selection and optimization. This could lead to the development of more energy-efficient video compression algorithms and inform the design of future video-enabled devices and applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper describes an experimental setup where the researchers measured the bitrate, energy consumption, and video quality (distortion) for several popular video codecs, including AVC, HEVC, and VVC, across a range of encoding settings.
They used a custom hardware platform to accurately measure the energy consumption of the codecs during the encoding process. Video quality was assessed using standard objective metrics, such as PSNR and VMAF.
The results are presented in the form of rate-energy-distortion curves, which illustrate the complex relationships between these three key performance indicators. The authors also discuss how these curves can be used to optimize video codec selection and configuration for different application scenarios, such as real-time XR video or adversarial-robust image compression.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and comprehensive approach to evaluating video codec performance, which is a valuable contribution to the field. However, the authors acknowledge several limitations of their work, such as the use of a single hardware platform and the reliance on objective quality metrics, which may not fully capture the subjective experience of video consumption.
Additionally, the study focuses on a relatively narrow set of codecs and encoding settings, and it remains to be seen how the rate-energy-distortion framework can be applied to a wider range of video compression technologies and use cases.
Further research is needed to validate the findings, explore the generalizability of the approach, and investigate the potential trade-offs and optimizations that can be achieved by considering energy consumption in video codec design and deployment.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to evaluating video codec performance that goes beyond the traditional rate-distortion perspective by incorporating energy consumption as a key metric. The researchers have demonstrated the feasibility of this rate-energy-distortion framework and provided insights into the trade-offs involved in video codec selection and configuration.
The findings of this study have the potential to inform the development of more energy-efficient video compression algorithms and the design of future video-enabled devices and applications, particularly in the context of battery-powered and environmentally-conscious systems. As the demand for high-quality video content continues to grow, the consideration of energy efficiency will become increasingly important, and the approach outlined in this paper offers a valuable tool for addressing this challenge.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Towards Video Codec Performance Evaluation: A Rate-Energy-Distortion Perspective
Geetha Ramasubbu, Andr'e Kaup, Christian Herglotz
The Bj{o}ntegaard Delta rate (BD-rate) objectively assesses the coding efficiency of video codecs using the rate-distortion (R-D) performance but overlooks encoding energy, which is crucial in practical applications, especially for those on handheld devices. Although R-D analysis can be extended to incorporate encoding energy as energy-distortion (E-D), it fails to integrate all three parameters seamlessly. This work proposes a novel approach to address this limitation by introducing a 3D representation of rate, encoding energy, and distortion through surface fitting. In addition, we evaluate various surface fitting techniques based on their accuracy and investigate the proposed 3D representation and its projections. The overlapping areas in projections help in encoder selection and recommend avoiding the slow presets of the older encoders (x264, x265), as the recent encoders (x265, VVenC) offer higher quality for the same bitrate-energy performance and provide a lower rate for the same energy-distortion performance.
Read more8/20/2024
0
New!On the Computation of BD-Rate over a Set of Videos for Fair Assessment of Performance of Learned Video Codecs
M. Akin Yilmaz, Onur Kelec{s}, A. Murat Tekalp
The Bj{o}ntegaard Delta (BD) measure is widely employed to evaluate and quantify the variations in the rate-distortion(RD) performance across different codecs. Many researchers report the average BD value over multiple videos within a dataset for different codecs. We claim that the current practice in the learned video compression community of computing the average BD value over a dataset based on the average RD curve of multiple videos can lead to misleading conclusions. We show both by analysis of a simplistic case of linear RD curves and experimental results with two recent learned video codecs that averaging RD curves can lead to a single video to disproportionately influence the average BD value especially when the operating bitrate range of different codecs do not exactly match. Instead, we advocate for calculating the BD measure per-video basis, as commonly done by the traditional video compression community, followed by averaging the individual BD values over videos, to provide a fair comparison of learned video codecs. Our experimental results demonstrate that the comparison of two recent learned video codecs is affected by how we evaluate the average BD measure.
Read more9/16/2024
📈
0
A Parametric Rate-Distortion Model for Video Transcoding
Maedeh Jamali, Nader Karimi, Shadrokh Samavi, Shahram Shirani
Over the past two decades, the surge in video streaming applications has been fueled by the increasing accessibility of the internet and the growing demand for network video. As users with varying internet speeds and devices seek high-quality video, transcoding becomes essential for service providers. In this paper, we introduce a parametric rate-distortion (R-D) transcoding model. Our model excels at predicting transcoding distortion at various rates without the need for encoding the video. This model serves as a versatile tool that can be used to achieve visual quality improvement (in terms of PSNR) via trans-sizing. Moreover, we use our model to identify visually lossless and near-zero-slope bitrate ranges for an ingest video. Having this information allows us to adjust the transcoding target bitrate while introducing visually negligible quality degradations. By utilizing our model in this manner, quality improvements up to 2 dB and bitrate savings of up to 46% of the original target bitrate are possible. Experimental results demonstrate the efficacy of our model in video transcoding rate distortion prediction.
Read more4/16/2024
0
Feature-Preserving Rate-Distortion Optimization in Image Coding for Machines
Samuel Fern'andez Mendui~na, Eduardo Pavez, Antonio Ortega
With the increasing number of images and videos consumed by computer vision algorithms, compression methods are evolving to consider both perceptual quality and performance in downstream tasks. Traditional codecs can tackle this problem by performing rate-distortion optimization (RDO) to minimize the distance at the output of a feature extractor. However, neural network non-linearities can make the rate-distortion landscape irregular, leading to reconstructions with poor visual quality even for high bit rates. Moreover, RDO decisions are made block-wise, while the feature extractor requires the whole image to exploit global information. In this paper, we address these limitations in three steps. First, we apply Taylor's expansion to the feature extractor, recasting the metric as an input-dependent squared error involving the Jacobian matrix of the neural network. Second, we make a localization assumption to compute the metric block-wise. Finally, we use randomized dimensionality reduction techniques to approximate the Jacobian. The resulting expression is monotonic with the rate and can be evaluated in the transform domain. Simulations with AVC show that our approach provides bit-rate savings while preserving accuracy in downstream tasks with less complexity than using the feature distance directly.
Read more8/14/2024