Translating Subgraphs to Nodes Makes Simple GNNs Strong and Efficient for Subgraph Representation Learning

Read original: arXiv:2204.04510 - Published 5/24/2024 by Dongkwan Kim, Alice Oh

🚀

Overview

Subgraph representation learning is an important problem in graph neural networks (GNNs)
Existing approaches use specialized GNNs on large global graphs, which require extensive memory and computation
This paper proposes a novel "Subgraph-To-Node (S2N) translation" approach to learn subgraph representations

Plain English Explanation

Graphs are a way of representing relationships between objects or entities. In many real-world applications, these graphs can be very large and complex, with hierarchical structures of smaller "subgraphs" within them. Subgraph pooling and multi-view subgraph neural networks are examples of techniques that try to capture these subgraph structures.

However, the current state-of-the-art approaches use specialized GNN models that require a lot of memory and computing power to process the entire large graph. This makes it challenging to model the hierarchical structure of the subgraphs.

The key idea of this paper is to take a different approach. Instead of working with the entire large graph, the researchers propose to construct a new, simpler graph by "coarsely transforming" the subgraphs into nodes. This "Subgraph-To-Node (S2N) translation" method significantly reduces the memory and computation required, while still capturing both the local and global structures of the subgraphs.

By leveraging graph coarsening techniques, the S2N approach can even outperform the existing methods in situations where there is limited data available for the subgraphs. This makes it a promising approach for real-world applications where data may be scarce.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a novel "Subgraph-To-Node (S2N) translation" formulation for learning representations of subgraphs. The key steps are:

Given a set of subgraphs in the global graph, construct a new graph by coarsely transforming the subgraphs into nodes.
Apply graph neural network models to this new, simplified graph to learn the representations of the subgraph nodes.

This approach has several advantages over the state-of-the-art specialized GNN models:

Reduced memory and computational cost: By working with the coarsened graph instead of the entire large graph, the S2N method requires significantly less memory and computation.
Improved modeling of hierarchical structures: The coarsening process helps capture both the local and global structures of the subgraphs, which is challenging for the existing models.

The paper provides both theoretical and empirical evidence to support the effectiveness of the S2N approach. Experiments on eight benchmark datasets show that the S2N method can process 183 to 711 times more subgraph samples than the state-of-the-art models, while achieving better or similar performance.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising new approach for learning subgraph representations, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

The paper focuses on the overall effectiveness of the S2N method, but does not provide a detailed analysis of the types of subgraph structures it can effectively model. Improving interpretability of GNN predictions could shed light on this.
The experiments are conducted on a limited set of benchmark datasets. It would be valuable to evaluate the S2N approach on a wider range of real-world applications, especially those with diverse subgraph structures and data availability.
The paper does not explore the potential trade-offs between the computational efficiency of the S2N method and the expressiveness of the learned subgraph representations. Further research is needed to understand these trade-offs and how they might impact downstream tasks.

Overall, the S2N translation approach is a significant contribution to the field of subgraph representation learning, and the results suggest it could be a valuable tool for a variety of graph-based applications. However, as with any new technique, additional research and validation will be needed to fully understand its strengths, limitations, and best practices for deployment.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel "Subgraph-To-Node (S2N) translation" approach for learning representations of subgraphs within large, complex graphs. By coarsely transforming the subgraphs into a simplified graph, the S2N method significantly reduces the memory and computational resources required, while still capturing both the local and global structures of the subgraphs.

The key innovation is the shift away from the traditional approach of using specialized GNN models on the entire large graph. The S2N method's ability to outperform state-of-the-art models, especially in data-scarce scenarios, makes it a promising technique for a wide range of real-world graph-based applications. As the field of graph representation learning continues to evolve, the S2N translation approach could be an important step forward in our understanding and modeling of hierarchical subgraph structures.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🚀

Translating Subgraphs to Nodes Makes Simple GNNs Strong and Efficient for Subgraph Representation Learning

Dongkwan Kim, Alice Oh

Subgraph representation learning has emerged as an important problem, but it is by default approached with specialized graph neural networks on a large global graph. These models demand extensive memory and computational resources but challenge modeling hierarchical structures of subgraphs. In this paper, we propose Subgraph-To-Node (S2N) translation, a novel formulation for learning representations of subgraphs. Specifically, given a set of subgraphs in the global graph, we construct a new graph by coarsely transforming subgraphs into nodes. Demonstrating both theoretical and empirical evidence, S2N not only significantly reduces memory and computational costs compared to state-of-the-art models but also outperforms them by capturing both local and global structures of the subgraph. By leveraging graph coarsening methods, our method outperforms baselines even in a data-scarce setting with insufficient subgraphs. Our experiments on eight benchmarks demonstrate that fined-tuned models with S2N translation can process 183 -- 711 times more subgraph samples than state-of-the-art models at a better or similar performance level.

5/24/2024

A Flexible, Equivariant Framework for Subgraph GNNs via Graph Products and Graph Coarsening

Guy Bar-Shalom, Yam Eitan, Fabrizio Frasca, Haggai Maron

Subgraph Graph Neural Networks (Subgraph GNNs) enhance the expressivity of message-passing GNNs by representing graphs as sets of subgraphs. They have shown impressive performance on several tasks, but their complexity limits applications to larger graphs. Previous approaches suggested processing only subsets of subgraphs, selected either randomly or via learnable sampling. However, they make suboptimal subgraph selections or can only cope with very small subset sizes, inevitably incurring performance degradation. This paper introduces a new Subgraph GNNs framework to address these issues. We employ a graph coarsening function to cluster nodes into super-nodes with induced connectivity. The product between the coarsened and the original graph reveals an implicit structure whereby subgraphs are associated with specific sets of nodes. By running generalized message-passing on such graph product, our method effectively implements an efficient, yet powerful Subgraph GNN. Controlling the coarsening function enables meaningful selection of any number of subgraphs while, contrary to previous methods, being fully compatible with standard training techniques. Notably, we discover that the resulting node feature tensor exhibits new, unexplored permutation symmetries. We leverage this structure, characterize the associated linear equivariant layers and incorporate them into the layers of our Subgraph GNN architecture. Extensive experiments on multiple graph learning benchmarks demonstrate that our method is significantly more flexible than previous approaches, as it can seamlessly handle any number of subgraphs, while consistently outperforming baseline approaches.

8/23/2024

Subgraph Clustering and Atom Learning for Improved Image Classification

Aryan Singh, Pepijn Van de Ven, Ciar'an Eising, Patrick Denny

In this study, we present the Graph Sub-Graph Network (GSN), a novel hybrid image classification model merging the strengths of Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) for feature extraction and Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) for structural modeling. GSN employs k-means clustering to group graph nodes into clusters, facilitating the creation of subgraphs. These subgraphs are then utilized to learn representative `atoms` for dictionary learning, enabling the identification of sparse, class-distinguishable features. This integrated approach is particularly relevant in domains like medical imaging, where discerning subtle feature differences is crucial for accurate classification. To evaluate the performance of our proposed GSN, we conducted experiments on benchmark datasets, including PascalVOC and HAM10000. Our results demonstrate the efficacy of our model in optimizing dictionary configurations across varied classes, which contributes to its effectiveness in medical classification tasks. This performance enhancement is primarily attributed to the integration of CNNs, GNNs, and graph learning techniques, which collectively improve the handling of datasets with limited labeled examples. Specifically, our experiments show that the model achieves a higher accuracy on benchmark datasets such as Pascal VOC and HAM10000 compared to conventional CNN approaches.

7/23/2024

📶

An Efficient Subgraph GNN with Provable Substructure Counting Power

Zuoyu Yan, Junru Zhou, Liangcai Gao, Zhi Tang, Muhan Zhang

We investigate the enhancement of graph neural networks' (GNNs) representation power through their ability in substructure counting. Recent advances have seen the adoption of subgraph GNNs, which partition an input graph into numerous subgraphs, subsequently applying GNNs to each to augment the graph's overall representation. Despite their ability to identify various substructures, subgraph GNNs are hindered by significant computational and memory costs. In this paper, we tackle a critical question: Is it possible for GNNs to count substructures both textbf{efficiently} and textbf{provably}? Our approach begins with a theoretical demonstration that the distance to rooted nodes in subgraphs is key to boosting the counting power of subgraph GNNs. To avoid the need for repetitively applying GNN across all subgraphs, we introduce precomputed structural embeddings that encapsulate this crucial distance information. Experiments validate that our proposed model retains the counting power of subgraph GNNs while achieving significantly faster performance.

6/14/2024